Cindy looked disappointed but just kept moving her waist and rubbing against him. When he uncovered her mouth for a moment she started moaning again. Frowning, he grabbed the paper bag he had set on the coffee table and retrieved something from inside. She stopped moving at the sight of a large blue plastic phallus, at least as big as Jaden’s if not bigger. “What are you doing with that?” she muttered.
“I brought some toys this time,” he explained.
“You don’t think that will fit in my peehole, do you?” she was slightly terrified.
“You have other holes,” he reminded her.
She instinctively covered her butt. After a moment of thought, she opened her mouth, willingly offering it to him. It was the hole she thought would hurt the least and if he was determined to penetrate her, she wanted to at least decide where. He grinned as she seemed to be thinking the same thing he was. Without warning or lubrication, he shoved the tip of the dildo into her mouth, effectively stopping her moaning.
She tried to swallow but found it impossible. The dildo was too large and just stretched her jaw. Jaden held the back of her head with one hand and pressed the dildo with the other one, sliding it into her mouth and eventually the back of her throat. Her eyes were wide with concern. Saliva dripped out of the corners of her mouth as she could not close it.
Satisfied she was gagged and could no longer draw Kayla’s attention; he returned one of his hands to her crotch and began to fiddle with her pussy and clit. She winced and whimpered but was too busy trying not to choke to really get into the feeling of having her pussy touched. She had stopped all of her own attempts to feel his cock through his pants too.
Eventually, Jaden lost interest in just touching Cindy. He opened the bag again and produced a fist full of what looking like plastic eggs to her. He set them in the crevice of the couch and then picked one of them to press against her wet cunt. She squealed as it was forced past the opening. It was almost too big, but the rounded shape allowed her cunt to open and then close around it.
He repeated this 5 more times until she had all 6 inside her. When he looked at her face he found her eyes completely white and drool running down her chin. There was a remote in the bag that would make the eggs vibrate inside her. He was about to retrieve it when he heard a noise from the kitchen. Kayla had just taken a pot off the stove. “It’s ready, but hot,” she called when she saw him looking. “We can watch the end of whatever’s on before we eat.”
Jaden quickly grabbed the end of the dildo in Cindy’s mouth and twisted it, as if trying to unscrew it from her throat. She wretched and spit it up with his assistance, pulling it out. He only just managed to return it to the bag and push Cindy off his lap when Kayla entered the living room. She sat on the couch on his left side since Cindy was on his right. She leaned against him and rested her head on his shoulder. Jaden only just realized the TV had been on this whole time. He sighed with relief when he saw Cindy pretending to watch as well. Somehow they had not gotten caught.
—————————————————————————————————————————————————————-
After the show on the TV ended, the 3 of them went to the kitchen to eat. Cindy did a good job of pretending her cunt was not full of plastic eggs, but Jaden could tell she was walking with a limp.
After eating, the 3 of them returned to the couch and put on a DVD Jaden had brought. It was part of their date. While having Cindy leave them alone to cuddle would have been preferable, Kayla did not push too hard. She wanted to appear like a caring older sister, hoping she could win Jaden over that way as well.
Having woken up early to practice cooking, and having spent all afternoon in front of the stove, it was hard on Kayla to stay awake for the movie. Halfway through, she leaned on the far armrest and began to snore softly.
Jaden pretended to try waking her while actually making sure she was deep enough asleep that any noise would not bother her. As soon as he was positive, he reached to his other side and began touching Cindy’s crotch. She had been focused on the movie and not realized Kayla was asleep. She panicked and covered her mouth at first but sighed with relief when she looked past him as saw her sister asleep.
She let him finger her and fondle her breasts for a while before he finally just pulled her up into his lap. She finally felt the warmth of his exposed cock touching her from below. The tip pressed her cunt and made her moan, but it could not fit inside, not while she was stuffed with plastic eggs.
She expected Jaden to try removing them and she even tried helping expel them by clenching her abdomen. However, Jaden instead went back to his bag of items. He produced the blue dildo again and shoved it against her tight cunt, spreading the eggs apart to make room for the hard object. Before supper she might have been able to stand it but having just eaten she was on the verge of puking.
Jaden ignored her clutching her stomach and instead retrieved a small tube of lubrication from his bag. He spread some on the tip of his cock and then the rest in-between her butt cheeks. It took her only a moment to realize what he was planning. She twisted her head as much as she could to look at his face. Her mouth was quivering as she tried not to throw up. Drool was leaking from her lips as her body prepared to protect itself from the potential bile.
With one thrust, Jaden’s lubricated cock slid into Cindy’s puckered asshole, stretching it and making her wheeze. She was winded and did nothing to maintain her balance on his lap, almost trying to fall off. He grabbed her pigtails, causing her to straighten her neck and face forward. With her hair as handles he began to thrust into her butt, pushing her forward off his lap, and then pulling her back onto him.
Cindy could do nothing but cover her mouth to keep from throwing up as her bowels were stretched and filled alongside her pussy. She could not help but realize that if he had his chopstick with him he could have filled a 3rd hole with a 9th object.
“Are you alright?” Jaden had expected her to be more vocal about getting fucked in her ass. Her only response to his question was to shake her head. “Come on, it can’t be that bad. You’ve had worse things shoved in your bladder.” He refused to acknowledge her discomfort.
Eventually Cindy could not keep her stomach from turning. She leaned forward and pulled the dildo out of her cunt just in time to push it into her mouth to block the bile rising in her throat. Jaden recognized the sound and stood up. He rushed to the kitchen to let her puke in the sink but just then he saw Kayla stirring. Rather than the noise, the movement of them leaving the couch had disturbed her.
He quickly ran out the back door, still holding Cindy against his chest. He set her down in a bush and pulled his cock out of her butt. She keeled over and puked the dildo and her dinner out onto the ground. Jaden could not see her face as it had gotten dark out, but he knew she must look like a mess. How they planned to get back inside without Kayla being suspicious was a mystery to him. The only option he could think of was to leave Cindy alone outside so that they could re-enter at different times and hopefully not be too suspicious.