Eventually, Jenny came down from her orgasmic high, and I felt her anal sphincter muscles lighten up around my dick-shaft.
“I’ve never seen you cum so hard before. Why does this turn you on so much?” I asked as I felt myself getting closer and closer to my own orgasm and sperm-release.
“You’ve got to understand something. When I told you in the bathroom at Wendy’s that I was virgin, I wasn’t lying to you, because in the past I had used God’s loophole with my ex-boyfriends.”
“God’s loophole?” I asked, not ever having heard that terminology before.
“I’m not surprised. You’re quite a bit older than me, remember?”
“Hey! You don’t have to rub it in.”
“But yes, whenever a girl insists that her boyfriend fuck her in the ass, instead of her pussy, she’s using what all my girlfriends call ‘God’s loophole.’ And by the girl choosing to do that, her boyfriend at the time is happy, because he gets his rocks off inside his girlfriend by pretending that her rectum is her vagina. And of course, the girl is happy too, because she gets to technically keep her virginity intact, since a girl ‘losing her virginity’ is specifically defined as that girl having a guy’s erect penis inserted up into her vagina. So it’s a win/win scenario for both people.
“By the way, the girl who’s getting butt-fucked should be lying on her back, just like I am, during the anal intercourse with her boyfriend, so that the excess sperm doesn’t ooze out of her asshole and flow down into her pussy, thanks to gravity. That way there is the added benefit that the girl doesn’t ever have to worry about getting pregnant–just as long as the guy cums inside her rectum, instead of pulling out at the last minute and cumming in her pussy.”
“Like this, you mean?” I asked, as I quickly pulled my dick out of Jenny’s butt-hole, and used my hips to shift the head of it slightly upward, and then intentionally slid the head of my penis up into her wet vaginal entrance just a split second before I began orgasming, and instinctively shoved my pulsating dick deep inside Jenny’s baby-making hole, so that the head of my dick was pressed up against her cervix.
“God damn it! What the fuck are you doing, Carl?” Jenny chided me, obviously very concerned about my actions, as she began violently wriggling around underneath me, obviously trying to pull her vagina up off of my skewering penis.
My instinctive response to that was to double down, as I quickly placed a hand on each side of Jenny’s hips and used all the strength I had to hold her lower body and pelvic region in place, so that no matter how hard she tried, she wasn’t able to escape my fully-inserted, ejaculating penis.
“God damn it, Carl!” Jenny said with her voice shaking badly, as she finally stopped struggling underneath me and accepted her fate.
And with seconds, I felt her vagina start repeatedly contracting around the shaft of my dick, as she was squirting little spurts of her urine-like cum-juice all over my dick and balls.
Afterwards, I realized that Jenny was in tears and openly crying when she asked me, “Do you realize what you’ve just done?”
“Yeah, I just fucked you in the ass, and then I came in your pussy. What’s the big deal?” I asked, as I finally pulled my dick out of her baby-making hole. “You acted like I was raping you, or something.”
“‘The big deal’ is that a guy should never do that to a girl, because you just stuck your dick up into my vagina and my womb, without stopping to clean off my fecal matter from your dick first. I could get a serious infection from that kind of stuff. One that could eventually cause me to get a hysterectomy, and keep me from ever being able to get pregnant and have kids.
“I tried to pull my pussy up off of your dick. But then you held me down and raped me!
“The worst part was that I orgasmed my ass off while you were doing it. That’s why I stopped struggling. I guess I must just be one sick puppy to actually enjoy getting held down and raped like that by your shit-covered dick.”
“I’m sorry, okay?” I said to her, now that I realized that I had really scared her badly. “I didn’t mean to rape you like that. What can I do to make it up to you.”
“The next time you rape me–and knowing how you men are, I’m sure there will be a next time–just don’t do it with a shit-covered dick, okay? Is that too much to ask?”
“No, of course not. I’m sorry I hurt you, Jenny. I didn’t mean to. But when you were trying to pull away, I was already on the verge of orgasming and not exactly thinking clearly. I didn’t even realize that I was raping you, until after you stopped struggling underneath me and began crying. But by that time, my dick was already ejaculating sperm inside you, and it was too late for me to stop. That’s the honest-to-God truth,” I told Jenny, lying to her face.
Of course, the real truth of the matter was that I knew that I was raping Jenny, from the very first moment that she began struggling underneath me, and I was forced to quickly pin her down underneath me in order to complete the unwanted-on-her-part sexual intercourse. Intentionally shifting gears, and raping Jenny like that, once she began putting up resistance to my pussy-fucking, only served to make the whole sexual act that much more exciting and taboo for me than it already was. And as a direct result, I ended up orgasming my ass off while I was cumming inside Jenny’s pussy, and forcing her to take my sperm into her womb against her will.
“Yeah, we humans do some pretty fucked-up stuff, don’t we?” Jenny remarked, trying to lighten up the situation. “I’m just scared right now. That’s all. I mean, I hope I don’t get some sort of weird vaginal e-coli infection, or something, because of what you just finished doing to me.”
“Once again, I’m so sorry. I can’t apologize enough. I didn’t know that what I was doing was so dangerous for your pussy, or I would’ve never done it. I promise you that. I would’ve went ahead and ejaculated inside your poop chute instead, just like you were obviously wanting me to do,” I said to Jenny, lying to her face once again.
The truth was that, from the moment that I had penetrated her rectum and had begun fucking Jenny in the ass, I had already decided in my head that I was going to pull out of Jenny’s rectum when I felt myself getting close to orgasming, so that I could shove my dick up into her vagina and let myself cum inside it.
I mean, even though it was definitely exciting for me to be thrusting my dick in and out of Jenny’s ass-hole, butt-fucking her like that, the last thing I felt like doing was releasing my sperm inside her rectum. No, sir. To my way of thinking, there’s no such thing as an acceptable “pussy-substitute” when it comes to ejaculating sperm during sexual intercourse with a woman.
And while I was mulling over in my mind the two flat-out lies that I had just finished telling Jenny, Sofia, the middle-age Hispanic neighbor from across the street, unexpectedly sauntered into the bedroom. She was already buck-naked, as she plopped herself down on her back on top of the bed–right beside Jenny and me–and she spread her legs apart a little bit as she reached down into her own bare crotch and began slowly fingering her clit with the tip of her middle finger, using a small circular motion, while she announced, “I’m next.”