He laid on his back while she crawled on top of his waist. Though it was dark, he could see her cunt glistening above him. He undid his cargo shorts and let his cock spring up between her legs. Lily looked confused as he tried to lower her down onto it. She expected him to go for her asshole as her father always did, but instead he pushed the head toward her cunt. “Stop,” she grunted.
“Does it hurt?” he was cautious.
“I don’t know. It feels weird.” She pulled on her cunt to open it a little. “Will it fit? I had the stick from the mower in there yesterday but it’s smaller than you are.”
“You lost your virginity to a stick?” Mr. Richards was confused and a little disappointed.
“I don’t know what that is,” Lily admitted.
He just sighed while pulling her down further. “It’s okay. My stick bends and squishes,” he assured her. She winced as he forced his hard cock head past her cunt lips. Her vision went white for a moment when it popped inside, which was disorienting in the dark shed. She let him keep pulling her down by her waist until she could reach his hands which she grabbed hold of.
He thought she looked cute trying to grip onto anything and he lifted his head off the mat to kiss her. She was used to Max kissing her but he never did it for long, just enough to keep her voice down. Mr. Richards plunged his tongue into her mouth and swirled it around. She was reminded of the times he and Max had forced their cocks past her lips and wondered why they did not do it this way instead. It made more sense to put their privates in her privates and their mouths in her mouth. She did not understand why they would enjoy doing it any other way.
It took a while for Lily to sink all the way down onto Mr. Richards’s cock, but when she finally did, he immediately pulled her back up. She thought he was trying to get her off of him so she stood up completely, pulling his cock out of her. He was confused and disappointed so he pushed her down onto her back and plunged back into her from between her legs. She gasped and covered her face.
It felt much stranger than when Max tried to push into her asshole too quickly. It did not fold inside out and did not hit any bends. She was starting to realize that her pussy was the hole for sex while her father was weirdly obsessed with her anus.
While thinking of the difference between the two of them and how much slower Mr. Richards was, Lily accidentally spoke out loud. “Daddy, harder.” She immediately covered her mouth with her hands but Mr. Richards already got the message. Compared to the stick she’d had up her cunt yesterday, he was less stimulating. He had to pick up the pace, even at the risk of hurting her.
She gasped when she felt him bucking his hips against her. His cock slid further up inside her and caused her tiny cunt to spread. Obviously it could not reach her cervix like the mower gear, but it was fatter and was touching all the walls, which overloaded her senses.
She gripped his shoulders and tried not to be pushed up on the mat by the force of his groin hitting hers. When he pulled back, she felt his cock leaving her cunt and felt extremely empty, like he had stretched her and shaped her insides. It was not the same as her bowels that returned to normal after being straightened by Max’s cock. It was more like her anus which always remained gaping for hours after Max was done with her.
Again Lily accidentally let slip what was on her mind. “Daddy always fills my butt,” she moaned. “What would getting stuffed in 2 holes feel like.”
“Sorry I don’t have 2 dicks,” Mr. Richards groaned in her ear. Wanting to satisfy her though, he reached below his cock and pushed his fingers into the tight ring of her anus. Lily’s eyes bulged and she immediately began to squirm. She tried to push him away by the chest enough to look down her own front. She could not see her butt as he was in the way and instead resorted to grabbing her own hair and rolling her head around deliriously.
Thinking he was doing something right, Mr. Richards continued to plunge his fingers into her asshole. He pushed four of them inside and pried it apart. Lily could feel cold air rushing inside her. She could not beg him to stop after having been the one to suggest it. Instead she just covered her eyes to hide her tears.
Mr. Richards pulled his cock out of her cunt and lifted her butt off the mat by her anus alone. With only her shoulders touching the mat, he spat a glob of saliva into the gaping hole and then pushed his cock inside, straight down like a piston. Lily shrieked as her asshole was stretched to the limit; four fingers and an adult man’s cock.
“Daddy please,” she finally begged for mercy, despite not actually saying the word stop. Mr. Richards did not seem to notice and only removed his fingers from her asshole in order to pull her up into his arms. Her whole body swung upward as he pulled on her waist. She had to grab onto his shoulders to keep from falling back down.
He finally noticed the tears streaking her face and could think of nothing else to do but to kiss her. It was sloppy and wet but somehow the most he had ever been into kissing a girl. She wrapped her legs around his waist to keep from sliding down. Her asshole was still wrapped around his cock, though it felt loose without his fingers prying her apart.
Finally realizing he had done something wrong, Mr. Richards lifted her enough to slide his cock out of her asshole and back into her cunt. She sighed with relief, letting her head hang backwards and roll around on her shoulders.
He walked over to the wall of the shed and pressed her against it so he could get deeper into her cunt. She made noise with each thrust but was probably not going to scream again unless he messed with her asshole more.
Unsurprisingly as this was the youngest and tightest cunt he had ever fucked, Mr. Richards was on the verge of orgasm after only a few thrusts. Not knowing if she even could and not wanting Lily to get pregnant, he pulled out and dropped her to the ground. Her legs were too far apart for her to stay standing and she hit her knees a moment later.
She had little time to complain as a spurt of cum hit her in the face. She tried to put her mouth over his cock but when the second spurt went into her throat, she had to turn and vomit immediately. The next 2 spurts hit her cheek and eye, gluing her eyelashes down and causing her to keep one eye shut.
“What a mess.” She shook her hands as if she could get the cum off of them like water. She resorted to wiping them on the underside of her skirt which was still around her belly. Mr. Richards stood there panting and looking at the cute naked girl coated in his cum, proud of himself instead of guilty like before. “What about my badges,” she brought him back from his bliss.
Annoyed he retrieved his shorts and took out a badge for her. It was the only next level badge he had on him at the time so 1 would have to do. He was shocked when she pushed the pin through the skin of her other breast and thrust her chest out proudly to show it off. He shook his head in disbelief. He had taught this once innocent girl to degrade herself.