As I slowly moved in and out of her, I made a show of thinking it over, but I knew it had to be true.
“Yeah, you did that.” She looked back, grinning and I kissed her hard, then whispered into her ear, “You slut!”
She laughed, a soft tinkling sound and reached back, pulling me to her.
“So what happened then? Did you go out with this guy?” I grunted as we moved together.
Kim shook her head and moaned, then kissed me.
“We never… uh… went out…”
I grinned and fucked her slowly. “That’s too bad.”
“Ah, it was okay. Turns out, he got the bitch pregnant a few months later, and they had to get married. I never did hear what happened to them after that.”
“Did his girlfriend ever find out about what you guys did in the gazebo?”
Kim shook her head. I pulled out of her and had her lie flat. I climbed over and settled between her spread knees, my dick sliding back inside her.
Her head bobbed against the pillow in time with my thrusts. “I don’t… ah… think so.”
We made love slowly, our bodies moving together as one. Then I remembered something from her story.
“Hey, you mentioned that you weren’t on birth control when you did that guy.”
Her hands pulled me close and her legs wrapped behind my ass as I continued to push as far into her as I could each time.
“Yeah,” she gasped, “I was actually late that month, and it scared me.”
I slowed and looked into her eyes.
She shook her head. “No, I wasn’t pregnant. My period came a few days late. I don’t know why.” I sped up. “But I went on the pill after that.”
My balls tingled, and I loved knowing she was safe and I could cum in her as much as I wanted. And man, did I want to.
I arched my back, changing the angle of my penetration. It put more pressure on her clit, and she responded. We moved, and after a few more minutes, she called out and came. I was right behind her, shooting deep into her.
We caught our breath as we lay side by side, grinning at each other.
“That was amazing,” she said and rolled over to press against me.
I wrapped her up in my arms and kissed her. “It was. I love hearing about things you did before I met you.”
She nuzzled my chest and settled in. “I have to admit, I did too. It surprised me.”
After a moment, she looked over at me, grinned. “Oh! I forgot one other thing about that.”
“What?”
“Remember I told you we ended up on the wooden floor as he was pounding me?”
My dick twitched from the way she said that, and the mental image it created. “Yeah.”
She giggled like a little girl. “I got a splinter!”
“Wait! Where?”
“On my ass!” She laughed and wiped a tear from her eye.
“Oh, shit!”
“Yeah, I had to ask my mom to get it out because it got infected.” She could barely talk from laughing.
“What did you tell her?”
“I made up some story about sitting down on the deck, or something. It hurt like hell for a week!”
“That’s what you get for fucking some guy when his girlfriend is looking for him.”
“Oh, and fucking your girlfriend’s sister in the backseat when she’s passed out in the front is alright?”
I shook my head. “Nope, it was totally wrong. But damn, it felt incredible.”
Kim slapped my arm and kissed me.
“I can’t wait to hear something really raunchy next time.” I nuzzled the top of her head.
“Be careful what you wish for!” I could feel her giggling as we held each other, our bodies nestled together as we kissed.