Vanessa's Choice by technowhimsey,technowhimsey

I said, “‘Accusations’. That’s an interesting word to use. Did she accuse somebody of something?”

Vanessa snorted. “Only all the time. Even my poor dad. Or maybe especially him.”

“Would you please elaborate on that?”

She hesitated. I could tell from her body language that I’d hit a very sore spot. She remained silent and tense. I looked at the clock and decided we’d done enough for one session. “I tell you what. We’re nearly at the end of the hour, so let’s stop there. I’d like to see you at least once a week for a while. Will that be convenient?”

She nodded. I asked, “Will the same day and time be convenient?”

She glanced at me and then lowered her eyes and turned them to the left, a sure sign that she was about to lie. Without looking at me, she said, “I usually spend Tuesday afternoons playing tennis. Do you have any openings on Wednesdays?”

A child would have known she was lying, but I decided not to press. We all lie occasionally, and psychiatric patients more than most. We agreed on Wednesdays at two. She put on her shoes and walked toward the door. I couldn’t help but admire her derriere. It moved delightfully from side to side and her stockings swished as her thighs rubbed together. I licked my lips.

She put her hand on the door knob but didn’t open it. She half-turned and looked back at me.

“Thank you, Sue. I feel good about coming in to see you. You’re right. I believe I can talk to you. I trust you. Maybe more than anybody else in the world. See you next week.”

She left before I could respond, which was a good thing. Just as when she nodded her tear-stained face at me like a little girl, her words and the expression on her face smote my heart and I felt like crying myself.

Session 02

When I let my one o’clock out the door the following Wednesday I found Vanessa sitting patiently in the waiting room. She was dressed in khaki shorts, a light blue cotton blouse, and high-heeled cork-bottomed sandals. She carried a straw purse and matching wide-brimmed hat.

I smiled and said, “Please come in.”

“Thanks, Sue.”

“You look a lot more casual today. Been out having fun?”

Vanessa lowered her gaze and looked left. I waited for another lie. “No, not really. I feel more comfortable now, you know, less formal. Is it okay?”

“Of course. I’m here to do whatever is best for you, whatever it takes. Besides, you look exceptionally pretty in those clothes, THE All-American Girl.”

She blushed and took my hand, briefly, and then let it drop while she walked into the office. She sat on the couch, took off her shoes, and lay down while I dimmed the lights. I turned on the tape recorder, picked up my pad, and took my accustomed place at the head of the couch. I breathed deep and said, “Last week we stopped at the point of your mother accusing your father of something. The incident clearly upset you so we quit. If you feel up to it, I’d like to start there.”

Vanessa answered, “Okay. Well, you know, I really loved my dad. He showed me a lot of attention. You know how all some men do when they’re not at work is sit and watch TV? Especially sports. I’ve been to several ball games, baseball, football, and basketball. It’s fun to sit in a crowd and cheer and eat hot dogs and drink beer, you know, exciting. You get caught up in the moment with all the energy of the people around you. But watching it on TV? For three hours? And I’d bet most of the men doing that never put on pads or cleats and walked out onto the field. Just a bunch of silly wannabes.

“Well my dad wasn’t like that. He would often have a game on. Sometimes I’d watch it with him, especially baseball. Even then he paid attention to me. He told me all about the rules and what kind of plays might be made and then explained the action we were watching. But if I got bored and asked him to read me a book or something, he always got up and turned the TV off and took whatever book I gave him. I loved ‘Green Eggs and Ham.’ He read it to me even though I had heard it so many times I recited the words along with him. And we built Lincoln Log buildings and put together jigsaw puzzles and played Go Fish. And he always put me to bed with a hug and a kiss and called me his ‘Darlin’ Girl’. He would probably have put that on my birth certificate if my mother would’ve let him.”

Her voice cracked and she began to sniff. I put the box of tissues within her reach. She blew her nose and continued. “Momma never did anything like that. She stayed busy cleaning up the kitchen after dinner or doing something else.”

She remained silent for several moments. To get her started again, I asked, “It sounds as if you have many fond memories of your father, is that right.” After she nodded, I asked, “Do you have any similarly fond memories of your mother?”

Vanessa’s voice tightened. “Hell no. It was always, ‘You oughta know better. Stop that. Shut up. Can’t you see I’m busy? Christ, I wished I’d never had kids.’ And shit like that. My earliest memories involving her are about trying to hide from her. I was always afraid.”

“Did your mother ever strike you?”

Vanessa shrugged. “Maybe a few times, you know, a slap or two here and there. Nothing major. She never hit me with a belt or a switch. Her damn sour mouth was enough to keep me in line.”

“That’s a pretty grim picture. Why do you think she behaved that way toward you?”

“Not just toward me. Toward Daddy, too, and some in her family. I saw her own mother, my grandma, acting the same way. I guess Momma was just mean and unhappy and hateful. No other way to explain it.”

I lowered my voice. “Do you think she was ever abused by your grandmother, the way she abused you?”

Vanessa got angry. “What the fuck difference does it make if she was? You think that’s an excuse? Look at the way she treated me and I’m not like that. I try my best to treat people well and do things that please them.”

I noted the phrase “pleasing other people” for future reference. “I’m sure you do. And no, I’m not trying to excuse your mother’s behavior, just understand it.”

“Well, don’t waste your time. I hate her, I have nothing to do with her, and I won’t miss her when she’s dead. Hell, she may already be dead for all I know and good riddance to her. She killed Daddy.”

I had to tread very lightly here. “Would you care to explain that, please? What do you mean she killed your father?”

Silence.

“Vanessa, did it have anything to do with your use of the word ‘accusation’ last week?”

More silence.

“Please, Vanessa, if I’m going to help you, I need to know. What did you mean? Whom did your mother accuse and of what?”

I’d said all that I could. I got up and sat opposite her as I had done the week before. Her shoulders shook and tears streamed down her face. She wore no makeup. I assumed she anticipated she might cry during the session and didn’t want to be seen with a smeared face. She was clearly suffering. I wanted to put my arms around her and try to make the pain go away.

Some counselors do that, but never a psychiatrist. It’s not within the clinical guidelines. And besides, I felt a strong physical attraction to her as well as an emotional one, straining my capacity to remain emotionally detached. Putting my hands on her lovely body would destroy any chance I had to help her, and I was desperate to save her. I mean that literally. I deemed her suffering so acute that she might attempt suicide. I sat and waited and said nothing more, fully intending to remain silent for the rest of the hour if necessary. I had shown her the road, but she had to walk down it on her own.

Leave a Comment