I was more than on board, quickly grabbing the bottle of jelly lube for us.
I stretched Brooke’s pussy wide so Hope could shove as much of the bottle inside Brooke as possible. Hope then did the same, allowing me to shove the bottle well past its neck, deep into Brooke’s anus. Hope and I pumped the bottles fast and hard into Brooke. We showed her no mercy as she squirmed and whimpered under our aggressive thrusts. Having never been drunk, Brooke was in no state to deny us entry to her virgin holes.
Next, Hope pushed her ring and middle fingers around the bottle in Brooke’s ass. As she stretched her I pulled the bottle out leaving her formally tight rosebud gaped wide open. I immediately dove into her devouring her insides. I lapped every inch of her walls before finishing her off with my tongue circling her rim.
Hope said she wanted a turn so we switched positions. I now held Brooke’s gape open while Hope tongue fucked her. Hope jokingly said her tongue was tired. She went on to stroke Brooke’s pussy lips, slipping her fingers inside and covering them in cum.
While I kept Brooke stretched open, Hope explored the depths of Brooke’s ass. She had her four fingers pressed together in the void of Brooke’s gape. I was instructed to remove my fingers so she could feel Brooke clench around her. Hope wiggled her fingers, enjoying the warmth around them before giving her ass a final, violent finger fuck. She made sure her tight virgin hole would never be the same again.
Hope went on to say it was time for more pussy play. It dawned on us that four fingers were just as wide as the base of the hypnotic bottle. We figured if four fingers fit up her ass then filling her cunt with the bigger bottle should be no problem. We took turns finger fucking Brooke. I had my four fingers buried deep in her stretching them apart as wide as a could. After stretching her as much as I could I told Hope to get the bottle, she was ready to go.
I used my other hand to pull one side of her pussy open then quickly slipped my fingers up and out of the way while keeping her spread. In an instant Hope shoved the bottle deep into Brooke’s pussy. She held it buried deep inside her, letting her pussy fully stretch around it. She started slowly pulling the bottle out then slowly pushing it back in. She did this little by little, pushing and pulling until she almost completely pulled out. When the bottom of the bottle was just about to slip out of Brooke, Hope rammed it back in her hard and fast. I thought for sure Brooke was going to wake up, but our innocent, lightweight hardly even squirmed under us.
Brooke continued breaking in her pussy like this for a bit. She asked me to hold Brooke’s pussy open. Hope took the bottle out and dove face first into the deepest, pink pussy gape I had ever seen. She finished her off by spitting inside her then slamming the bottle right back in her. I was still holding Brooke open when Hope pulled the bottle out, quickly replacing it with her fingers. She instructed me to let go of Brooke’s pussy. I sat back watching Brooke slowly clench around Hope’s fingers.
At this point Brooke’s holes were so used, my four fingers slipped right inside her ass. Hope and I worked both her holes, while simultaneously fingering our own cunts. We loved rubbing her inner wall, feeling each other’s fingers through her thin skin.
Hope and I were still pretty horny and ready to get each other off. Hope grabbed two bottles then used one to fill Brooke’s ass again. She went face down into Brooke’s pussy and pushed her ass up while handing me the second bottle. I knew exactly what she wanted. I buried the bottle into her pussy.
As I thrusted her vagina with the bottle I used my tongue to thrust her butt hole. This combination makes Hope burst girl cum all over the bottle and my hand. I pull the bottle out and suck every last sweet drop pouring from her young cunt. Hope said how amazing that was and she had to return the favor.
We switched positions allowing me to drink Brooke’s juices while I pounded her ass. Hope knew me well enough so she slipped the bottle from her pussy and used it to stretch my ass. Sucking Brooke’s ass while Hope pounded my ass was enough to push me over the edge. I soon felt cum dripping from my pussy. Hope was quick to catch it, lapping and sucking me good. She removed the bottle, lapping and sucking my ass until my legs shook.
Hope took the bottle out of Brooke’s ass to throw out along with the others. I wiped up the mess we made of Brooke before covering her up.
Hope and I lay in bed looking at photos and videos we had taken that night. We scrolled through, fingering each other until we drifted off to sleep.
The next morning we all woke up around the same time. Brooke said she couldn’t believe how sore she was from the hangover, that she was even sore between her legs. Hope and I giggled, saying
“What did you except? You asked us to do the same thing that was happening to the girl in the porn you were watching.”
Brooke gasped, a puzzled look washed over her face. She stammered, struggling to explain how she could hardly remember the night before.
I immediately started raving about how fun she was and how she kept asking for more. Hope told her she loved ass play the most and begged for us not to stop. Brooke turned beat red with embarrassment, but Hope and I just told her how hot she was. We told her now that she had her first ass and pussy orgasms, she would crave it. She’d probably end up masturbating at least once a day.
Brooke sat through breakfast very quietly, most likely in a state of shock. Little did she know we were about to give her the shock of a lifetime.
Hope started making plans for another sleepover with the three of us. Brooke timidly said she wasn’t sure if she’d be able to make it. That’s when I took out the compromising photos and videos we had staged of Brooke. Hope told her if she didn’t come to our sleepovers we would release the photos and videos all over school. If that happened she’d never be popular or have a chance with any guy.
Brooke sat there with tears streaming down her face. Yet she somehow muttered the words
“I’ll be here Friday night.”
I stroked her hair and whispered good girl in her ear.
TO BE CONTINUED…