Wine Night with my Exhibitionist Girlfriend – Chapter 7 – by superwriter1337
“Yes, please,” Alyssa said softly.
With that, Alyssa began rubbing her clit again, and Madison began sliding her two fingers in and out of her girlfriend’s ass.
“Oh shit,” Alyssa gasped. “That feels so fucking good.”
“Right??” Madison laughed. “I knew you’d like having your ass played with.”
“You were so right,” Alyssa said. “Fuck me, that’s amazing. Don’t stop!”
Madison continued finger-fucking Alyssa’s ass, which was gripping her fingers tightly. Alyssa’s fingers were a blur on her clit at this point; clearly, she was working her way towards a big orgasm.
I watched as Alyssa instantly became lost in the pleasure of having something in her ass. She rubbed her clit faster and faster as Madison continued finger-fucking her tight little hole. I couldn’t believe I was seeing this. Never did I think I’d have a front-row seat to Madison finger-fucking Alyssa’s ass.
“Fuck, fuck, fuck!” Alyssa gasped. “You can fuck me harder, baby. Finger my ass harder!”
Madison bit her lip and began sliding her fingers in and out of Alyssa’s ass even faster. Alyssa began to moan loudly. Her back was arched, and her toes started to curl. That girl was quickly falling in love with anal. I was surprised. Even Ashley took a little bit of time to warm up to having her asshole played with. But Alyssa was taking a pretty-good fucking from two fingers, despite having never put anything in her ass before tonight.
“I’m gonna come,” Alyssa cried. “Fuck, I’m gonna fucking come!”
“Good lord,” I said under my breath.
“Come for me, baby girl,” Madison cooed. “Come for me, nice and hard.”
Alyssa gasped for breath and arched her back hard. She was rubbing her clit in little circles while Madison finger-fucked her asshole. Ashley and I watched, both of us unbearably horny, as Alyssa enjoyed her first (of many!) orgasms with something in her ass.
Alyssa sighed heavily as her orgasm subsided. Madison slid her fingers out of Alyssa’s ass gently. She got up and went to the bathroom to wash her hands while Alyssa caught her breath.
“So,” Ashley began. “What did you think?”
“That was incredible,” Alyssa breathed. “My orgasm felt amazing. It was so intense.”
“That’s awesome,” I grinned. “But I’m a little surprised that all three of you girls apparently like anal. And I’m shocked you came around to it so quickly, Alyssa.”
“I’m not,” Ashley shrugged. “What’s not to like? It’s hot. It feels great.”
“Girl, even you took longer than that to start liking anal,” I grinned.
“Fair,” Ashley said. “But Alyssa had a room full of experts making sure her first experience with something in her ass was a good one!”
“You know what,” I said, laughing. “You make a good point.”
“I personally just can’t believe we did that,” Alyssa giggled. “Madison really fingered my ass while you guys watched.”
“Well, I didn’t just watch,” Ashley said. “I was totally touching myself that whole time.”
“Oh my God, really?” Alyssa asked, looking up.
“Mhm,” Ashley said. “I haven’t really stopped.” Indeed, Ashley’s hand was still in her panties, and she was clearly still rubbing her clit, albeit fairly slowly.
“You wanna take your panties off?” Alyssa asked. “I’m the only girl sitting here with her pussy out right now.”
“Actually, I pulled my panties down already,” Madison said. She stood up and kicked them off of her feet.
Ashley followed suit. She brought her legs together and quickly pulled her panties off, kicking them down onto the ground. She leaned back a bit and spread her legs so that Alyssa had a good view of her pussy. “Is that better?”
“Much better,” Alyssa said, looking greedily at Ashley’s pussy.
Madison came back from the bathroom and immediately noticed that Ashley was no longer wearing her panties.
“Nice pussy, sis,” Madison giggled.
“Thanks!” Ashley smiled.
Madison sat down on the couch next to Alyssa and spread her legs so the rest of us could get a good look between her thighs.
“Damn,” Ashley said. “I guess having bomb-ass pussies runs in the family.”
Alyssa laughed. “Apparently.”
“Well shit,” I said. “I’m the only one here still wearing underwear”
Ashley laughed, as did Madison.
“That’s a good point,” Alyssa said, biting her lip. “Y’know, I’ve heard an awful lot about that cock of yours, but I’ve never actually gotten a good look at it.”
“Hey, yeah,” Madison said. “Ashley always talks about how much she likes your dick. I think it’s about time we see it.” Okay, Madison. It’s not like you just spent part of the evening having your ass fucked by me and my friend. And we fucked your mouth too, for that matter!
Ashley grinned. “Well Brian?”
Man, I was lucky this was not my first rodeo. Otherwise this big reveal would’ve likely been a bit disappointing for these three ladies. But I was long past being nervous in this type of scenario.
“Alright,” I shrugged. “But if you guys want to see it so badly, why don’t you come over here so you can get a closer look?”
Alyssa and Madison glanced at each other before standing up and walking over. Both girls had a thin strip of hair above their pussies; they looked very sexy walking over here without any panties. Evidently both girls had foregone their bras, judging by how clearly their nipples were poking through their tops. I could even see Madison’s areolas faintly through the fabric of her tank top.
I spread my legs wide, and the two girls got down on their knees in front of me. I was obviously still rock hard given I just watched Alyssa enjoy her first anal encounter, so I was ready to go. I glanced at Madison and gave her a look as I lifted myself up off the seat a bit. She took the hint and grabbed my pants and boxers, gently pulling them down. She brought them down to my ankles, and my cock sprang up, pointing straight towards the ceiling.
“Oh my,” Alyssa managed. Ashley bit her lip and watched her little sister — and her little sister’s girlfriend — take in the sight of my rock-hard cock.
Alyssa stared at it fairly wide-eyed with a mixture of shock, bewilderment, and arousal painted across her face. It had clearly been a little while since she was eye-level with a hard dick. Madison, on the other hand, stared at my cock with only lust in her eyes. She slowly traced her hand up my right thigh, stopping just before touching my cock. Alyssa did the same.
“Can I–”, Alyssa said, turning to look at Ashley. “Can we…?”
“I’d be offended if you didn’t,” Ashley grinned. She was openly masturbating again. One hand was working her clit while she had two fingers from the other buried in her pussy. Alyssa and Madison would both have likely been fixated on that display if it weren’t for the fact that they were eye level with my erection.
I moaned softly as Alyssa wrapped her fingers around the base of my shaft. She just held my cock in her hand like that for a moment, squeezing it softly, enjoying how it felt in her hand. Madison immediately cupped my balls and began to massage them gently. She already knew what I liked.
“Wow,” Alyssa said. She slowly traced her hand up my shaft, stroking my cock gently while Madison continued working my balls. Alyssa traced her thumb around the head, feeling the ridge against her fingers. “You weren’t lying, Ashley.”