Bobby pressed his lips against her slit, slipping his tongue between her lips, licking the length of her folds. He repeated this maneuver before sliding up to her clit, replacing his tongue with two fingers, which slid inside easily. He started gentle, easing his fingers deeper, flicking her clit with the flat of his tongue. Sarah grabbed his hair, pulling him against her, just as he’d done as she went down on him. He took the cue and increased his efforts, pumping his fingers faster and deeper, and sucking her clit into his mouth, circling it with his tongue as he deftly held it with his teeth.
He reached up and grabbed her tit with his free hand, tweaking her nipple, increasing the pressure when she responded positively. Sarah started to writhe on the couch, gently thrusting her pelvis against her brother’s mouth, her orgasm growing closer as he increased his aggression on her clit and cunt.
“Oh yes, yes, yes! Make me cum!” Sarah screamed, “I want to cum all over your face, Bobby!”
Candice was the first to stir outside, aroused by Sarah’s cries. She roused the others, and they crept inside, standing behind the sofa watching Bobby eat his sister towards a massive orgasm.
“Fuck yes, suck harder, keep going, I’m almost there,” Sarah’s words transitioned into a primal scream before her body went limp. The other girls smiled as they watched as her brother slowed and began to gently kiss Sarah’s legs as she came down from her climax.
Sitting back on his knees, Bobby looked up to see the crowd had watched the final moments of what he’d thought was a private moment between him and his sister. As Sarah lay back, her breasts heaving as she sucked air deep into her lungs, Bobby realized that it was an opportunity to answer the other question he’d asked Dee. His sister, Dee’s original answer, wouldn’t be a candidate, but she’d be able to judge which of the other girls ate the best pussy. Bobby picked up the discarded tie and fastened it around his sister’s eyes.
“Truth or dare? Sis,” Bobby asked in jest. It was a rhetorical question, and even if she’d picked truth, it would’ve been ignored. “Same rule as before, you each get two minutes to prove you’re the best.”
Candice was the first to kneel before Sarah, gently kissing the sensitive skin of her inner thigh, starting at the knee and working her way higher. Her hands caressed Sarah’s hips before moving to grip her ass as she pulled her face into Sarah’s sex. Her cunt was hot and wet, as she was still recovering from the orgasm Bobby had given her. Candice did not start slow, knowing Sarah was ready to go, driving two fingers inside her as she sucked her clit into her mouth. Piggybacking on her previous climax, the intense sensations Candice provided instantly put Sarah on the verge of another orgasm. It was an unfair advantage for the competition and one that Candice knew she could exploit. She often experienced back-to-back orgasms when alone at home, so she knew Sarah could do the same.
“Oh my god, yes, yes, fuck that feels good,” Sarah said through deep breaths.
Candice knew she had her. She sucked harder and curled her fingers to hit Sarah’s G-spot. She just needed a few more seconds.”
“Time,” Bobby called out, “back away from the pussy.”
Sarah let out a disappointed groan as Candice threw her hands up in exasperation. Ashley was quickly pushing Candice aside, eager to take advantage of Sarah being on the verge of orgasm. Her tongue dipped between Sarah’s folds, diving as deep as it could go. Her thumb found Sarah’s nub, angling from above, rubbing intensely as she lapped the sweet nectar. The change in technique was just what Sarah needed.
“I’m cumming. Keep going, don’t stop,” Sarah cried out, “fucking hell that’s good.”
Bobby should’ve called time, but he let Ashley go another fifteen seconds to not interrupt his sister’s pleasure. It might have given an advantage to Ashley, but it would’ve been cruel to his sister to do otherwise.
Ashley sat back, a wide smile on her face, her chin shiny with Ashley’s juices, clearly proud of making her friend cum. Dee pushed her out of the way, eager to get started, unaware that Sarah needed some time to recover from her second orgasm in a few minutes. Dee quickly discovered Sarah’s clit was too sensitive. As soon as Dee licked the nub, Sarah pushed her face back.
“That’s too much. Take it slow.”
Dee obeyed but knew that she was out of the running as she kissed Sarah’s stomach and gently slid a finger inside her. She was kind and gentle, letting Sarah recover as her time ran out.
“Thank you. I needed that,” Sarah said as she ran her fingers through Dee’s hair.
Bella took her time, allowing Sarah time to recover, only taking her position when the others insisted. She picked up where Dee had left off, being gentle, but quickly tested the waters of Sarah’s clit. When Sarah moaned in appreciation, Bella upped the intensity, slipping a second finger inside her as she switched from licking to sucking. Bella’s nose was buried in Sarah’s pubic hair as she tried to make up for lost time. Unfortunately, the seconds ticked away before she could bring Sarah to a third orgasm, falling well short of her objective.
“Sorry, Bella, time’s up,” Bobby said, placing a hand on her shoulder.
“I guess it’s time to find out who’s the winner.” Ashley smiled.
“And we never heard Bobby’s conclusion from earlier either,” Dee added.
“But we all know who won that round,” Sarah said as she sat up and removed the blindfold. Her cheeks were flushed, matching her aroused pussy lips. She had been worked over by everyone and was showing the signs.
The sexual tension had only risen since breakfast. Bobby and Sarah had each cum, but none of the other girls had even come close. The previous night had satisfied them, but going down on the siblings had brought them back to needing relief.
“So,” Candice asked, “are we going to get our answers?”
“Fine,” Bobby said, “but let me say that you’re all amazing, so don’t hate me for any of this.”
“We promise,” Ashley spoke for the group.
“Okay then, the first two girls, you both did a great job, but you seem a bit inexperienced and could use for more confidence in your actions–”
“Maybe you could give us some instructions before you leave?” Candice interrupted, nudging Bella, urging her to nod in agreement.
“I’d love to. Just let me know when,” Bobby winked in return. “The third girl, taking all of me in your throat, that was incredible. I’ve never experienced anything like that before, but it was just one trick.”
“I can do more. I just didn’t have enough time,” Ashley protested.
“I’m sure you can,” Bobby smiled. “Dee, I assume you were forth? I loved you sucking on my balls. It would be amazing to combine that with Ashley’s deep-throating if we can find the time.”
“I’m sure we can,” Dee said, glancing at Ashley for confirmation.
“And your technique, swirling around my head like you did, that was pure magic. I wouldn’t have lasted much longer.”
“I knew I was better than you,” Dee smirked at Ashley.
“But,” Bobby emphasized, “only one of you made me cum, so I have to give the prize to my sister. I know I was blindfolded for the others, but there was nothing that compared to looking down and seeing my younger sister with my cock between her lips. I must say, I wouldn’t turn down a BJ from any of you. You’re all sexy as fuck.”