“There’s something else I want to find out,” Dee smirked.
“What’s that?”
“Which of us has the best cunt?” Dee answered, slipping her finger through her wet lips.
“I’d love to answer that, all of your pussies felt amazing last night, but honestly, I would need a more direct comparison.”
“We could arrange that,” Ashley said, sliding up next to Bobby, her naked body warm against his.
“Anytime you like, but just not now,” Bobby squeezed one of Ashley’s breasts, “I need to talk to Sarah. We’ve got a lot to discuss.”
“I’m sure you do,” Dee mimicked sex by sliding a finger through the circle of her index finger and thumb.
“Bobby’s right. I need to talk to him. You are welcome to stay and do what you need to do. Our parents won’t be home until this evening, but we’re going to need some privacy,” Sarah interjected, making sure the girls knew to take her seriously.
“Dee, we need to talk as well,” Bobby said.
“I know. I know. I’ll stop by the drug store on the way home,” Dee responded, acknowledging the need for the morning-after pill.
“Wait. Sarah, which one of us ate the best pussy?” Candice asked.
“You were all amazing.”
“Yeah, yeah, but who was best?” Ashley asked.
“Candice, you were great, but you need to change up your tactics to find what is best for me, which Ashley did perfectly. But this was unfair to Dee and Bella. I have to say that I appreciated Dee for listening to me. She just needed more patience to start with. And Bella, you had me going, but time was not on your side.”
“So,” Ashley begged, “who was the best?”
“Bobby,” Sarah smiled, “He beat you all by a mile. But I agree with him. Any of you can go down on me whenever you like.”
Bobby took Sarah by the hand and led her upstairs. As they disappeared, the other four girls looked at each other with lust in their eyes. They’d all hoped to fuck Bobby again, but Sarah was monopolizing that option unless they were really going to take the time to discuss what was going on between them. It was a possibility, but the girls figured their desire would take over, and the conversation would have to wait until they were satiated. They all knew you should always have sex before a serious discussion. After all, it might be the last time you do it.
“So, who wants to eat me out?” Dee asked.
“Only if we can sixty-nine,” Bella responded before pulling Dee in for a kiss.
Soon the four girls were wrapped up in each other’s naked bodies, hands groping, tongues licking, and toes curling. They were getting used to pleasuring each other, especially when there wasn’t enough cock to go around. Hopefully, in college, they’d find boyfriends or fuck buddies because they wouldn’t have each other to fall back on. Right now, they didn’t care as they had each other, and from the sound of it, they’d have Bobby’s cock inside them soon.
*****
Bobby leaned back on his pillow as Sarah sat on the end of the bed. They were both still naked, but their emotions were trying to crawl away and hide. Looking at each other, they knew they shouldn’t be doing what they were, but it didn’t feel wrong while in each other’s arms. It only got awkward when they thought they needed to talk about it.
“So,” Bobby stalled, “where should we start?”
“Umm, I don’t know,” Sarah looked down at the bed, “How about here?”
Sarah crawled forward, her lithe naked body stretching across the mattress, as she reached for her brother’s limp dick. Blood returned to it, causing it to rise before her hand made contact. She stroked him as he grew longer and thicker as she looked him in the eyes.
“Do I really suck cock the best?”
“There is nothing better than when you look at me like that. Your eyes are sexier than anything.”
“Even Ashley’s tits?”
“Don’t get me wrong, those are spectacular, but they still don’t compare to–”