Wine Night with my Exhibitionist Girlfriend – Chapter 2 – by superwriter1337
“That’d be nice every once in a while,” Madison said.
“What would? Having sex three times in a day?” I asked.
“Mhm,” Madison said. “Like, I totally see the appeal of spending the whole day getting fucked.”
“That sounds very appealing,” Ashley giggled. The three of us laughed.
“No, no, it totally does,” Madison said. “But just, like, not every day! Just sometimes, I’d like to spend the day in bed getting laid.”
“Doesn’t have to be in bed,” Ashley winked.
“Good point,” Madison said. “Then I’d like to spend the day getting laid. In bed, in the shower, on the floor, wherever.”
“Mhm,” Ashley said.
“But just not every single day,” Madison said.
“What’s your, like, ideal frequency for having sex?” I asked.
“Depends,” Madison said. “If I’m not busy, then I wouldn’t mind having sex every day. But a few times a week, at least.”
“Yeah, a few times a week is good,” Alyssa said. “You can always go crazy some weeks if you’re in the mood.”
I nodded. “Makes sense.”
“Pretty sure I’ve asked Ashley this before,” Madison said. “And she said every day, at least, right?”
Ashley nodded. “I prefer to get dick at least once a day.”
“Which works for me,” I said. “I’m an everyday type of guy at the moment.”
“Hey, do you guys wanna play a game?” Ashley asked, clearly already feeling the effects of her wine. I think all of us were a bit tipsy at this point.
“What did you have in mind?” Alyssa asked.
“How about Never Have I Ever?” Madison suggested.
“Works for me,” Alyssa said.
“I’m down.” I said, taking another swig from my beer.
“Me too,” Ashley said with a sly grin spreading across her lips.
“How about you go first, Ashley?” I said. “Since you suggested it and all.”
“Okay,” Ashley smiled. “Everybody put up all five fingers.”
We all did as we were told.
“Now then,” Ashley said, pausing for a moment to think of a prompt. “Never have I ever smoked a cigarette.”
Madison rolled her eyes and put a finger down. “Were you targeting me? That was one time when I was, like, sixteen.”
Alyssa laughed. “Serves you right for trying cigarettes at all!”
Madison chuckled. “I suppose so, it was dumb.” She took a big sip of wine. “So who’s next?”
“Let’s go clockwise,” Ashley said. “So Brian, you’re next.”
I had been trying to think of a prompt while Ashley was doing her turn, but I hadn’t come up with anything yet.
I thought for another moment before saying, “Never have I ever accidentally walked in on two people having sex.” I’ve definitely walked in on people having sex before, but never by accident!
Madison thought for a moment. “How do you define walked in on? Because I come downstairs and hear you and Ashley going at it at least twice a week.”
Ashley laughed. “Hey now, we almost always have sex in my bedroom!”
“Almost always?” Alyssa inquired, taking a small sip of wine after she spoke.
“Well, yeah,” I shrugged. “Sometimes we’re out here. Like last week, I’m pretty sure we banged right where you’re sitting.”
“Oh my God,” Alyssa laughed. “You didn’t!”
“It might’ve been where Madison is sitting,” Ashley said, scratching her head. “I’m not really in the right state of mind to remember right now.”
“Oh, I think you’re right, Ashley,” I said.
“Yeah. Because I think I remember being able to see that painting –” Ashley gestured to this painting hanging on the wall behind Madison — “while I was riding you.”
“Oh, you were riding him?” Madison laughed. “Thanks, now I think I have the right mental picture.”
“Mhm,” Ashley said. “If it helps, I was completely naked, but Brian only had his pants down a bit.”
“Why weren’t both of you naked?” Alyssa asked.
“Well, I had just gotten out of the shower,” Ashley said. “And I was horny –.”
“As usual,” Madison interjected.
“Right,” Ashley laughed. “So I came over to where Brian was sitting, and I just got down on my knees, pulled his pants down, and started blowing him.”
“Wow,” Alyssa mused.
“It was pretty great,” I grinned.
“And once he was hard,” Ashley continued. “I sat down on his dick and started riding.”
“Sounds like a good time to me,” Alyssa chuckled.
“Oh, it was,” Ashley said.
“Where was I?” Madison asked. “I don’t remember this.”
“We were pretty quiet for once,” Ashley said. “I thought you might have gone to bed so I didn’t want to wake you up.”
“Ah, but if you had reason to believe I was awake, then you wouldn’t have bothered with trying to be quiet, right?” Madison said.
“Of course not!” Ashley laughed. “It’s more fun when you can be loud.”
“You’re not wrong,” Alyssa said in agreement.
Madison laughed and rolled her eyes. “Okay, well then I suppose I haven’t walked in on you guys doing it before.”
Alyssa thought for a moment before slowly putting a finger down. “I think I walked in on my sister having sex once? I’m not 100% sure because she won’t admit to it, but that had to be what she and her boyfriend were doing.”
“Probably was,” Madison said. “I take it you didn’t ask her?”
“Nope,” Alyssa chuckled. “I felt weird about it at the time. I don’t think I’d care now. If anything, I’d just tease her about it. Alyssa took another big sip of her wine as “punishment” for having to put a finger down. “It definitely looked like they’d been having sex though.”
“Yeah, if it looked at all like they were having sex, then they were probably having sex,” Ashley laughed.
Alyssa nodded. “Yeah.”
“So who’s next?” Ashley asked, looking at the group. “Alyssa is, right?”
“Yeah,” I said. “I just went, so she’s next.”
Madison, Ashley, and I turned and faced Alyssa, who was currently thinking about what to say.
After a bit of thought, Alyssa blushed and said, “Never have I ever done anal.”
Madison blushed a bit too, and then both Ashley and Madison started giggling. I have no idea if Alyssa had any idea that Madison had just spent the evening getting fucked in the ass by two different cocks. All I know is that I did not expect Alyssa to be the first person to give an overtly sexual prompt. I figured it’d be me or Ashley.
“Ooh, it looks like I got a few of you guys, huh?” Alyssa grinned.
“Mmm, I think you did,” I laughed. I took a big swig of my beer and put a finger down.
Alyssa giggled. “You’ve put your, erm, thing in a girl’s butt before?” Alyssa then turned and looked at Ashley. “Does that mean you’ve taken it in the butt before?”
Ashley laughed. “Oh, Brian’s put his ‘thing’ in my butt once or twice.”
Alyssa glanced at me and caught me mid-eye roll. “What?”
“Once or twice? Please” I said.
Ashley laughed again. “Okay, okay, maaaaybe I’ve taken it in the butt — oh, let me see — more times than I can count.”
“That’s more accurate,” I laughed.
———————