“It took a while for me.” She wrinkled up her mouth. “Especially the swallowing part,” she giggled. “My brother Jim caught me spitting it out a few times after pretending that I’d swallowed.” She looked over and gave a bashful smile as she remembered that her husband was sitting right there.
“Well, I’m glad you got over that before we met!” Trey’s father feigned relief. His wife Betsy reached over and smacked his arm lightly.
“You should be, mister!” Trey’s mother rolled her eyes. “You must have been saving up for weeks that first time. It was twice as much as my brother had ever produced.” She rolled her eyes before placing her hand of Candace’s arm comfortingly. “I don’t know how you put up with him until I took over.”
“Oh, it wasn’t so bad,” Candace shrugged. “Bill was probably just excited to have someone so lovely doing that for him. You were such a doll in college, Bets.”
“I’m just glad they weren’t all like that!” Trey’s mother marveled. “I never would have accepted the proposal if he’d kept that up.”
“Oh, don’t make him feel bad, Betsy,” Candace cooed. “Trust me, there were plenty of other girls at the sorority who would have taken your place on their knees,” she smiled reassuringly at her brother. “But I’ll admit he did make a girl work to get it all down when he was excited.” She laughed and put her hand on her sister-in-laws shoulder. “I remember one time I thought that he had to be done, and pulled away to swallow the mouthful I already had, and he just kept going, at least a couple more times! Got it in my hair and everything!” She was laughing so hard she could barely finish the story. “We were out in the garage at our parents place and I had to sneak upstairs to wash it out once we got back in the house!” Betsy laughed right along with Candace.
Trey’s father grinned sheepishly, feeling like he was that same awkward eighteen year old apologizing to his older sister after ejaculating in her hair and onto her cheek. “And I’ll thank you to stop sharing family secrets, Candy.”
“Oh hush,” Candace scolded him. “After all, Betsy is family now and we have obviously already shared something a little more intimate than just a few old embarrassing stories.” She turned to her sister-in-law and couldn’t keep the twinkle out of her eye as they met each other’s gaze.
“I’ll say we have!” Trey’s mother was feeling more than a little tipsy at that point. “Even if there isn’t a ceremony where they pass off that particular baton!” Both she and Candace broke out in uncontrollable laughter, causing people at nearby table to turn to see what was causing such hilarity.
Trey delayed it as much as he could, but as he hooked his thumbs in the waistband of his boxers, it wasn’t as if his state of arousal was much of a mystery any longer. He had to lift his waistband up, and over, to clear the tip of his embarrassingly hard cock, before lowering his underwear to the ground, and stepping out of them, naked as he could be, in front of his sisters.
Even having seen, and touched, her brother’s dick already, Cissy had been unprepared for how her throat had tightened up as she watched him get undressed. As much as she wanted to give her attention to the distended length of his hard cock now sticking up in plain view, she found herself marveling at the sweep of his chest, his shoulders and firm stomach, his powerful thighs and the muscles in his neck as he stood fully revealed before them. Cissy found herself feeling an intense mixture of shame, at the uncontrollable arousal surging through her body, and excitement, as her body reacted to being naked, in the same room, with a man in a similar condition, even if it was only her brother.
For Carol’s part, she had thrown out the dare as a means to both move the level of intimacy along, as well as lessen her own embarrassment, by making Trey suffer the same humiliation as she and Cissy had, when they were forced to get naked in front of their siblings. She was completely unprepared, for the audible gasp that she produced, once her brother lowered his boxers and she got her first look at a man’s erect penis. As much as she and her friends joked about swimsuit mishaps and awkward efforts men went to to try and conceal that they had a boner, there was something a little overwhelming, about finally seeing her brother’s erection fully exposed.
It should have made Trey look comical to stand there naked with an uncontrollable erection, but both of his sisters gaped, open-mouthed in fascination, at the sight of his throbbing manhood. Carol was embarrassed, but her fascination wouldn’t allow her to look away from the long, meaty length of her brother’s cock. She felt a tingling warmth pulsing out from between her legs, and pushing up through her lower stomach, as if a part of her body was trying to reach out, on its own, toward those long inches of her brother’s meaty dick. Carol’s eyes flickered up to brother’s face, and she blushed uncontrollably, to see that Trey had been looking right at her while she had examined his exposed cock. She found, for the first time in her life, that she couldn’t hold his gaze, as she demurely lowered her eyes, suddenly conscious again of her own nakedness.
“So is this what you had planned, Carol?” Trey took a seat on the warm marble of the hearth, leaning forward to place his elbows on his knees.
“Well, yeah I guess,” Carol shrugged and shot a glance over at her sister.
“So you do know then,” Cissy said quietly.
“Well, I know what we’re supposed to do,” Carol looked back and forth between her siblings. “I guess I just didn’t know any other way to go about it.” She shrugged, but her face wrinkled up involuntarily as the next question came out. “Were you two ever going to tell me?”
“Of course we were Carol,” Trey felt ashamed for having been so awkward about approaching her. “It all just sounded so…crazy…that I was trying to find a way to tell you that didn’t sound well…crazy.” Carol could see the helplessness in his expression. She knew her brother didn’t make a habit of lying.
“But you told Cissy?” Carol did her best not to sound petulant.
“She kind of dragged it out of me, to be honest,” Trey admitted. “She could tell how much it was bothering me and threatened to go to mother and father thinking I was hiding something much worse.” He shrugged, all of his cards now out on the table. He tried to look into Carol’s big blue eyes to emphasize the totality of his disclosure, but his eyes kept creeping down to her magnificent tits that had still only been exposed for brief time.
“Have you already tried it?” Carol turned to Cissy.
Cissy nodded her chin slightly. “Just a little…today”, her eyes flickered over toward her brother.
“Will you show me how to do it then?” Carol wasn’t used to asking her sister for advice with boys, but after the last few hours, it felt like everything in the world had changed.
“I was thinking that there should be something more formal, and decorous, about the handoff from a man’s sister to his intended,” Candace mused a few drinks later. “Instead you’ve got some girl kneeling in the dark of night, behind the bleachers at the stadium, or the back bedroom of some frat house, at the moment she takes over, and the sister is retired.”