We hove-to in a secluded cove on the leeward of the island and made Huntress fast. I turned on the audio system and let the sounds of Sinatra and Connick wash over us. We fished another bottle out of the cooler below and sprawled out on the settee in each other’s arms, letting our hands explore the contours of the other’s body, hearing the contended sighs of lovers as we talked about nothing. Our reverie was broken by the arrival of a smaller powerboat in the cove. A voice called out and asked if they could share the anchorage. Although loathe to give up our privacy, courtesy prevented me from waving them off.
Another voice called out, thanking us and inviting us for cocktails. I felt Holli stiffen slightly, then laugh as she looked up at me. “Kat”, she purred, “I hear two men”, her hand stroked over my pussy and told me what she had in mind. I called out and invited the captain to raft up for the evening. As they approached, we stood in our short t-shirts and smiled as lines were passed across.
Holli made a point of reaching out to tie off the boats just far enough to confirm their suspicions that we were only wearing those shirts. The two men looked confused, and hopeful as we tied up and introduced ourselves. Keith and Brian were on a cruise to Seattle, bringing down a friend’s boat for the summer. Both appeared to be in their late 20s and were pleasantly surprised to find a boat, hoping to share dinner and drinks with fellow sailors.
We shared the remainder of our second bottle with them as Holli slid closer to Brian and me to Keith. The boys were enjoying the attention and the wine ran out as we flirted and made contact “accidentally” with our newfound friends. Holli excused herself to get another bottle below deck, then called out for me to help her. I went below and we hatched our plan for the evening….
Coming back on deck we returned to our seats and cuddled a bit closer to each man. Their crotches gave away their feelings about our activities and both of us began to furtively caress the bulges, stealing kisses and snuggling in next to our targets. I made eye contact with Holli and we stood in unison, looking the boys in the eye as we both stripped off our shirts and kneeled, naked in front of them, unzipping their flies and taking those lovely cocks in hand.
I said simply “Gentlemen, it’s your lucky day, but you have to agree to one thing” As their cocks were pulsing in our hands, I knew this negotiation wouldn’t take long. Keith and Brian readily agreed without hearing the condition. As I kissed the head of his lovely 7 inch member I looked into Keith’s eyes and simply said: “you have to fuck both of us” and proceeded to swallow him down to his balls, letting my tongue swirl over the length of his shaft. I knew Holli had made the same demand as I heard them both groan in delight.
Holli and I sucked the boys and brought them close once or twice, only to switch men and begin the process all over g again. Brian’s cock was a bit bigger than Keith’s, and tasting Holli on it made it even more fun to go down on. As we stood up the second time, we gave them another choice- whose mouth did they want to cum in? Keith immediately chose Holli, and Brian looked dejected.
Holli took his cock in one hand and Keith’s in the other and smiled, letting them know it was fine with her if both unloaded in her mouth. For my part, I simply took advantage of the situation by having the mouth of the man not being serviced firmly planted on my pussy while Holli brought the other to a shattering orgasm.
Once the preliminaries were out of the way, we knew which man each of us wanted first and proceeded to get them ready for round two. I walked over to Brian and sat on his lap, firmly putting that lovely thick member between my ass cheeks and slowly riding him until he responded. Holli went to Keith and put his cock between her breasts, smiling as she tit-fucked him back to life.
Once hard, the boys had no problem as I turned on Brian’s lap and guided him in and Holli laid back and Keith slipped in from above. The boat rocked at anchor in synch with our fucking. After a few minutes I slowed and looked at Brian and smiled as I stood. “Remember, you promised” I said as I reached over and tapped Keith’s shoulder. Holli stood next to me as we held onto those big cocks, all slippery from inside o us and led them to the front of the cockpit. We let go and turned, spreading our legs as we leaned against the cabin and invited the boys back in.
Keith’s cock slid in and I recognized immediately one thing – he knew how to fuck soooooo much better than his slightly-more well endowed friend! His strokes were deep and even and his hands went to work on my nipples and clit immediately, send waves of pleasure through me as I pushed back against him. I looked over at Holli and saw her enjoying Brian as well.
Reaching out, I touched her hand and brought it to my lips and was rewarded with a smile and a kiss as we continued to enjoy these perfect guests. The kiss must have set the boys off, because the speed and depth of Keith’s thrusts mounted steadily, along with the occasional withdrawal and slipping along the crack of my ass… almost like a request. I decided to honor his request the next time he slid out and pushed against him as his head slid over my ass. He froze, and I worked his slippery cock slowly into my ass, feeling the head pop in and then most of his shaft.
I smiled back at him as he looked down in almost disbelief and let him know I wanted him to cum in my ass. Holli smiled over and kissed me again, whispering how hot she thought that was. Keith didn’t last much longer, firing off a huge load that I felt fill me up. Brian followed suit, although he pulled out of Holli and unloaded all over my lover’s beautiful back. I grabbed his cock and cleaned it, then lapped up his load from her back, explaining I hadn’t had a chance to get any earlier. Holli reached behind me and slipped her finger in my ass and pulled it out licking it clean as she smiled at Keith.
Smiling at the boys, we curled up in each other’s arm sand bid them goodnight, promising to have breakfast in the morning as they jumped aboard the boat for the night….