Finally, then, Susan came back and pushed Katie back down again. Even so the angle wasn’t quite right, the plug was larger and her body was constantly in motion. It took several goes, but final Susan managed to position the bulb right and put enough pressure on to get it in. Too much pressure, as for the first time she felt genuinely hurt as it slid in. She suddenly understood why a lot of girls didn’t like anal, but it had only been for a second and now that it was in it was fine.
With the plug now in, she could focus again on Mr Collins. The little sounds he was making and the speed of his thrusts told her it wasn’t going to be long. His hands had thus far remained around her head, but now he moved one hand down and started squeezing her boob. It was a rough squeeze, demanding and uncaring. He brought his finger back and pinched at her nipples.
“Okay, remember girl, no spitting or swallowing. Don’t fuck this up.”
Three thrusts later, he hit the point of no return. She was expecting him to thrust his cock deeper into her mouth as he came, but instead he held back, drawing his cock back so the head was only just past her lips. He quivered uncontrollably and she felt her mouth fill up with liquid. She had never liked the taste of cum and this was no different, bitter and slimy, but she waited holding it in her mouth. After a third and final spasm, he gently pulled his cock out, being careful to give her time to seal her mouth back up afterwards. She tilted her head up slightly. It made it easier to keep the mouthful in that way.
Mr Collins had reached over to the desk, pulled out a wipe and was cleaning himself up, apparently having forgotten about Katie. Instead it was Susan who came round and held out a large steel dish.
“You may spit.”
Katie dribbled the whole of the load onto the dish.
“Okay, that was brilliant, darling. You can take a swig of water from the bottle over there.” Katie gratefully opening the bottle of mineral water and took a swig. She swirled it around her mouth for a second then spat it into the waste paper basket.
“Now, tilt you head back,” Susan said. She lifted up the dish and titled it up, slowly letting the semen land on Katie’s face. The forehead was first, then she moved her hands down so it started falling onto her nose and then chin. The semen on the noses dribbled down onto her eyes which she had to shut. She could also feel it getting trapped in her eye-lashes.
“Okay, Mr Sutcliff, she’ll be ready for you in just a second. Now might be a good time to see if she can take the final plug. No worries if you can’t dear, we’ll just give it a quick go.”
In the end, it was easy. As she wasn’t being fucked anymore, Susan was able to angle her body carefully and get both plugs out and in without any trouble. She should have been scared of the size of the final plug, but she found she was more worried about her face. It was a mess and she could smell the reek of semen constantly.
Having completed the swap over, Susan took her hand and led her back to the group of three men. One down and two to go, thought Katie, but she wasn’t sure how much she had left in her. Where before, she had taken a perverse kind of pride in the men’s admiring comments, now she stood before them dishevelled and ashamed. Susan passed her hand to Peter and said “Your blushing bride.”
Katie hesitated again. “Anything I should know?” she asked Susan.
Susan shrugged. “No, this is going to be a fairly standard doggie fuck. Again, we want to keep the semen inside you, so keep your face lower than you back especially when Mr Sutcliff cums. You may find the sensations extra extreme with the large butt-plug in — it tends to move your anatomy around.”
“Okay”, Katie got down on her knees again, turned round and pressed her face down into the carpet. “Mr Sutcliff, please fill me up with your cock and your cum.”
He said nothing, but she felt his cock enter her. Susan was right, between the plug and the penis she’d never felt so full before. The walls of her passage were pushed down, as he entered her, his cock pushed them back up, squeezing them between flesh and plastic. He pushed in again and she didn’t know if she was going to be able to take it. He must have sensed this, because on the next thrust, he pushed down hard on the base of the plug. Both her holes were filled at the same time.
Less than ten seconds and in only three thrusts, she came loudly. The convulsions from her orgasm rippled around the toy and the dick, pushing both directly into her G-spot. She came again, louder. This time, the shaking pushed the toy half-way out of her. Another thrust of the dick, and the toy fell out completely, rolling onto the carpet. Katie was only barely aware of Susan rushing to retrieve it, and store it away safely.
Katie’s body stopped moving, completely. She realized that she wasn’t being fucked anymore. Neither holes had anything in them anymore. Had Peter cum or was he just giving her some time to recover. She looked over and saw Peter starting to clean up.
“Goddamn Peter, that was quick, but I can’t say I’d have lasted any longer in your position,” Bill said.
“Now if you’d just like to squat down for me,” Susan said. She placed the same dish plate as earlier under her and let her bend over it. As it started to trickle out of her, Katie had it confirmed that Peter had indeed cum inside her. The first few dollops landed in the plate. Susan had a small plastic spoon ready. “If you’ll excuse me,” she said, she inserted it into Katie and started to tease the rest of the liquid out. There was less than had been in her mouth. Maybe it was more difficult to recover, or Peter had produced less anyway. In any case, when she had got all she thought she could, Susan took the plate and started to spread the load around Katie’s groan — the pubic hair, the thighs and even round her labial lips.
“Okay, do we need a breather before round three?” she asked.
“No, I’m ready” Katie replied. “Where do you want me?”
“We can use the desk again,” said Bill unzipping. His dick was just as large as it had felt before.
She leaned over, presenting herself to him. Her nether regions were now a mixture of cum below and lube above. The cum on her face had started to solidify across her eye-bows and eye-lashes. She could imagine what she looked like in his eyes.
Bill took the bottle of lube from Susan and applied a little to his dick. He moved his hand forward and back, half masturbating, half spreading the lube around. He pushed her legs a little further apart, being careful to go low enough to avoid the stains from the other man’s cum. He pushed her ass just a little bit lower. Then, in one movement he entered her. It was skilfully done. She gasped slightly but there was no real pain. He moved his hands up to her shoulders.
Slowly, deliberately, he started to fuck her ass.
It was different from the toy. Part of that was the warm and, though he was hard, he was less rigid than plastic. More than that though was the feeling of being used for pleasure. She didn’t know if she could come through anal sex. She’d heard that some girls could. It didn’t matter to her though. She’d already had two earth shaking orgasms. She just wanted Bill to feel good.