Brie’s Babysitting Service: Sadie by Jay2Kay

“Is Lindsay what you really want?” she asked sincerely.

He stared out the windshield for a full minute before answering. “I don’t know,” he told her. “A part of me wants to say yes, but a part of me wants to say no, then there’s a third part of me that wants to say, ‘You’re only eighteen, go fuck the hot chick that’s been all over you all night’,” he told her and laughed; she laughed with him.

“I think I know which part of you that is,” she said.

“Oh, I know which part of me is saying that; he still is,” he admitted.

“Well,” she said finally opening herself up to him again as she began to lean towards him. “What if I told you that you could listen to that not-so-little part of you and still get the girl of your dreams?”

He looked at her confused. “How?” he asked. “Do you really think she’d want me if she knew something happened between us?”

His question was fair, and his tone was definitely one of curiosity and not of doubt and sarcasm. “Let me ask you this,” she replied. “How much do you think she’s already assuming we’ve done already? We’ve already made out twice now, one of those times I grinded my pussy into you to make you cum in your pants; plus, let’s not forget the fact that I gave you a blowjob right after; also, it was pretty obvious what you were doing to me on the bleachers just a little bit ago. She’s probably assuming we’ve fucked like rabbits for you to be brave enough to do that in a public place,” she reasoned with him.

He thought about her point for a moment and nodded. “That does make sense. So, then we should just go ahead and do whatever it is she’s assuming we’ve done?” he asked.

“Don’t you want to?” she asked, gripping his thigh, just inches away from his already stiff cock.

“I think that’s obvious,” he says, swallowing hard.

“Wanna skip the lake?” she asked.

“A part of me would definitely like to,” he said.

“But a part of you wants to try and win Lindsay over, too, huh?” she asked and he nodded.

She thought about it for a moment and came up with an idea. “I think my plan I had in my head is changing,” she said.

“What plan?” he asked.

“I was considering causing a scene between us and leaving you there so Lindsay would give you a ride home tonight,” she told him and he thought about it.

“It could still work,” he said.

“You really wanna try and get it all, don’t you?” she giggled, gripping his cock this time, causing him to gasp; she could feel his cock pulsing, threatening to blow his load already. “Be honest with me,” she said, gripping him tighter and he closed his eyes painfully.

“I do,” he cried and then she released his rigid pole.

“Good,” she said. “We’ll figure something out,” she said and then Lindsay drove by in her Jeep Wrangler, the other girls with her; one sat up front while the other three squeezed together in the back.

“That’s her,” he said and then started the car and followed her to the Lakeside Fairgrounds.

When they arrived, there was a guy in his late twenties/early thirties waving them in and when the line of cars ended with Sean and Lindsay’s vehicles, he partially closed the gate behind them. Sean followed Lindsay’s Jeep to where the others were parked on a grassy lot.

“Ready, stud?” Sadie asked and then leaned over to kiss him hard on the lips. “Gotta keep up the act, right?” she asked with a wink.

“Right,” he half-agreed.

“That WAS you,” Lindsay said as they got out of the car.

“Yep!” Sean said, grinning at her. “We saw you go by in the parking lot and quickly followed you,” he told her.

Sadie joined him, hooking her arm into his. Lindsay’s face immediately transformed from smiling at Sean to trying not to glare at Sadie; Sadie was finally convinced that Lindsay was actually jealous and most likely really wanted Sean.

“That’s a nice car,” Lindsay said, trying to be friendly. “Is it a rental? Or did you drive that all the way out here?” she asked.

Sadie grinned at her; this girl is smart, trying to poke holes in their story. She wasn’t buying the whole Twitch friend thing, but she had to sell it to her.

“It’s a rental. Do you think I’d let him drive it if it were mine?” she teased.

Lindsay gave a fake smile. “Well, Sean is a pretty safe driver, so I’d trust him,” she countered.

“That’s true,” Sadie agreed. “Babe, can we get a drink? I’m sure they’ve got something here at this party,” she said.

“Yeah,” he said and then smiled at Lindsay. “Catch up later?” he asked her and she nodded.

“She wants you for sure,” Sadie said when they were out of earshot.

“She does?” he asked her, looking over his shoulder, but she reached up and pulled him in for a kiss with full tongue to remind him of their plan.

Sean’s cock twitched from her kiss and when they broke the kiss, he immediately searched for where they were keeping the drinks to find they had about five beer kegs set up and they were filling red SOLO cups, handing them out to anyone who approached. Sean took two cups, handing one to Sadie who quickly chugged hers down and asked for a refill right away. The two beefy guys tending to the kegs gawked at her and handed her a refilled cup without a word, their eyes darting back and forth between Sean and Sadie as if shocked to see him with a girl at all, let alone one as hot as Sadie.

“Come on, Sean, let’s find somewhere a little more private,” she said and then pulled him a ways off from the main party where a couple large bonfires were already lit with teenagers drinking, laughing while some couples were already making out together.

They found a spot secluded with a few trees blocking them from the view of the rest of the party, though they could see if anyone was coming. Sadie dropped her cup of beer and pulled Sean into her and their mouths reconnected; she had to make this as animalistic and emotionless as possible; she couldn’t risk either of them growing some sort of attachment to each other.

“Whoa, slow down,” he said.

“Why?” she asked and then dropped to her knees where she began to unfasten his belt and tug his jeans down to his ankles. “You’re not falling for me, are you?” she teased.

“Sadie, stop,” he said and gently pulled her back up, though his jeans were already pooled up around his ankles. “Do you really want to do this? Just fuck, cause a fake scene and then take off?”

“Are you saying you don’t want to fuck me?” she asked frustrated at his mixed signals. “You said you wanted to do both, for us to finally fuck and to end up with Lindsay. Are you telling me you’re not okay with that?”

“Well, you said Lindsay seemed really into me? What will she think of me if we hook up and then you just ditch me?” he asked. “She’ll think I’m just some asshole who fucks girls and moves on,” he confessed his fear and she took a deep breath to calm herself.

She thought about it for a moment. “Then I’ll make myself look like the slut who got rejected by you,” she said. “I can spin the fight to look like you’re a good guy just looking for the right girl. Hell, I can even put you and Lindsay on the spot and make myself out to be the jealous one because you were still hung up on her,” she said.