Ashley’s pussy gripped me tightly, but I was able to stave off my orgasm for about ten minutes. Outside Ashley’s bedroom door, Madison was setting up for the evening. She had brought out wine glasses, shot glasses, cups, and water bottles. Ashley and I were making no effort to be quiet; her parents had gone to bed about an hour ago. So Madison heard us, clear as day. She heard Ashley’s moans of pleasure as I fucked her pussy. She heard Ashley cry out when her first orgasm hit. And Madison heard her big sister announce that she was cumming for her second orgasm too. And finally, Madison heard me groan that I was about to finish, and she heard Ashley plead for me to cum deep inside her pussy. And I did. I sank my cock into my girlfriend’s pussy and ejaculated deep inside her.
Once my orgasm ended, I kissed Ashley deeply again. “I love you,” I said.
“I love you too.”
Ashley got up, grabbed her clothes, and quickly waddled to the bathroom to clean up. Madison laughed. I finished getting dressed and walked outside of Ashley’s bedroom to join Madison on one of the couches.
“How was the sex?” Madison smirked.
“Amazing,” I grinned. “I’m a lucky man.”
“Clearly,” Madison laughed. “Did you finish inside her?”
“Of course!” I said. “You jealous?”
“A bit,” Madison giggled. “But I’ll get my turn soon enough.”
“I hope so,” I said.
A moment later, Ashley came out and joined us on the couch, sitting to my right. Madison was on my left. We sat on our phones and chatted while we waited for Alyssa to arrive. The night was only just beginning.