“Fuck me, Brian,” she groaned. “Fuck my tight little ass.” Hearing Madison talk dirty like this was driving me crazy.
I slowly slid my cock about halfway out before thrusting forward so that I bottomed out inside her again.
“Fuck, that feels so good,” she moaned.
I began to thrust my cock in and out of her ass faster now, and with longer strokes. She was impossibly tight and so warm. I reached up and grabbed a handful of her breasts as I slid my cock in and out of her ass.
“Oh my God, Brian,” she cried out. “Your cock feels so good. Please don’t stop, fucking Christ, please don’t stop!”
I pinched her nipple with one hand while I gripped her side with the other. Her ass felt so fucking good. I leaned forward and moved my face towards hers as I began to really fuck her fast now. I brought my lips to hers and we kissed as we felt our orgasms approaching. She traced my lips with her tongue as I did hers, and our tongues intertwined in between gasps and moans. I broke our kiss to watch her face contort with pleasure as I pounded her ass. She cried out my name in between gasps and groans. She felt impossibly tight, and it wouldn’t be long before I was emptying my balls inside her.
“Are you close?” I whispered to her, knowing I didn’t have much left in me.
“Yes,” she whimpered.
I grunted and forced myself to hold on a little longer as I pounded this girl’s ass. I straightened back up and gripped her sides hard as I thrust myself deep inside her with each stroke. The sight of her ass swallowing up my cock would be burned into my mind for a long time after this.
Finally, I could hear the familiar tells that Madison was about to her cum. Her moans became increasingly frantic, and her breathing was rapidly growing faster and faster.
I let myself lose control. I fucked her hard and fast now. With each stroke I sank my cock deep inside her ass, my balls slapping against her ass cheeks as I pounded her. The feeling of her asshole tightly gripping my cock was incredible. And the fact that I was fucking my girlfriend’s little sister in the ass was unbelievable.
“Fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck, FUCK!” Madison cried out. “I’m gonna cum Brian, oh my GOD!”
Madison’s eyes rolled into the back of her head and her toes curled as her orgasm hit. I felt her ass begin to pulse and spasm around my cock, and that immediately pushed me over the edge.
“Fuck, I’m cumming too,” I grunted. I grabbed her hips and sunk myself deep inside her as I shot the first rope of cum deep into her ass. Finally.
“Fuck,” Madison cried as she felt my cock pulse and spasm as I unloaded inside her. Her fingers toyed wildly with her clit as she came with my cock deep inside her. I couldn’t control my moans as I shot another four ropes of thick, hot cum inside her.
I quickly slid my cock out of her once my orgasm finished. Madison was breathing hard, but she wanted more.
“Your turn, Jordan,” she grinned. “I don’t think you’ll be needing any lube. Brian took care of that for us.”
“Jesus Christ,” I breathed. I scooted to the side and sat down as Jordan took my position. His cock was already rock-hard.
Just as I did, Jordan took a moment to appreciate the sight before him. Madison was laying on her back, legs spread, her pretty, pink pussy and gorgeous tits on full display. And below her pussy, her tight little asshole, now with my cum beginning to leak out of it, waiting to be filled by a second cock.
Madison gently toyed with her clit as Jordan’s eyes ran greedily over her body. Finally, once Jordan had enough, he moved forward and pressed the head of his cock against Madison’s now cum-covered asshole. The fact that he would be using my cum as lube to fuck Madison’s ass was in and of itself insane.
“Ready?” Jordan asked.
“Fuck yeah,” Madison whimpered. “Fuck my ass, Jordan”. She began rubbing her clit more intensely as Jordan thrust forward. Madison’s asshole, slick with the fresh load of cum I had left inside her, readily gave way to this new intruder.
Jordan moaned as he sank his cock into Madison’s ass. He stopped when he was half-way inside her, giving Madison a chance to adjust to his impressive girth. Jordan ran his hands over her body, caressing her stomach and her thighs and her breasts. He pinched her nipples between his fingers and groped her breasts as he enjoyed the feeling of Madison’s asshole tightly gripping his cock.
“Okay,” Madison breathed. “Give me the rest. I want all of that cock inside me.”
The two of them moaned softly as Jordan slid the rest of his erection into her asshole, and Madison’s eyes rolled into the back of her head as he bottomed out inside her.
“Fuuuuck,” she breathed. “Oh my God.” She was already moaning loudly now, no doubt loving the feeling of Jordan’s massive cock filling her butt.
Jordan began to fuck her slowly, using shallow thrusts with only the top-half of his cock for now. The two of them moaned together as Madison enjoyed taking her second cock of the night in her asshole.
It wasn’t long before Jordan was fucking her faster. Madison’s moans and grunts became more frantic as Jordan began to really pound her ass. With each thrust, his balls slapped against her buttcheeks and her body shook. I was surprised Madison was taking his thick cock in her ass so well, but she appeared to love how much he stretched and filled her.
“Your ass is so fucking tight,” Jordan grunted. “I can’t take much more of this.”
“Cum for me,” Madison grunted. “Give my ass a second load of cum. Fuck my tight little asshole, Jordan!”
Jordan did exactly as I had done. He gripped Madison’s side and thrust himself deep into Madison’s ass as he began to unload inside her. He groaned loudly as he pumped her butt full of a second load of thick, white cum. Madison looked like she was in heaven.
“Fuck yeah,” Madison whimpered. The two held eye contact as Jordan’s cock painted the inside of Madison’s ass.
Jordan finished cumming and slid his cock out of Madison. Madison’s tight butt now had a healthy flow of cum dripping out of it onto Ashley’s pillow.
“I think Ashley is gonna need a new pillowcase,” Jordan chuckled, watching as his and my cum slowly trickled out of Madison’s punished hole.
Madison laughed. “You guys really filled me up.”
“Did you like it?” I asked.
“Fuck yeah,” Madison said. “Having you guys fill my butt with your cum was amazing.”
“Are you sore at all?” Jordan asked.
“Hmm,” Madison said, contemplating his question. “Not really? But maybe that’ll change. Hopefully not, though. Do y’all wanna put a towel under my ass real quick?” she asked.
Jordan nodded. I handed him a towel as Madison lifted her butt up off Ashley’s pillow. Jordan slid the towel under her ass and moved Ashley’s pillow.
“Gimmie her pillow,” I said to him.
Jordan handed me the pillow. I slid the pillowcase off and through it on the floor by Ashley’s dirty clothes hamper. I put the pillow back in its original position for now.
Madison was still laying on her back. She had brought her legs up so that they were bent at the knee but still spread, giving Jordan and I a perfect view of her pussy and her asshole. She sighed.