“Jesus Christ,” Ashley said. “Both of y’all have great tits. Holy shit.”
“Thank you,” Alyssa and Madison said. Both were smiling. After letting Ashley look for another few seconds, they lowered their shirts and bras back down.
“Y’know,” Ashley said. “I think we can all agree that we enjoy looking at each other’s tits, right?”
Alyssa glanced at Madison before answering. “Well, yeah.”
“Yes,” Madison said.
“So why don’t we all just take our tops off?”
“I’m down,” Madison said.
“Me too,” Alyssa grinned.
With that, Ashley pulled her shirt up over her head and unhooked her bra. Madison and Alyssa quickly followed suite. The girls tossed their shirts and bras on the floor in front of them.
“This is pretty hot,” Alyssa said, looking around. “Like everyone having their tits out.” Clearly seeing everyone with their tits out was turning Alyssa on.
“Yeah, this is great. Are your nipples hard?” Ashley asked. “Mine are.”
“Very,” Alyssa said. She glanced over at Madison’s tits. “And Madison’s are too.”
“Shall we continue the game?” Madison asked with a smile.
“Yes, let’s keep playing,” Alyssa said. “Whose turn was it again?” They must’ve been fairly drunk to not remember that Ashley went last. But they hadn’t been focused on the game for a few moments.
“I think it was mine,” Ashley said. “But first.” Ashley stood up and hooked her thumbs into her running shorts. She swiftly slid them down her thighs and kicked them off her feet before sitting back down. She was wearing just a black thong now. “Much better,” she said as she sat back down.
Madison looked at Alyssa for a second before standing up and stripping down to her panties too.
“Why are we doing this?” Alyssa said as she too stood up and took off her pants. “Not that I’m opposed.”
“I don’t know, it just sorta feels right,” Ashley shrugged. “I mean, we’re all sitting here with our tits out. Why bother with pants?”
“Works for me,” Alyssa shrugged. Madison nodded in agreement.
“Right. So my turn. Hmm.” Ashley thought for a moment. “Madison, truth or dare?”
“Dare,” Madison said. She hadn’t felt this exposed since she, Brian, and Ashley first started playing together. Sitting here in just her panties with no shirt or bra in front of both her girlfriend and her sister was almost overwhelming.
“I dare you to grope Alyssa’s tits,” Ashley grinned. “While I watch, obviously.”
“Okay,” Madison smiled. At this point, Madison remembered Ashley had been last to go, but who cares?
Alyssa turned to Madison and bit her lip. Madison immediately reached over and squeezed Alyssa’s tits, holding one in each of her hands. Madison gently ran her thumb over Alyssa’s nipples, causing Alyssa to moan softly.
“Oooh, she liked that,” Ashley said. “Keep rubbing her nipples, Madison.”
Alyssa blushed and moaned loudly as Madison ran her thumb back and forth across her nipples.
“Yeah, like that,” Ashley cooed. “You’re making her moan! Don’t stop”
Madison traced her thumbs around Alyssa’s nipples, eliciting another few moans. Madison gently pinched Alyssa’s nipples, causing her to whimper and arch her back. She gripped the edge of the couch cushion as Madison’s fingers continued to tease her nipples.
“Okay, that’s enough. You fulfilled the dare,” Ashley said. “You can go next, Madison.”
“That was a lot,” Alyssa breathed. She was in the process of catching her breath and still recovering from Madison playing with her nipples in front of Ashley. Ashley and Madison laughed.
“No kidding,” Ashley chuckled. “You certainly look like you enjoyed it though.”
“It felt really good,” Alyssa nodded, biting her lip again. She was so turned on she almost couldn’t think straight.
“Alright so Alyssa, truth or dare?” Madison said.
“Everyone seems to be doing dares now so dare.”
Madison smiled. She glanced at Ashley, who met her eyes briefly, before looking back at Alyssa. “I dare you to lick one of Ashley’s nipples.”
Alyssa looked at Madison wide-eyed. “You seriously want me to lick your sister’s nipples?”
“I do,” Madison said. “It’d be hot.”
Alyssa bit her lip and looked at Ashley. “May I?”
“Please,” Ashley smiled. She scooted over slightly and patted the space next to her. “Like I said, I love having my nipples played with.”
Alyssa took a shaky breath before standing up and walking over. She struggled to walk in a perfectly straight line which made Madison giggle. Alyssa sat down next to Ashley, who leaned back a bit and puffed her chest out. She was trying to position herself so Madison would have a good view. Alyssa leaned forward and opened her mouth, sticking her tongue out slightly. Slowly, she moved her head towards Ashley’s chest, incredibly excited at the idea of pleasuring Ashley sexually in some capacity.
Madison watched as Alyssa’s tongue made contact with Ashley’s nipple. At first, Alyssa just sort of held her tongue against Ashley’s breast. Slowly, she began to run her tongue up and down, twirling it around.
“Shit, that feels good,” Ashley moaned softly. She looked down at Alyssa, who was gazing back up at her.
“That’s so hot,” Madison said softly. She had the urge to masturbate, but she restrained herself.
Alyssa got a little more into, flicking her tongue up and down across Ashley’s nipple.
“Oh God,” Ashley groaned. “Please don’t stop, Alyssa.”
Alyssa took all of Ashley’s nipple into her mouth and sucked it gently, twirling her tongue around it and flicking her tongue back and forth, up and down. Ashley placed her hand on the back of Alyssa’s head and moaned, and Alyssa reached over and held onto the sides of Ashley’s stomach, bracing herself for support. Madison was so turned on she almost couldn’t stand it. It was overwhelming.
Ashley stroked Alyssa’s hair gently as Alyssa’s tongue worked her nipple. Alyssa flicked it up and down before twirling it around. Alyssa sucked Ashley’s nipple gently, using her tongue to tease it. Ashley groaned, “Fuck, that feels so good.”
Finally, after letting Alyssa tease Ashley’s nipple with her tongue for a bit longer, Madison said, “Alright, you’ve fulfilled the dare.”
Reluctantly, Alyssa popped Ashley’s tit out of her mouth. She smiled at her girlfriend’s sister before standing up and walking back over to her seat.
“That was really hot,” Ashley said, breathing hard. “And it felt really good.”
“Yeah, that was so hot,” Alyssa agreed. After a pause, she asked, “Is it my turn now?”
“Yep,” Madison said.
“Alright. Ashley, truth or dare?”
“Dare. I’m just always doing dares from here on out, probably,” Ashley said.
“Same,” Alyssa said. “And alright. I dare you…” she trailed off for a second while she thought about what the dare should be. “I dare you to flash us your pussy.”
Ashley smiled. She had no problem with that. Ashley leaned back and spread her legs open. She grabbed her panties and slowly pulled them to the side.
“Holy fuck,” Alyssa breathed. “Holy fucking shit.”
“Oh my God,” Madison said.
The two girls looked hungrily at Ashley’s pussy. Her pretty pink lips were nicely shaved, and as usual there was a neat landing strip right above her pussy.
“Good enough?” Ashley cooed, still holding her panties to the side. She could tell her audience was absolutely entranced by the sight of her sex. Ashley adored being on display like this. Alyssa whimpered softly; Madison just stared hungrily.