“Yes,” Alyssa nodded. “It’s your turn now, Ashley.” Alyssa and Madison kept their eyes glued to Ashley’s crotch until her panties were back in their usual position.
“I’m sorry to be so unoriginal again,”Ashley said slowly. “But I think I’d like to see your pussies — both of you.”
Alyssa blushed and looked at Madison, who returned her look and nodded. Alyssa inhaled sharply and grabbed her panties. She pulled the strip of fabric aside, revealing her pussy to Ashley and Madison. Madison then did the same, pulling her panties to the side, exposing herself in front of her girlfriend and her sister.
Ashley bit her lip as she took in the sight of two gorgeous pussies. Both Alyssa and Madison kept themselves neatly trimmed.
“Fuck yeah,” she said softly. “You guys are both so hot.”
“Thank you,” Alyssa smiled.
“Thanks sis,” Madison said.
Ashley enjoyed the view for another moment before ending the dare. “Okay, that’s good. You guys fulfilled the dare,” Ashley said after a moment. “Back to you, Alyssa.”
Alyssa thought for just a second. “To be honest, I don’t think I’ve seen enough of your pussy yet, Ashley.”
“Is that so?” Ashley cooed.
“And I bet Madison would love to see it again too, as dirty as that is,” Alyssa said. She looked at Madison who just giggled.
“So what’s the dare?” Ashley asked.
Alyssa looked at Ashley. “Take your panties off and spread your legs so we can see everything.”
“You’re so naughty,” Ashley said softly with a smile. She hooked her thumbs into the waistband of her panties and slowly slid them down her legs and off her feet. She tossed the panties on the ground in front of her couch and slowly moved her left leg out to the side, teasing Alyssa and Madison. Carefully, she moved her right leg out to the side, completely exposing herself to her audience.
“Fuck yeah,” Alyssa whispered as Ashley’s pussy came into view, completely unabstructed. She looked at Madison, who turned away from Ashley’s pussy long enough to meet Alyssa’s eyes. “Does it turn you on to look at your sister’s pussy?” Alyssa whispered.
If Madison weren’t drunk, she may have feigned indifference. But that was not the case. Instead, she nodded. “Yes”
Alyssa looked satisfied by Madison’s answer. “That’s so dirty.”
“Is that a bad thing?”
“No, definitely not,” Alyssa grinned. The two girls turned and looked back at Ashley, who still had her legs spread wide open.
“How does it feel having your legs spread in front of us like that, Ashley?” Madison asked.
“Amazing,” Ashley smiled. “It’s a huge turn on. And it’s your turn, I believe.”
Madison turned towards Alyssa, who knew what was coming. “Truth or dare, Alyssa?”
“Dare.” Alyssa didn’t even wait to hear what Madison’s dare was. She hooked her thumbs into her panties and slid them down her legs, tossing them on the ground. She spread her legs open, putting herself and her pussy on display.
“Madison,” Ashley cooed. “I think you should take your panties off too.”
“I agree,” Alyssa said. “We wanna see your pussy again.”
Madison smiled and slid her panties off, tossing them on top of Alyssa’s. She spread her legs too, laying her right leg atop Alyssa’s left.
“This is so hot,” Ashley whispered.
“Is your pussy wet, Ashley?” Alyssa asked.
“Mhmm,” Ashley said. She traced a finger down her slit before pulling it away slowly. A line of pussy juice extended between her body and her finger. “It looks like you guys are wet too.”
“I am,” Madison said. She reached over and began stroking Alyssa’s thigh with her finger tips. Alyssa did the same to her.
“Me too,” Alyssa said. “Is it my turn yet?”
“I think so,” Ashley said. “Truthfully I don’t really remember, but you can just go next.”
“Okay, I actually know what I wanna dare you to do already,” Alyssa said.
“Great,” Ashley grinned. “What is it?”
Alyssa hesitated for a second, which is surprising considering she was three big glasses of wine in, and then spoke. “I dare you to flash your asshole.”
Ashley grinned. “I was wondering if you were gonna ask me to do something like that.”
“You were?” Alyssa asked.
“Mhm,” Ashley said. She stood up and turned her back towards Alyssa and Madison, who were both now staring at Ashley’s big, round butt.
“Goddamn girl,” Alyssa said. “Now that’s an ass!” She reached over and began to play with Madison’s boob. She was mostly squeezing it, but every so often she’d brush Madison’s nipple with her finger.
Ashley bent over a bit and leaned forward, bracing herself against the top of the couch, arching her back slightly.
“Holy shit,” Alyssa grinned. “I’ve never gotten a good look at your butt before Ashley, but holy fuck.”
“You like it?”
“Fuck yeah!” Alyssa said. Madison just laughed.
Ashley reached back and grabbed an asscheek with each hand. Slowly she spread her cheeks apart, giving Alyssa and Madison a perfect view of her pussy and asshole. Ashley was very clearly wet.
“Oh my God,” Madison said. Seeing her sister’s asshole was the ultimate sin; Madison could not get over how dirty it made her feel. She loved it.
“Fuck me,” Alyssa whispered.
“I didn’t know you had a thing for assholes, Alyssa,” Ashley giggled.
“I’m an ass-girl,” Alyssa said. “Therefore I like assholes.”
“I mean, me too,” Ashley said. She was still spreading her buttcheeks apart.
“You’re good,” Alyssa said finally. “I do have a question for you, though.”
Ashley stood up straight and then turned around. She sat back down and spread her legs open again. She began to slowly trace her fingers up and down the sides of her pussy and her inner-thighs. “And what would that be?” she asked as she continued to stroke her thighs.
“You ever take a cock in there?” Alyssa asked, blushing. She was asking Ashley such a dirty, vulgar question.
“In my ass?”
“Mhm,” Alyssa nodded.
Ashley grinned. “Yes, of course. I love being fucked in the ass.”
Alyssa looked at Madison. “Have you ever heard them doing anal? Like could you tell Brian was fucking her in the butt?”
“Yes actually,” Madison laughed. “There have been a few times where I’m walking by her door when she moans something like ‘come in my ass’ or ‘fuck my ass’ or something like that.”
“Holy shit,” Alyssa whispered. “That’s so hot.”
“Yeah, it really is,” Madison admitted.
“I don’t know about you guys,” Ashley said. “But I’m really horny.”
“Me too,” Madison said. “My pussy has been wet this entire time, honestly.”
“Mine too,” Alyssa giggled.
“Would it make either of you uncomfortable if I got myself off?” Ashley asked. She had already started teasing herself with her fingertips; she was slowly running her fingers up and down her slit.
“I would love to see that,” Alyssa said. “What about you, Madison? I bet you’d love to watch your sister masturbate.”
Madison giggled. “I would, actually.”
“You should come sit with us though,” Alyssa said. She scooted over and made room in between her and Madison.
“Yeah, c’mere,” Madison said, patting the space in between her and Alyssa.
Ashley walked over and sat down in between Alyssa and Madison. Each girl spread her legs such that one leg was overlapping with one of the other girls’ legs. For example, Ashley had both of her legs atop the left and right legs of Alyssa and Madison.