Suddenly, someone taps him on his shoulder and he turns around. His heart almost stop. Behind him is Josh. Carter desperate hopes that his friend didn’t hear everything. Fortunately, Josh gives him a smile and the boys embrace. “Hey! Good to see you back, man. You’ll have to tell me about all the stuff you did while you were away,” Josh says to him. It makes Carter flinches as he thinks about he definitely can’t tell him about all the stuff he did. He did do his friend’s girlfriend, after all.
“I’m not sure that you would like hearing all of it, Josh,” Christine pipes in with a mischievous glow in her eyes, making Josh confused and Carter panicked. Carter desperately pleads with her through eye contact to not say anything. “Our dear friend here did many questionable things. You wouldn’t want to hear all about his escapades.” Then she saunters away, cackling, her large, firm ass swaying from side to side as she walks, giving everyone around a great view of her ample derriere. Josh looks away, not wanting to be tempted by another girl.
He now watches his friend’s fidgety expression, curious. Something really seems off about the way Carter is acting. Josh tries to understand why his best friend might be so nervous but he couldn’t figure it out. It is all very perplexing to him. “What was she talking about?” he asks the much stronger teen. “Did you, like, got a little wild with someone?” If only he knew who that someone is, their friendship would fall apart right then and there. Carter knows he has to be very convincing to avoid this from going tits up.
“Nothing! It was nothing, Josh,” he says, trying to sound like he’s not hiding anything, failing. Fortunately, someone else shows up. Unfortunately, it’s Elizabeth, who becomes horny for him again right after seeing his face. She loves only Josh but seeing Carter again makes the guilty feeling goes away, replaced by arousal. Adjusting the hem of his shirt, he tries to think of a way to avoid a clusterfuck. “Um, hi Elizabeth. Nice to see you again,” he murmurs, hoping Josh wouldn’t notice his immediate reaction. Damn his penis for being so unruly and getting hard when it’s most inconvenient! Josh turns to kiss his girlfriend’s cheek, making her beam before turning back to smile at Carter.
“Good to see you, Carter,” she says to him in a friendly, conversational tone. She then says to Josh “Can I borrow him for a moment, baby? There’s something I want to talk to you about.” Josh nods and she walks towards Carter. “Come on, buddy. Let’s go talk somewhere else.” It’s good that Josh is not a jealous boy. Otherwise, he’d definitely notice that something is going on between them. Instead, he just strolls around to try to find someone he can talk to. He doesn’t really like social events very much and only turned up for his girlfriend. No other reason for it.
Once they are outside and out of anyone’s earshot, Elizabeth begins eye-fucking Carter, looking up and down his stocky frame. “How have you been, handsome?” she asks him. “Did you enjoy your holiday?” He nods uncomfortable, wanting to leave but wishing to avoid causing a scene and drawing attention to themselves. “Bet it must have been very fun to travel about. Wish I could do the same sometimes, but my parents wouldn’t let me.” It doesn’t help that she is so pretty, being one of the two most beautiful girls at their school, the other being Christine.
“It was pretty fun,” he finally manages to say. The boy looks down at the ground, taking deep, calming breaths and wishing the ground would open up and swallow him whole right now. She is staring at his handsome face very intently and he wishes she would stop. Not that he doesn’t enjoy the affection of a hot girl, but the fact that she is his friend’s girlfriend really ruins it. “My dad complained that I spent too much money though, which was a fair point, since I really did over-indulge myself.” He scratches the back of his neck with a nervous laugh.
She walks up towards his powerful body, feeling his strong arms with her dainty hands. “Did you fuck any hot European chicks while you were there?” Elizabeth asks him, making his eyes go as wide as saucers. “You can be honest about it. You fucked many, did you?” In point of fact he did. “And I bet you thought about me a lot too. You thought about my face and body when you fucked them. Did you picture my tits in your mind when you cummed deep inside their cunts?”
As much as Carter is getting turned on by this conversation, he has to be the mature, responsible one and pull away. “Yes, I fucked a bunch of Europeans on holiday and I thought about you while balls deep inside of them. But we can’t do what we did again. I already feel bad enough after just one time. Please just go back to the party, okay?” Elizabeth pouts cutely, trying to work him over with her allure, knowing how much boys are affected by it.
“Aw! Why not?” she asks him in a very cutesy tone, biting her lower lip and fluttering her eyelashes at him. The girl reaches over to touch his strong, broad shoulders, feeling herself get wet from how muscular they are. “Don’t you remember how good it felt to stick your cock all the way up my pussy, baby? It felt so good to ride you, bouncing up and down on your lap. Then you took me from behind, pounding my ass and stretching my asshole open, gaping it. You must have dumped gallons of cum inside my holes that night. And it was just one night too. We could do it again several times.”
“No, we can never do it again. I’m very serious about this Elizabeth,” he says to her, surprising the girl by his adamant rejection. She thought he would be all over her like he was on that fateful day. “Josh is my best friend. He is like my brother and you are his girlfriend. We can never betray him again.” His words bring sense back to her and she feels so ashamed of what she did but she still can’t stop being horny for Carter.