Before we cleaned up dinner, Caitlyn sent me out to uncover the hot tub and start it heating. That was when I realized how bad the snow was. I had to shovel a path over the short distance between our back door and the tub.
We finished the dishes and Caitlyn asked Sherry and Craig to go into the living room. Caitlyn and I stripped off in the kitchen and walked out to rejoin our guests, nude and holding hands. Seeing Caitlyn nude, and without thinking, Craig said “wow!” He was right. Caitlyn was a “wow” clothed and extremely “wow” nude. Craig’s remark still earned him a slap in the chest from Sherry.
“Peter looks pretty great naked too,” Sherry said.
“Ok guys,” Caitlyn said, “it’s decision time. We’re going out to the tub. I hope you go nude like we are but, if you prefer, you can change into swimsuits in the guest bedroom upstairs and leave your street clothes up there.”
Buying time, I think, Sherry said, “Either way, we need something for our feet. It’s snowing out there.”
“That we can handle,” Caitlyn replied. She walked across the room to a low chest against the far wall. With her back to Sherry and Craig, she bent over and opened the bottom drawer. She fished around for a moment, holding a pose that exposed her completely to our guests. They both looked. Caitlyn straightened, and turned, holding several pair of rubber flip flops. Smiling, and fully aware she had just shown off to Sherry and Craig, Caitlyn said, “I’m sure something here will fit you well enough.” Caitlyn walked back to where I was standing in front of Sherry and Craig.
“You really enjoy people seeing all of you, don’t you?” Sherry asked Caitlyn.
“I do,” Caitlyn responded. “It’s sexy and exciting. I’m fortunate enough to have a body some people think is attractive. It’s never made sense to me why I should be ashamed of that and hide parts of myself. It really is fun. You should try it.”
“I don’t look like you,” Sherry said.
“Sherry’s a beautiful woman, isn’t she Craig?” Caitlyn asked.
“Very beautiful,” Craig replied immediately.
Sherry gave a short laugh. “He has to say that, he’s my boyfriend.”
“Sherry,” I said, “I’ve never seen you out of uniform until tonight. The all black and the gun on your hip are a bit intimidating. When you took those off, you became more beautiful. You’ll be more beautiful still if you take everything off. I’ve never met a woman who wasn’t.”
Sherry gave Craig a questioning look. “It’s your call,” he said. “These are your friends.”
Sherry stood quietly for a long moment, the expression on her face suggesting she was genuinely torn. Finally, she said, “what the hell? Got to try new things.” She kicked off her shoes and pulled her sweater over her head.
Sherry was a somewhat fleshy woman. While she was not unattractive, I thought she likely would be very attractive if she dropped a few pounds. However, the extra flesh gave her nudity a naturalness that was quite sexy. In contrast, Craig did not appear to carry an ounce of fat. He wasn’t big but was all taut muscle. I outweighed him by at least 50 pounds, and was well-muscled myself, but I’d have not wanted to get into a fight with him.
The four of us went outside nude. It was cold and some more snow had accumulated between the door and the tub. We all scurried towards the steaming water. Sherry and Craig sat together on one side of the tub while Caitlyn and I sat together opposite them. We hadn’t been in the tub long before I was sent inside and get everyone more wine. The snow was over my bare feet as I went back to the house.
I looked at the front window of our house and saw that snow had piled up on the street. I went to the kitchen and uncorked two fresh bottles. I carried those and four plastic cups out to the tub. I placed the wine on a little stand we’d installed for that purpose, gratefully got back into the hot water, and poured everyone a cup. “You might as well drink up,” I said as I handed wine to Sherry and Craig, “you’re not driving anywhere tonight.”
“You can use our guest bedroom,” Caitlyn said cheerfully.
Cold as it was outside, the water felt hot after being in it a while. We had the tub built with a ledge around the top where a person could sit with only her feet in the water. After she finished a cup of wine, Caitlyn hopped up there to cool down for a few moments. She sat with her legs spread. I knew she was enjoying Sherry and Craig looking at her.
After quite a while, Sherry rose from the water and sat on the ledge. She was watching me, I think, to see whether I was looking at her. At first, she kept her knees locked together. I saw her take a deep breath, then she spread her legs apart. She was staring at me the entire time. I think she felt some embarrassment from being so fully exposed but was also excited and wanted to be seen.
Caitlyn and Sherry both sat on the tub ledge until they got too cold and slid back into the hot water. That was followed by a series of requests that had me repeatedly leaving the tub to bring things from the house. The third time I was walking back to the tub, Sherry said, “I like how Peter’s dick is so thick. It is nice to watch. It must feel wonderful.”
“It feels fantastic,” Caitlyn replied. “But” she continued, “I haven’t gotten a good opportunity to look at Craig’s.”
“Craig, get up on the ledge and let Caitlyn see you,” Sherry commanded. Craig gave me a resigned look, but he stood up and seated himself on the ledge. “Get those legs apart,” Sherry directed. Craig’s penis was narrow but quite long.
“I imagine Craig feels pretty good too,” Caitlyn told Sherry.
“He feels great,” Sherry replied. She laughed. “But he’s too long for me to get all of him in my mouth.” I got the sense that Craig enjoyed Caitlyn looking at his dick and the two women discussing it. I could empathize with that.
We stayed in the tub. We showed off to each other and discussing each other’s body parts until we emptied both bottles of wine. The others went inside while I shut down the tub and put the lid on. I was freezing by the time I got in the house. I heard water in the large shower we had installed next to the sauna. When I went there, I saw Caitlyn, Sherry, and Craig inside. “Get your butt in here,” Caitlyn ordered. I followed orders. The four of us showered together, but we all kept our hands off the others’ partner.
The next morning, Caitlyn and I were in the kitchen, nude, making coffee. Sherry walked in wearing one of the fluffy robes we kept in the guest bedroom closet. Seeing us, she said, “Guess I don’t need this.” Sherry took the robe off. I was pleased to see she was naked underneath it. Craig walked in a moment later in a pair of shorts which he took off upon seeing that the rest of us were nude.
As we were drinking our coffee, Sherry said, “Uh, well, uh, Craig and I were talking last night. We’ve really enjoyed the video of the two of you fucking, but it seems, well, a little one-sided. Uh, would the two of you like to watch us fuck?”
“Sure,” Caitlyn said, “that would be great, and it is so kind of you to offer!” I glanced at Craig. I’d expected a look of resignation, like he’d given me the night before. Instead, I saw something different, excitement?