I couldn’t believe my luck, I was only teasing her, I didn’t think for a minute she would actually let me fuck her ass.
“Are you sure, Jess?” I asked. “You don’t have to if you don’t want to.”
“What’s the matter?” She asked, gripping my cock with her pussy, “Don’t you want to?”
“Only if you want this.” I replied.
“Oh, I want it all right, now get me lubed up!”
I flipped the top of the lotion and dripped some down on her tight ass-hole. I slid the lube up and down her crack, working some into her ass-hole with my finger, getting her nice and ready.
When I thought she was good to go, I pulled out of her cunt and placed the head of my cock at her ass, pressing gently. Jessica groaned slightly as the head popped in her ass. I felt a little resistance as I pressed forward, but soon it gave way and I slid inch by inch into her ass until my hips rested against her ass cheeks.
I stopped there, letting Jessica get used to the feeling. Soon, she started moving a little, and I pulled out just an inch or so before sliding back in. Jessica reached a hand down between her legs and started rubbing her clit as she started moving faster.
“It feels good, baby,” Jessica said, “Just go gently for a minute, and when I tell you, you can start fucking me harder.”
I did as told, not wanting to rush this. I was gently thrusting in and out, feeling her ass clench at each thrust, not wanting to let me out. The lube did its job, and soon I was sliding in and out with ease.
“Ok, honey, you can start fucking me harder, as hard as you want. I can take it.”
I took her at her word and started thrusting harder and faster, grabbing her hips so I could get more leverage. Her ass gripped me as I got closer to orgasm, and soon, I could feel my cum starting to rise. My thrusts got more erratic, and Jessica could tell I was close.
“That’s it, baby. Cum when it feels good, I want to feel your cock explode in my ass. Give me that cum!”
“I gonna cum Jess!!” I yelled as I thrust one last time in her ass, burying my cock deep as I came inside her ass.
I slumped against her back as I shivered all over, coming down from an orgasmic high. My cock slowly softened and slid from her grasping ass as I fell to the bed beside Jessica. Jess was soon lying on her side next to me, her hand across my chest. We lay there, letting our breathing return to normal, when I heard a noise across the room. I looked at the door and was startled to see someone standing there! Another woman!
I nudged Jessica and pointed at the door. Jess smiled and motioned for the other person to come in the room. I didn’t think the night could get any more surprising, but I was wrong. As the girl came closer, I got another shock. It was the blonde stripper I was watching just before Jess approached me at the club: Alison!
“Ray, I’d like you to meet my roommate, Allie”…..