Madison laughed. “Yeah babe, I think it’s about time you showed us the goods.”
“Agreed,” I said. “Your panties have gotta come off.”
“Jesus,” Alyssa said. She sighed and brought her legs together. She hooked her thumbs into her panties and began to slowly pull them down.
“Ho-ly fuck,” I said under my breath. Alyssa’s pussy slowly came into view. She had her legs pressed together, meaning her pussy lips were pressed up against each other. She looked incredibly tight. Immediately I thought again about how good it’d feel to slide my painfully-hard cock inside her right then and there. I honestly doubt anybody would have complained, especially not Alyssa. But I just sat there and drank in the view. Below her pussy was our target, her asshole, which honestly looked equally inviting.
“My God,” Ashley said. “Your pussy looks so fucking good.”
“So does your ass,” I said.
“Agreed,” Madison said. “You’re so hot, baby.”
“Thanks guys,” Alyssa said, still clearly embarrassed to have everything out on display. Despite this, however, she tossed her panties onto the ground and spread her legs again. The view was absolutely incredible. I wanted to fuck her so badly, as did Ashley and Madison, I’m sure.
“Okay,” Ashley said. “You ready?”
“I think so,” Alyssa breathed. “I’m the weirdest combination of drunk, horny, and embarrassed right now.”
“Sounds like the perfect combination for your first experience with butt stuff!” Madison giggled.
“Alright,” Ashley said. “Madison, go ahead and squirt some lube on her ass.”
Madison nodded and uncapped the bottle of lube. She moved closer to Alyssa and held the bottle over her ass. Slowly, Madison squeezed a big drop of lube onto Alyssa’s asshole.
“Eep!” Alyssa said. “It’s cold!”
“Sorry,” Madison said. “Too cold?”
“No, no,” Alyssa said. “It just surprised me.”
Madison capped the lube and began to slowly massage the lube around Alyssa’s asshole.
“Oh wow,” Alyssa said. “That actually feels really good. Surprisingly.”
“That’s a good sign,” Ashley grinned. I noticed Ashley had her hand between her legs and was very slowly rubbing her clit over her panties. I don’t think Alyssa or Madison noticed though.
Madison positioned herself so that she was basically on her hands and knees, though she was leaning her body against the back of the couch a bit so as to give us as good a view as possible of the action between Alyssa’s legs. And we had a pretty good view. Ashley and I were enjoying a gorgeous look at Alyssa’s pretty, pink pussy and below that, her tight little asshole.
“Alright, I’m gonna start putting my finger inside, okay?” Madison said.
“Mhm,” Alyssa said. She took a deep breath as Madison pressed her finger against Alyssa’s asshole. Madison only had to press for a second before the tip of her finger slipped inside.
“Oh shit,” Alyssa said. She had a weird look on her face. This was definitely her first time experimenting with putting something in her ass. She closed her eyes, maybe trying to focus on how she was feeling.
“How’s that?” Madison asked. She was holding the tip of her finger inside Alyssa’s butt. She was only maybe one knuckle deep at this point.
“Weird,” Alyssa said. “But not bad. Just… very weird. You can do a little more.”
Madison nodded and pressed her finger in a bit more. She stopped once she was two knuckles deep.
“Can you guys see okay, by the way?” Madison looked back, grinning.
“Oh yeah,” I said. I had a great view. I could see Alyssa’s pretty pink pussy and Madison’s finger halfway inside Alyssa’s ass.
“I’m good too,” Ashley said.
Madison noticed that Ashley was masturbating. She smiled and watched Ashley touch herself for a brief second before returning her attention back to Alyssa.
“How are you doin’, baby?” Madison asked.
“Good,” Alyssa said. “Can you do your whole finger now?”
“Sure,” Madison said.
Ashley and I watched lustfully as Madison slid the remainder of her finger to Alyssa’s ass.
“How does that feel?” Madison asked.
“Really nice,” Alyssa cooed. She reached down and began to rub her clit. “Do you want to start fingering me?”
“Like in and out?”
“Mhm.”
“Fuck yeah,” Madison grinned. She slowly slid her finger out of Alyssa’s ass until it was just one knuckle deep. I glanced over and saw that Ashley’s hand had moved inside her panties. I thought about jerking off, but I decided to hold off for the time being.
Alyssa moaned softly as Madison pressed her finger all the way back inside her ass. She continued toying with her clit as Madison began to finger her, maintaining a slow and steady rhythm. Alyssa was still laid back on the couch in front of us, legs spread wide open. She had her head back now, and her eyes were still closed. She was definitely focused on enjoying the feeling of Madison’s finger sliding in and out of her ass.
I glanced over at Madison and realized that we actually had a great view of Madison’s ass too; I had just been so focused on Alyssa that I hadn’t realized it. Like I said, Madison was on her hands and knees, which is already a sight to behold. But she was also wearing that skimpy little thong, which made her look even more sexy. Her pussy lips were just barely covered, and I could see most of her asshole behind the fabric. I couldn’t believe I had just spent a good part of the evening fucking that tight little asshole of hers. In fact, some of my cum was presumably still inside her.
“Madison,” Ashley whispered quietly. I don’t think she wanted Alyssa to hear, but that was bold given Alyssa and Madison were basically equally far away from where Ashley and I were sitting.
That being said, it seemed like Alyssa was too focused on having her ass fingered for the first time to notice. Either that, or she didn’t react if she heard Ashley. But Madison heard Ashley, so she slowly turned her head and looked back.
Ashley pointed at Madison’s butt, then reached down and pulled her own thong to the side for a second, flashing her pussy at Madison. Then Ashley gestured towards Madison’s butt again.
Madison furrowed her brow for a second, clearly confused, until it clicked for her. Madison turned back towards Alyssa. She reached back with her free hand and pulled her thong to the side. She positioned it so that it was now stretched across one of her ass cheeks, giving us a completely unobstructed view of her pussy and her asshole.
I looked at Ashley and nodded approvingly. She gave me a wink before turning back to enjoy the view, continuing to masturbate, obviously. I focused my attention on Madison for a moment. I swear, I will never get tired of looking at that girl’s bare ass when she’s on her hands and knees. Her pussy looked so good; she was incredibly wet, and I’m sure it would’ve felt incredible to slide my cock inside her. And above her pussy, of course, was that tight little asshole that I fucked earlier this evening. It honestly required a bit of self control to stop myself from getting up and walking over to fuck Madison’s brains out right then and there.
“Baby,” Alyssa said softly. “I think I want a second finger in my ass.”
“You got it,” Madison said. She reached for the lube, uncapped it, and squirted some more around the finger that was already embedded in Alyssa’s ass. She capped the lube, placing it back down beside her.