“Oh my God,” Alyssa gasped as she found her rhythm. She bucked her hips steadily. “Oh my God. Oh my fucking God.”
The room was filled with the sounds of our fucking. Alyssa was so incredibly wet. Everybody could very clearly hear the sound of my cock sliding in and out of her pussy as she rode me. And she felt incredible — her pussy was so warm, so wet, so tight. I hoped this was my first of many times inside her.
“I can’t believe I’m fucking you,” Alyssa breathed as her pussy moved up and down my shaft. Her lips were gripping me so tightly; it felt amazing.
“Me neither,” I moaned. “Your pussy feels so fucking good.”
“So does your cock,” she whimpered.
The two of us continued fucking like this for a while. To our right (well, my right, Alyssa’s left), Ashley sat, legs spread, masturbating furiously to the sight of another woman riding her boyfriend’s cock. And sitting on the ground in front of us, Madison was taking in the sight of my cock disappearing inside her girlfriend’s pussy. She watched my balls bounce rhythmically as Alyssa slammed herself up and down onto me, and as loud gasps and moans escaped our lips. Madison could see how wet her girlfriend was for me. She watched Alyssa’s lips gripping my cock as she rode me. And she could hear how incredible I was making Alyssa feel. I wondered if she cared that Alyssa was enjoying my cock in her pussy first.
For a while, Alyssa would do the work. She would bounce her ass up and down while I sat back and enjoyed the feeling of her pussy gripping my cock. Some of the time, the two of us would kiss. Sometimes I would take her nipples into my mouth and suck them or flick them with my tongue. I groped her tits and squeezed her ass, spanking her good and hard. She cried out with a picture of pleasure and pain every time I slapped her ass.
Other times, Alyssa would rest for a moment. She would brace herself against me, and I’d brace myself against her, holding her hips tightly as I began to thrust upward into her pussy. She moaned the loudest when I did the work; I could fuck her much harder and much faster than she could ride me. Clearly she loved having her pussy pounded. Yet again, we were lucky I’d spent so long fucking Madison’s ass, or else I wouldn’t have lasted two minutes inside Alyssa. Especially when I was fucking her like that.
We fucked for another minute or two before Alyssa was on the brink.“I’m going to come,” she whimpered. “Brian I’m going to come on your cock!”
“Good girl,” I said, looking into her eyes. I spanked her ass and grabbed her tits. “Come for me. Come on my cock like a good little slut! Your girlfriend is watching, remember? She’s watching you take my cock. Don’t you want Madison to watch you come on my big cock?”
“Yes,” Alyssa cried out. “Yes, fuck me, I’m gonna come! Oh my God, I’m coming!”
Alyssa leaned forward, clutching me hard as her climax hit. She moaned loudly and dug her nails into my back as I took over and began fucking her, trying my best to match the pace she had been riding me.
“Keep fucking me,” she begged. “Shit!”
I held her hips with both hands as I fucked my cock in and out of her pussy. It was hard to stop myself from cumming as I felt Alyssa’s pussy pulse and throb around my cock.
“Fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck,” Alyssa breathed. “Shit! Fuck me, holy fuck, oh my GOD!”
“Holy FUCK,” I heard Madison say, though I couldn’t see her. I briefly wondered if she was masturbating before my focus returned entirely to the feeling of Alyssa’s pussy climaxing around my cock.
Finally, after what felt like well over a minute (though in reality it was probably not quite that long), Alyssa’s orgasm finished. She collapsed in a heap on top of me. She was breathing hard. She brought her head up, grabbed my face in her hands, and kissed me deeply.
“Thank you for that,” she said. My cock was still inside her, of course. “Holy shit.”
“How was it?” Ashley asked.
“Just… wow,” Alyssa sighed. “Fucking amazing. You definitely lived up to all of Ashley’s hype.” She winked at me. “I hope you enjoyed my pussy as much as I enjoyed that cock of yours.”
“Oh, I did,” I grinned. “You’re an incredible fuck. If I wasn’t drunk, there’s no way I would’ve been able to last through your orgasm. That felt amazing.”
“We’ll have to go at it again sometime,” she smiled back. “Soon, I hope. There are a few more positions I’d love to fuck you in.” She turned her head and looked at Ashley. “And I wouldn’t mind getting you off in my pussy next time.”
“Yes, please,” I grinned. The thought of pumping a load inside of Alyssa’s pussy was… wow, yeah, that would be great. And if Alyssa stayed interested in anal, then maybe I could fill her ass up just like I had done with Madison earlier.
“Can I join you on the couch, Ashley?” Alyssa asked.
“Of course, baby girl,” Ashley said.
Slowly, Alyssa came up off my cock. I was actually disappointed as I felt myself leave her pussy. But my disappointment was not long for this world. Alyssa walked over to the couch on which Ashley was masturbating. She sat beside her, catching her breath for a moment, before leaning over and kissing Ashley, who enthusiastically kissed her back. I bet they would’ve started making out, and honestly that might have progressed to them having sex, but they stopped before things got too far. They didn’t want to miss the upcoming show, after all.
Madison, who had been watching Alyssa walk over to sit with Ashley, turned her attention back to me. Our eyes met as she rose up off the ground and walked over to me. Like her girlfriend before her, Madison carefully climbed onto my lap. But unlike her girlfriend before her, Madison was in a familiar position. My hands found her ass, and then Madison’s top was on the floor. I took her left nipple into my mouth and sucked it gently. She ran her hands through my hair and moaned softly.
“Are you ready?” I asked her softly, briefly taking her nipple out of my mouth before continuing to suck it softly.
“Yes,” was her response. “I’ve wanted this for so long. And I’m so horny after watching Alyssa take your cock like that.”
“Me too.”
Without breaking our gaze, I felt Madison’s hand wrap around my cock. I felt her shift into position as she aligned my cock with her pussy. She held still for a moment, with the head of my cock pressed up against her. She took a deep breath, and slowly, she took me inside her.
Finally. The two of us had been waiting for this moment for a long, long time. We looked into one another’s eyes as Madison sank down. She moved slowly, savoring every inch of me that entered her. She moaned softly as I bottomed out inside her pussy for the very first time.
“Oh my God,” she whimpered.
She braced herself against my chest and slowly began to rock her hips. The tight grip of Madison’s pussy was intoxicating. She felt different than Alyssa. Not better, not worse, just different. But like Alyssa, Madison was unbelievably wet. No doubt she was as turned on as I was. Ashley stopped masturbating for a moment, taking in the sight of her boyfriend fucking her little sister for the first time.