8- My High School Sweetheart’s Little Sister -pt. 8 (Practicing with Stacy / Poolside) by JadeGrey

Cindy flinched and opened her eyes, “Jeff!”

I just laughed realizing Cindy thought it was me who untied her. I started to massage her back, then motioned to Stacy to take over. I lifted one hand and she leaned forward and replaced it with one of hers. I lifted the other and Stacy replaced it as well. All was normal in Cindy’s mind until I started massaging her feet. Only a moment passed before Cindy jerked her eyes open and flipped her head the other way and saw her friend rubbing her back.

Stacy didn’t skip a beat, “I was getting bored… I thought I’d lend a hand.”

Cindy laughed, “okay… I guess I can’t complain,” and laid her head back down and closed her eyes.

Stacy was working Cindy’s lower back and running her hands up her sides. Cindy giggled when her hands ran up her ribs. I worked up her legs to her thighs, and motioned to Stacy to swap places.

So Cindy wouldn’t notice, Stacy and I swapped one hand at a time until I was rubbing Cindy’s back and Stacy was massaging her thighs. Stacy quickly started rubbing higher and deeper inside her thighs, until her hands were brushing against Cindy’s crotch. Thinking it was my fingers rubbing her, Cindy opened her legs a bit more, and arched her ass upwards so ‘I’ had better access.

I was trying to use a lighter touch on Cindy’s back so she wouldn’t recognize the swap. So far… so good.

Stacy pulled her hands back, and with one move untied both sides of Cindy’s bikini bottoms. Cindy didn’t react until Stacy pulled the material down and poured baby oil all over Cindy’s exposed butt.

Cindy gasped and opened her eyes, “Jeff!”

Stacy started rubbing the oil all over Cindy’s ass, and laughed, “It wasn’t Jeff, girlfriend!”

Cindy raised up enough to turn her head around and see Stacy’s hands on her ass, “Really? Oh my god, Stace…”, then turned her head to the other side to look at me. I just smiled and continued to massage her back. She laid her head back down, but her eyes were still open. Her face told me she was a bit nervous.

Stacy was not… not nervous in the least. She was rubbing the oil all over Cindy’s ass, and down deep between her thighs. After little more massaging, it seemed that Cindy was slowly getting more comfortable with the situation. I was watching her expression, and her legs and ass, to tell if she was enjoying herself or was about to bolt. She was now smiling, and she opened up her legs a little more when Stacy was rubbing between her thighs.

I had dropped my towel long ago and when I looked down my dick was pretty erect, down the right leg of my boxers. It was lifting up the material to the point I think Stacy could see the head poking out. But her eyes were on Cindy’s ass as she massaged it.

…..I stared at Stacy’s body in the tiny bikini. Although still a young girl, she was more developed than Cindy, with curves and hips, and nice round titties growing under that tiny top. My memory of her large nipples and areolas was vivid, and I wanted to see them out in the open… in the sun. I wanted to feel her pussy again… I needed to suck her fleshy labia and taste her… I had to push my cock into that tight little pussy of hers… inch by inch…

“You don’t want tan lines!”, I said and reached over and pulled Stacy’s straps down off her shoulders. Stacy just laughed, and reached up and untied the bow in the center and pulled off her top.

Seeing those round little titties with the huge nipples, sitting so high and firm on her chest, made me appreciate her even more than just the moment before. I had never fantasized over large areolas like hers before, but now I had to suck on them. They somehow made her look more ‘naked’ than the typical boobs I saw in porn mags, especially on such a young girl (which I never saw in any porn mags).

I realized I was getting distracted and turned my attention back to Cindy. She seemed to be enjoying the attention; she was much more relaxed and still had a smile on her face. Her eyes were closed and I wondered if she could tell whose hands were rubbing on her. I moved my hands down her back to the top of her ass, and slid my fingers down between her cheeks. Stacy was still rubbing between her thighs, up close to her crotch.

….… I was pretty sure Stacy would take the bait if I just created an opportunity

I rolled up a towel, grabbed Cindy’s hips and lifted her up, and slid the towel under her. When I let her back down, her back arched up so her little pink ass and pussy were more open and facing upwards. I looked over at Stacy and she was obviously enjoying seeing her friend so exposed. Her sunglasses were still blocking her eyes so I pulled them off her head. She barely reacted, her eyes still locked on Cindy’s pussy and ass. She finally started her massage again, this time up higher between Cindy’s thighs; the sides of her palms rubbing against her pussy.

The bright sun illuminated Cindy’s crotch so well… we could see everything in detail. The oil glistened on her sparse pubic hair on either side of her lips. I took both hands and spread her ass apart, and her tiny pussy popped open. A bead of lube strung across her tiny hole, which looked just a little larger than the last time I saw it. Stacy leaned forward to look more closely at her friend. She grabbed a bottle from a bag next to her and squirted a bunch of oil right down between Cindy’s cheeks.

“I don’t think baby oil is the safest thing for that.”

Stacy just held the bottle up for me to see. The label said ‘Personal Lubricant’. “I got this from my mom’s side table”, she said, giggling, “She keeps all sorts of sex toys in there and doesn’t expect her innocent little girl would ever go snooping around.”

…..Cindy was still smiling… eyes closed. I wondered if they had played with any of those toys

Stacy then slid her hands down the crack of Cindy’s butt. I spread Cindy’s ass wider to give her better access, and Stacy immediately slid her middle finger down over her ass, into her pussy.

Cindy gave a short gasp, but arched her ass upwards a little and moaned quietly in approval.

…….the view of Stacy staring at Cindy like that, mouth agape, little round titties exposed, with her finger in Cindy’s pussy, was one of the most erotic images I had ever seen

Still holding her cheeks open, I crawled up on the chaise and knelt down between Cindy’s legs. Scooting up closer I noticed Stacy had redirected her gaze from Cindy to my boxers, which had inched up my legs. My cock was sticking out the right leg, fully erect. Still fingering Cindy’s pussy with her right hand, Stacy reached out and grabbed the head of my cock with her left. She pushed her hand up the shaft, further pulling back the leg of my boxers, then squeezed hard and pulled back to the head, milking a large amount of pre-cum out onto her fingers. She then pulled her hand up to her mouth, and while looking straight at me, she licked the lube off her fingers. She then ran her tongue over her lips, and flirtatiously batted her eyes.

……Dammit, I need to fuck this little girl

I pulled my right hand from Cindy’s ass and reached out to Stacy’s crotch, and pushed my fingers down the front of her bikini bottoms. As I expected, her pussy was drenched; a thick flood of lube covered my fingers. I pulled my hand from her crotch and grabbed her little breasts, pinching her nipples and covering her with her own juices.

Leave a Comment