Slowly, Ashley began to trace her middle finger up and down her slit as her sister did the same. Each girls’ eyes watched greedily as they pleasured themselves. Madison slid just her middle finger inside of her, moaning as she entered herself. Ashley did the same, except she slid both her index and her middle finger inside her. Both girls began to fuck themselves gently, Madison quickly adding a second finger to her pussy. Once Ashley’s fingers were sufficiently coated with her juices, she moved up to her clit, rubbing it in a circular motion. Madison continued to finger herself, increasing her speed slightly. Both girls were moaning softly.
“I love watching you touch yourself,” Ashley cooed.
Madison smiled shyly. “You’re so hot,” she said softly.
Madison slid her fingers out of her pussy and began to rub her clit. She moved her fingers in a left-to-right motion, thrusting her hips gently as she pleasured herself.
“I think I’m ready to try,” Madison said after another moment. “How do I go about this exactly?”
Ashley paused for a moment. “Normally I masturbate in bed so I can sort of prop myself up comfortably and use two hands, but that’s not as easy here.”
“Right,” Madison said.
“You know,” Ashley said slowly. “If you wanted, I could…” she trailed off, unsure how to phrase her thought.
“What?”
Ashley thought for a moment. “Well, to put it bluntly, I could play with your ass for you so you could keep rubbing your clit.”
Madison turned bright red and didn’t speak. She didn’t look horrified by Ashley’s suggestion or anything — just surprised.
“It’s just that it makes the experience a lot better if you’re rubbing your clit,” Ashley explained. “At least for the first time. Once you’re comfortable with it, obviously you don’t need to be touching your clit. But it really helps when you’re learning.”
“Right,” Madison said. “I understand.”
“If you don’t want me to do that, then that’s fine,” Ashley shrugged. “Like I don’t care obviously. Whatever works for you.”
Madison thought for a moment. Perhaps she was considering how Alyssa would feel if Ashley played with her (Madison’s) asshole, but Madison didn’t vocalize her thoughts in this moment as far as I know.
“If you think it would be best,” Madison said slowly after a moment. “Then you can.”
“Are you sure?” Ashley asked. “I only want to do this if you are absolutely certain that you’re comfortable with it and everything.”
“Yeah,” Madison said. “I mean, you’re my sister. I trust you obviously. And you’ve already played with my tits and everything.” She shrugged. “Touching my booty isn’t too much worse than sucking on my nipples.”
Ashley laughed. “Well, when you put it that way, I guess.”
“So what now?”
“Well, if I’m gonna be the one touchin’ your ‘booty’,” Ashley said. “Then you may as well just lay all the way down.”
Madison nodded and laid down on her back. Ashley considered the fact that this would be significantly easier if they were just in Madison’s bedroom, but it did make sense to do this in a bathroom since it was Madison’s first time experimenting with anal. What really would’ve made sense is to do this in the shower, but there wasn’t enough space for that.
“Now just sorta bring your legs up a bit and spread them.”
Madison did as Ashley said. She bent her knees and spread her legs. Ashley scooted up so that she was sitting almost in between her sister’s open legs. The sight before her was almost enough to overwhelm her — Madison was completely exposed. Her tits were out and her legs were spread wide open, meaning Madison’s pussy and asshole were on full display. Ashley had butterflies in her stomach from seeing her sister in such an intimate, erotic position.
“Would it be weird if I said you have a nice butthole?” Ashley asked, giggling.
“No, that wouldn’t be weird,” Madison laughed.
“Okay,” Ashley said, still giggling. “In that case, you have a really nice butthole, Madison.”
Madison just rolled her eyes and laughed. “Thanks, Ashley.”
“Alright.” Ashley said a bit more seriously. “So you should just keep masturbating like you were before. You can finger your pussy too, if you want. Just try to keep your hand up away from your ass so I have room.”
“Okay,” Madison said. She happily resumed playing with her clit. She was fairly nervous, but she was incredibly horny too, and thus very happy to be able to continue masturbating.
Ashley placed both of her hands on the inside of her sister’s thighs, causing Madison to jump. Ashley quickly pulled her hands back.
“No, no,” Madison said. “You can put your hands there. I was just startled; I don’t know why.”
“You’re nervous. Just take a deep breath,” Ashley said softly. “Try to relax. Focus on how good your pussy and clit feel. Try to enjoy this.” She gave Madison a smile.
Madison smiled. “I like when you say sexual things to me.”
“Oh really?”
“Yeah,” Madison giggled. “It’s weird, but having my sister talk dirty to me is really hot.”
Ashley grinned. “Come on, baby girl. Touch yourself for me,” she gooed. “Play with that beautiful little pussy for your big sister.”
Madison moaned softly. She was rubbing her clit with one hand and pinching a nipple with the other. “Jesus Christ, Ashley,” she whimpered.
Ashley squirted a dollop of lube onto her finger. “I’m just gonna rub this on the outside of your asshole, okay?”
“Okay,” Madison said softly. She had definitely relaxed some, and she was very much into the feelings radiating from her clit.
Slowly, Ashley brought her fingers to her sister’s asshole. In a very gentle, very slow circular motion, she rubbed the lube onto the outside Madison’s asshole.
“Good girl,” Ashley cooed as Madison whimpered and continued masturbating.
“That feels good,” Madison moaned. “I can’t believe you’re touching my asshole. Oh my God.” She sighed loudly.
Ashley giggled softly. “Me neither, honestly.” She continued to rub the outside of Madison’s ass. With her free hand, Ashley slowly caressed Madison’s thigh, rubbing it gently. She watched Madison’s face — her jaw hung open with a distinct look of bliss on Madison’s face. Her eyes were closed. Ashley’s eye moved down Madison’s body, next stopping to watch Madison’s fingers working her nipple. Madison pinched and tugged on her nipple. She teased it, rubbed it, played with it.
Ashley’s eyes continued to move down her sister’s naked body, all the while she was caressing Madison’s thigh and massaging the outside of her asshole. Ashley now looked at Madison’s pussy. It was incredibly wet. Ashley would’ve loved to slide her fingers inside of Madison, or even to wiggle her tongue inside her sister’s pussy, but Ashley realized that there was a good chance she would have the opportunity to do both of those things in the near future. There was no need to rush things.
She watched Madison’s fingers work their magic on her clit. Madison’s hips were bucking ever so slightly as her fingertips moved in small circles. Madison’s toes were curling and uncurling, and her back was arched.
Ashley removed her fingers from the outside of Madison’s asshole and squirted some more lube onto them. She resumed rubbing Madison’s asshole.