“Shut up!” Alyssa said, giving Madison a playful slap on the thigh. Alyssa was bright red now.
“Did she now?” Ashley said, amused. Obviously Ashley was aware that Alyssa was seemingly turned on since Madison had told her everything, but Ashley was playing along as if she was hearing about this for the first time.
Alyssa blushed once again. If it weren’t for the wine, she may have tried to save face. But her inhibitions were gone. After a brief pause, she admitted to enjoying the show. “Okay, yes, I liked it.” She paused for a moment before saying, “it sounded like Brian was really giving it to you.”
“Well, that’s good. It’s only fun if everybody is enjoying it, really,” Ashley grinned. “And yes, Brian was really giving it to me.” Ashley giggled.
“Wait, so do you think it’s hot when Madison can hear you and Brian having sex too?” Alyssa asked. “Since she apparently hears you guys a lot?”
Ashley shrugged. “Well, yeah. It’s a bit weird since she’s my sister and all, obviously. But it’s still hot.” That was a white lie; Ashley loved the fact that her sister specifically could hear her having sex, but now was not the time to admit her overtly incestuous feelings to her sister’s girlfriend.
Alyssa looked amused. “Jesus Ashley. You’re kind of a freak.” She paused before quickly adding, “– in a good way. Like I didn’t know you were so kinky.”
“Really?” Madison asked. “Maybe it’s because I’m used to hearing them and all, but I could always tell my sister was a freak.”
Ashley laughed. “I suppose I am.”
Alyssa took another sip of wine, prompting Madison and Ashley to do the same.
“Do you guys wanna play ‘Truth or Dare’?” Ashley asked after a brief pause. Perhaps it was cliché, but the mood felt right. Or maybe Ashley was just horny. Either way.
“Sure,” Madison said, flashing a small smile.
“I’m down,” Alyssa nodded.
“Sweet. I’ll start,” Ashley said. She paused to think for a moment. “Alyssa — truth or dare?”
“Truth,” Alyssa said. It would be foolish to start with a dare — that makes it too easy for everyone!
“Do you like watching or listening to other people have sex?” Ashley asked.
Alyssa blushed. “You’re asking if I’m a voyeur?”
Ashley nodded. “I wasn’t sure if you were familiar with the term.”
“Well, I do like watching people have sex and whatnot, but I don’t have the opportunity to watch people very often, obviously.”
“Maybe the next time we have a movie night with Brian, he and I will slip away in the middle again,” Ashley said with a wink.
Alyssa grinned and giggled. “I would like that.”
There was a brief pause before Ashley spoke. “Since you were asked, you can go next, Alyssa. And then it’ll be your turn, Madison,” Ashley said.
“Okay,” Alyssa said, shifting around to get more comfortable. “Madison, truth or dare?”
“Truth,” Madison said. She was tapping her fingers on the armrest of the couch in a mix of nervousness and excitement.
“Do you enjoy listening to Brian and your sister have sex?”
Madison blushed hard. “Yes, I do,” she said softly. Her heart was pounding. Did she really just admit to her girlfriend that she was turned on by the sound of Ashley having sex? Madison shifted around anxiously in her seat.
Ashley grinned. “You like listening to me and Brian have sex?” Alyssa didn’t know, but Ashley was teasing Madison. Obviously Madison liked listening — in fact, she liked more than just listening.
“Yes I do. Just — shush,” Madison giggled. Alyssa and Ashley both laughed.
“I don’t blame ya, babe,” Alyssa shrugged. “In fact, I’m a bit jealous you get to hear them going at it every night.”
“Maybe you should sleep over more often,” Madison smirked. “Is it my turn?”
“Mhm,” Ashley nodded.
“Okay. Since you haven’t been asked yet — Ashley, truth or dare?”
Ashley smiled confidently. “Dare.” She had a devilish look in her eye. Madison knew Ashley wanted a juicy dare to start things off.
“Oooh, a dare!” Alyssa said excitedly. She put her hand on Madison’s thigh, stroking her leg softly with her fingertips.
Madison thought for a moment. “I dare you –” she paused. “Ashley, I dare you to flash us your tits.” Madison immediately started giggling.
Alyssa looked at Madison wide-eyed and gasped. “Madison!”
“What? You don’t wanna see Ashley’s tits?”
Alyssa blushed and looked at Ashley. It’s true — Alyssa did want to see Ashley’s boobs.
“Y’all ready?” Ashley said. She was already gripping the bottom of her cami with her hands. Apparently she had no issue with completing the dare.
“You’re actually gonna do it?” Alyssa gasped. There was obvious excitement in her voice, and she was leaning forward towards Ashley as if to be ready to get as good a look as possible.
Ashley shrugged. “I mean, she dared me to do it. A dares a dare, ain’t it?”
“Exactly. So do it,” Madison said. “Let’s see some titties!”
In one swift motion, Ashley pulled her cami up, revealing a lacy red bra. She immediately hooked her fingers underneath her bra and pulled that up too. Alyssa and Madison watched as Ashley’s tits dropped into view. First the left, then the right. They jiggled slightly as they fell out of Ashley’s bra.
“Ho-ly. Shit.” Alyssa said. Her eyes were drinking in the sight of Ashley’s breasts. Madison bit her lip.
“Are they nice?” Ashley said, still holding up her shirt and her bra. She was allowing Madison and Alyssa a good, long look.
“They’re gorgeous,” Alyssa said. The sight of Ashley’s nipples standing erect atop her big, round tits immediately made her wet. She had always wanted to see Ashley’s boobs, and they certainly did not disappoint.
“Agreed,” Madison said. “You’ve got a nice rack, sis.”
“Well, thank you,” Ashley replied with a small smile. She lowered her bra and then her cami back down over her tits. Madison and Alyssa couldn’t help but be disappointed. “Brian certainly seems to enjoy them.”
“How do you mean?” Alyssa asked. She just wanted Ashley to give more details; obviously she knew what Ashley meant.
Ashley knew this, and rewarded Alyssa’s boldness in asking the question. “Oh, he just loves playing with them and sucking on them when we have sex. I have sensitive nipples so I love when he takes them into his mouth and runs his tongue all over them.”
Madison thought that may have been a little too much, but Alyssa was blushing hard and very clearly turned on. Madison wondered if Alyssa was picturing what it would look like for me to be sucking Ashley’s tits as I fucked her. Probably. Madison was thinking about it, after all.
Alyssa nodded. “Yeah, mine are pretty sensitive too,” she looked at Madison and grinned. “I certainly enjoy the attention Madison gives them.”
Both Ashley and Madison giggled.
“My turn. And since I followed through on a relatively big dare, I’m gonna ask both of you at once for my turn,” Ashley said.
Alyssa and Madison both shrugged. “Fair enough.”
“So. Truth or dare?”
Alyssa and Madison looked at each other. “Dare.”
Ashley grinned and said nothing for a second. “You both know what I’m going to dare you to do.”
Both Madison and Alyssa blushed, but they both nodded. Together — with a hint of hesitation of Alyssa — they pulled their shirts and bras up over their tits. Ashley had seen Madison’s plenty, but Ashley knew she’d never actually get tired of seeing her sister’s boobs. This was the first time Ashley got to see Alyssa’s tits though, and while Alyssa’s tits were not as big as Madison’s or Ashley’s, they were just as gorgeous. Alyssa had small, pink nipples, and each of her breasts was a little under a handful.