“Neither of us are mad,” said Jack.
“That’s actually hilarious,” said Logan.
“Jack,” she hissed, “can you stop now?” He was still stroking her slit as it leaked juices.
“Sorry, babe, can’t help it. You got so fucking wet, it’s crazy.”
“This is so embarrassing,” she moaned.
“I mean, it’s not the first time I’ve seen you cum, Kil,” said Logan.
“Feel how wet she is right now,” said Jack.
“Jack?” Killian looked at him, wide-eyed. “Oh,” she gasped, feeling Logan’s finger’s join Jack’s, teasing at her wet hole.
“Shit,” said Logan, grinning at her. “You came fucking hard, didn’t you?”
Killian could feel her cheeks burning as she nodded shyly.
“You’re gonna make a mess on the couch, babe,” said Jack, feeling it leaking down towards her ass as the two boys worked their fingers in her.
“I’m so sorry.” Killian couldn’t believe what had just happened. She wanted to hide under the blanket and pretend this had never happened. And she really wished her pussy would stop dripping cum.
Logan took his hand away from Killian’s pussy. “Fuck, you taste so good too.” He sucked her wetness off his fingers. “I can help clean you up a bit, if you want,” Logan said meaningfully.
Killian was absolutely speechless.
“Go on, Killie,” said Jack. “Spread your legs for Logan.”
“What–Jack?” Killian looked at him, utterly bewildered.
“From what I remember hearing, you really enjoyed him eating you out,” said Jack. “If you don’t want to, you can say no, but you have my permission to say yes.”
“I-I, uh–,” she stammered. “Okay.” Killian had a million questions and no words to ask them. With her eyes still fixed on Jack, she spread her knees. Logan pushed the blanket off her and lay on his stomach between her legs. Jack stopped fingering her to give Logan full access to her pussy. She squirmed as Logan moved her shorts to side and began to play with her. She was so fucking confused. Killian fought back as gasp as Logan’s tongue started to probe her.
“Does that feel good, Killie?” asked Jack softly, as he kissed her neck.
“I-I…” Killian didn’t know what to say. She didn’t know what she was supposed to say.
“You don’t have to pretend to not enjoy it,” Jack murmured. “I’m not gonna be upset.”
Killian looked at Jack hesitantly. It didn’t sound like a trick. He didn’t look irritated at all. He just gave her a sweet, tender look and stroked her hair. Jack slipped his hand under Killian’s shirt and folded the cup of her bra down enough to play with her nipple. It knotted instantly at his touch.
She let out an involuntary moan of pleasure when Logan worked his finger inside her as he tongued her clit rapidly. Her gaze was still on Jack, but he just smiled at her encouragingly. “Just relax and enjoy yourself,” said Jack, obviously able to tell she was trying to minimize the noises she made.
Relax. Killian had no idea how she was supposed to relax. Her boyfriend was holding her and kissing her and telling her to enjoy herself while his stepbrother went down on her. There was nothing normal about that. Relaxing was the last thing on her mind. But as pleasure increased, her anxiety and confusion started to take a back seat.
“Oh my god,” gasped Killian suddenly. Logan had started to slowly stimulate her g-spot with a firm hand while he sucked on her clit. Her back arched as she subconsciously thrust into his hand.
“Did he find the spot?” asked Jack, watching her squirm as Logan pleasured her.
“Mm-hm,” nodded Killian.
“Well, don’t be rude, baby girl. Tell Logan.”
“Oh,” Killian breathed, hesitant to say it aloud. “Oh! Oh my god,” she gasped suddenly, as Logan continued his work. “That feels really good, Logan.” She could feel her juices leaking out around Logan’s finger. Jack rolled her nipple between his fingers as he watched. “Oh, fuck,” Killian whimpered. It was all too much.
“Mm,” Jack watched her longingly, “I can tell you’re about to cum. And so fast, Killie.”
“Y-yes,” she said, between uneven breaths, feeling very flushed. She bit her lip, looking down at Logan. “Fuck, Logan,” Killian breathed. It was so wrong, but Killian was absurdly aroused. “You’re gonna make me cum already.”
He just kept sucking her little clit between his lips until Killian was squirming uncontrollably.
“Fuck,” she panted. “Oh fuck!” Her fingers knotted in his hair and her hips bucked. Jack continued to toy with her hard nipple and Killian mewled in delight. She was overwhelmed with perverted arousal. “I’m gonna cum so fucking hard for you, Logan,” she gasped, though her eyes were locked on Jack.
Killian shuddered violently as her pleasure peaked. The pressure which had built to an insurmountable level finally broke, drowning her in waves of dizzying ecstasy. She closed her eyes. Her breath came in shallow gasps.
She felt lips on hers. Kissing her softly. She could taste herself on them. Her eyes fluttered open as she realized she was kissing Logan. When he pulled away, his lips were replaced by Jack’s. Killian’s head was spinning.
“Have you figured out what’s going on yet?” Jack asked.
“N-no,” Killian shook her head in utter confusion. “I have no idea what’s going on.”
“Logan’s agreed to fuck you in the ass for your first time.”