Love, Lust, and Erin: Pt. 04 by Hamlin,Hamlin

“Wh…what did you do with the little girl that used to beg me for a pony?” He asked.

“She grew up. And, she got super horny. And if you still love her, you’re going to have to be ok with the fact she DOES want her life to be like that which she so eloquently described.”

She snapped her fingers, flicked and tapped at the air, and then held out her left hand. In it, she held a little figure dressed in monastic robes, and said, “This is life choice number one. Celibate, whacking off secretly in the dark, praying to a man in the sky to forgive your animal nature. Every day you’ll be tortured by sounds of two hot, naked girls lezzing off together just down the hall, after they prance around the house cock-teasing you.”

She held up her right hand, which contained the face of Hugh Heffner, “and this is life choice number two,” she explained, “That of an adventurous, liberated playboy with a long line of arm (and bed) candy at his beck and call. Minus the millions of dollars, of course, but with your brains and Erin’s brains, I’m sure that part is inevitable. Hot, horny, sexy girls tend to pull in other hot, sexy, horny girls. They also like to share their toys, because they were taught good values.”

Dave had to agree that she was making a very compelling argument. Or, perhaps his erection was influencing his judgment. Any argument made by a braless brunette rubbing her panty-covered pussy against one’s erection did sound compelling, after all. Even when it was your own daughter. Yes, he was probably going to Hell.

“Now,” she asked, “shall we cut you a tonsure and call you Brother Dave?”

Dave shook his head.

She beamed, “I didn’t think so. Make sure you keep up your exercise. You’re gonna need a strong heart for this ride.”

She winked and hugged him, “I love you, dad.”

“I wub woo huvy.” he mumbled as she crushed his face into her chest.

For the next couple of hours, life returned to a somewhat normal state. Casey cuddled under a blanket with Dave, and they watched something silly. She made them lunch, giving Dave time to stretch. As he was settling back onto the couch, waiting for Casey, a stream of hearts appeared in his Haloes, followed by a kiss from Erin.

“Missing you guys.” came her message.

“Hal, call Erin.” Dave instructed.

He waited, and a moment later Erin appeared in front of him. Rather, a ghost Erin appeared, sporting a pair of jeans, cowboy boots, a cowboy hat, and a denim jacket.

“Howdy, buckaroo.” He jibed.

“Just to show you how in the mood I am for a ride.” She shot back, making him blush.

Casey came into the room, carrying a plate of turkey sandwiches.

“Hal,” Dave said, “include Casey in the call.”

Ghost Erin appeared to Casey, as well.

“How’s your mom?” Casey asked.

“Drunk,” Erin answered, “but what else is new. She’s fine. I have some homework to finish up, but I’ll be over later.”

Casey nodded and waved.

“We just wanted to say hello,” Dave said, “and we miss you. Come back soon.”

Erin blew him a kiss and faded from view.

Casey quickly wolfed down her sandwich and leaned back into the couch.

“God, I can’t wait!” She said suddenly.

Dave raised an eyebrow, mouth full.

“You’re really gonna let me watch you fuck Erin? Really?”

Dave choked on his sandwich. Casey waited, grinning, as he got himself under control.

“Jesus, Casey!” He said, “Not if you kill me, first.”

“Sorry. I’m excited! Can we do it tonight? Please, can we do it tonight?”

“I hadn’t really made any plans…”

“Ok, well, don’t forget about me. Geez, I’m totally horny thinking about it. I’m gonna go…upstairs for a while.”

Dave remained silent.

“You can watch, if you want. Maybe it will make you feel better about it.” She said with an inviting grin.

“I don’t think…”

She raised an eyebrow.

“I’ll stay down here.” He said, “you go do…what you have to do.”

“Ok. If you change your mind, I’ll leave the door open.”

She kissed his cheek and fled the room, ass jiggling delightfully. Dave forgot the rest of his sandwich, and curled up on the couch, pulling the blanket tightly around him. He most certainly was not going to go upstairs and watch his daughter masturbate. Most certainly not. Being coerced into having to do it with Erin’s pussy as the prize was one thing, but he was definitely not going to go upstairs and stand in her doorway like some kind of pervert, and watch her spread her legs and play with her horny pussy until she climaxed, imagining her best friend impaled by her daddy’s hard penis. No. He was not doing that.

Dave stood trembling a few feet from Casey’s door, listening to the hum of a vibrator from within. Casey moaned excitedly as she masturbated. Drawn forward by his raging erection, Dave took a few steps closer.

He thought of Erin’s pussy, slick and hot as she rubbed it along his cock this morning. He thought of her voice, dripping with desire and kink, whispering the filthiest things in his ear, words that made his blood boil. He wanted…he needed to feel it. He needed to be inside her. Her pussy was his drug. To get his fix, he had to let his daughter watch him deflower her best friend.

The sound of Casey’s aroused moans, the hum of the vibrator squishing wetly in and out of her hot, young, teenage cunt, was something he would have to get used to. If he wanted to fuel his addiction, to live his life like a porno, then he would have to adjust his moral compass. Just a peek. A little act of voyeurism. He was adventurous, liberated, not a pervert. Casey wanted this. She wanted her daddy to watch her play with her horny pussy.

Dave pressed his back to the wall just outside the door, heart hammering.

“Ooooh, fuuuck…” Casey hissed, and he knew she’d just cum.

It wasn’t the first time he’d heard it. In Florida, he’d heard her cum in the shower. Erin had made her cum. He’d have to share Erin with his daughter. His daughter liked dirty, kinky things, and she wanted him to share his girlfriend…girlfriend? Was he sharing her girlfriend? It was all so confusing. He couldn’t think straight with his cock aching so badly. He could take it out, right here. Casey couldn’t see. She’d never know he was jerking his cock while he listened to her moan. It would be a sexy secret. He shivered. They could all share a sexy secret.

Moral compass adjusted, he slowly peeked around the corner, and couldn’t look away. Casey was fucking herself slowly with a pink rabbit, plunging the vibrating toy in and out of one of the wettest pussies he’d ever seen. His girl was dripping liberally, coating her toy and her hand with her own sex juice. With her other hand, she mauled her own breasts roughly, pulling and pinching her nipples, her lips pursed tightly together as she beared down against an impending orgasm. God, she was beautiful, like an animal, wild and untamed.

She was a different beauty from Erin, but no less enticing. Some still-functioning part of his mind said that it was because she was his. She was the last piece of another life, a lost love, something that was special and beautiful, but finite. It was something too special for a man to hold onto forever. He could see the love of his youth in her, and maybe, just maybe that was the reason that she and Erin instilled that wild sense of abandon in him, now. They were brave, undaunted about who they were. They were a pair of horny, gorgeous young women, who loved with everything they had, and weren’t the least bit ashamed of the things they enjoyed. That was real freedom.

Leave a Comment