I trailed off. “She didn’t want that?” Katie asked sadly.
“She loved me. She trusted me in a way. But she was wounded. Far too wounded by what happened to her regarding her ex-husband and ex-best friend. I was ready to propose and she knew it was coming. So she broke up with me. She knew it was going to rip my heart out again. She hated herself for it because she loved me so much. But she just couldn’t do it again.”
“Sounds like she needs therapy,” Katie said.
“Perhaps. At least she broke up with me before I actually proposed.”
“Do you still speak to her?” Hannah wondered.
“Sometimes. I don’t want her out of my life. It’s difficult for both of us because those feelings have barely diminished. Now that I’m with my daughters, and soon to be you, Kelly, perhaps that will help me deal with how I still feel about her. That break up was harder than with your mother because I was still in love with her when she ended it. I knew, that same day, she didn’t want to end it. The way she kissed me once we left the pub we were in suggested it. She clung to me, not wanting to let me go. I had to let her go instead…”
“Daddy,” Hannah whimpered, feeling her soft kisses on my cheek.
I had to wipe my eyes and take a deep breath. “It’s okay. Never told anyone that. Not even Bill. I just couldn’t. I just told everyone we split up without giving a reason. After all I’d been through with Claire, I couldn’t deal with the pity and sympathy again. I was thinking about wedding bells and little kids whenever I was with her. At heart, I know she thought the same things, but she just wasn’t ready. If she’s ever ready, then I can only hope the man she’s with treats her like she deserves. She’s the best of us at heart, but her ex-husband and ex-best friend tore her heart out and she’s still carrying it on her heart and soul.”
“You still love her,” Kelly stated, her head still resting against my chest.
“Part of me always will. Like part of me will always love Claire, though that love is because of my daughters. If not for Hannah and Katie, I’d feel nothing for her. Melissa is different. Part of me understands why. In our hearts and our souls, we’re both a little damaged after what happened to us. Let’s be honest, apart from her, I’ve not really looked at settling down with anyone. And now I am where I am today…”
Hannah leaned close to my ear. “I love your big dick in my tight little pussy, Daddy,” she breathed.
“I loved it too, sweetheart.” I turned to look at Katie. “And now I’ll make love with my other daughter tonight.” Squeezing Kelly, “And after that, I’ll make love with you too.”
“Can I call you ‘daddy’?” Kelly asked.
“You can call me anything you want, gorgeous.”
She looked up and I wiped her cheeks with a thumb. “I never had a daddy,” she whispered.
“Then I’ll be yours for as long as you need.”
“Rest of my life?”
“If that’s what you need, I’ll gladly do it.”
Hannah and Katie joined the group hug. It was a rather emotional morning for all of us, or so it seemed. The three girls eventually left me alone for a couple of hours as I wanted to go work out. No surprise I had an audience as I worked the rowing machine before doing some weights. I had a good sweat going by the time I was finished, my three daughters, as that’s how I’d see them going forward, gathered around me. “You’re so fucking hot,” Kelly said.
“Want to join in?” I glanced over the three of them. “If I get a cycle machine and treadmill, it’s something we can do together. I’ve been thinking about it, but I usually use this time for myself. I get my thoughts in order, that sort of thing,”
“Are you sure?” Katie asked, “We wouldn’t want to intrude.”
“I am. It’ll be good fun, keep each other motivated. And I have a feeling you’ll enjoy the show when I’m doing certain things.”
Soft hands immediately moved up and down my arms. “I think we’ll love the show, Daddy,” Hannah whispered in a tone that suggested she was turned on.
I picked her up and carried her over to the weight bench. She giggled as I pulled down her shorts and panties, quickly striping off my sweaty shirt and shorts. I glanced at Katie and Kelly, who sat on the stairs to watch us. Hannah spread her legs and her pussy. “You want this again, Daddy?”
“We’re going to make love then I’ll take the three of you out for lunch.”
“Cum in me, Daddy, then I’ll put on panties and keep your cum in my pussy the entire time.”
“Fucking hell, Hannah!” Katie exclaimed.
Lifting her up, I made her squeal as I lay down instead, resting her on my lap and easily sliding my cock inside her. She figured out how to move rather quickly, her hands resting on my chest, and she was bouncing up and down on my cock rather happily a few seconds later. I glanced across at Katie and Kelly, both of them smiling, looking rather excited. “Love you, Daddy,” Katie called out.
“I want you so much,” Kelly added. I was beginning to understand just how much that young woman seemed to love me.
Returning my focus to Hannah, she rode me as hard as she had earlier that morning, I sat up so I could give those perfect little breasts of hers some attention. She loved that, her hands now around my back, figuring out how to ride me as I suckled at her breasts, kissing her neck before I kissed her properly, sliding my tongue in her mouth.
Her first orgasm tore through her body, feeling her arms tighten around me. “Keep riding me, sweetheart,” I whispered, “I love your tight little pussy.”
She rested her head on my shoulder. “I love you so much, Daddy,” she whimpered.
“I can’t even begin to describe how much I love my daughters, sweetheart,” I whispered back.
She leaned back just enough so I could kiss her, my tongue exploring her mouth once again. I felt her pussy grip my cock like a vice as she enjoyed another orgasm. She had to break the kiss to cry out as she enjoyed herself, whimpering and pleading for me to cum inside her. I easily lifted her up and turned her so she lay on her back, spreading her legs wide so I could start to pump into her. She was now begging me to cum inside her. I’d seen her emotional but this was something else. “Cum in me. Cum in me,” she almost chanted.
“Wow,” Katie whispered. I glanced to see she was sitting next to Kelly, holding hands. “So beautiful.”
Returning my attention to Hannah, I almost started to cry myself at the look on her face and in her eyes. A thousand emotions all at once. I leaned down, kissing her deeply, pulling back just enough so I could caress her face. “I’m close, sweetheart.”
“I want your babies, Daddy.”
“Okay, sweetheart.”
“I want to be… Your… Wife…”
Her orgasm set mine off. Her pussy gripped my cock like never before. I drove as deep as I could before I erupted inside her. After what she said, I was left hoping she’d at least take her usual morning pill. Both of us were breathing heavily, my cock still buried as I met her eyes. She seemed to realise what she’d just said. I calmed her down before she got upset. Cupping her cheek, she moved her head into my palm. “Let’s clean up first, sweetheart. Do you want to talk before or after lunch?”