“Oh God,” I whispered. “I just came, like, twice dude.”
Ashley cocked an eyebrow at me. She came over to me, grabbed my hand, and directed it towards her pussy. I felt.
“Jesus Christ,” I said softly. She was soaked. I know I just had two back to back orgasms, but come on. I guess that’s why she didn’t masturbate. She was just waiting until she could fuck me.
Ashley dropped to her knees and took me into her mouth. She sucked the mix of Madison’s spit and my cum off my cock and then continued to blow me. Once I was hard, she pulled my hand, directing me to lay down. I did as instructed, laying on the ground with my feet towards the shower. Ashley got on top of me and kissed my neck.
“Why are we always doing stuff in the bathroom?” I whispered with a slight laugh.
She laughed too. “I don’t know,” she whispered back. “It’s not like we only do stuff here.”
I chuckled. “I’m assuming we’re supposed to get caught here, right?” I was referring to Madison catching Ashley and I having sex.
“Duh,” Ashley whispered.
She reached back and grabbed my cock, pointing it up towards her pussy. She lined up my cockhead with her vagina and sat back down onto me. I slipped inside of her immediately. Good God was she fucking wet. Ashley braced herself on my chest and began to slide sort of diagonally back & forth and up & down on my cock. Even over the sound of the shower, I could hear the sound of my cock sliding in and out of her cunt. I wasn’t sure if Madison could hear, though. It turns out that didn’t matter though because Ashley made no effort to conceal her moans. She groaned and grunted loudly as she rode my cock. Sure enough, I saw Madison peak her head out from behind the shower curtain and gasp.
“Holy fuck,” I heard her say.
I shot Ashley a look that meant that we had been caught; I wasn’t sure if Ashley could hear. Ashley met my eyes and gave a slight nod. She arched her back and bounced her ass up and down on my cock.
I reached behind Ashley and grabbed her buttcheeks — one with each hand. As she bounced her butt up and down, I spread her buttcheeks wide open, giving Madison a completely unobstructed view of Ashley’s asshole (and her pussy). Madison could see Ashley’s buttcheeks as they bounced up and down. She had a great view of my cock going in and out of Ashley’s pussy, and she could definitely see my balls too. And now she had a perfect view of Ashley’s asshole being spread open as I fucked her cunt.
Ashley squeezed her pussy around my cock as she rode me. I could tell she was trying to make me come; Ashley wanted Madison to see me unload inside her pussy. The situation was hot enough that I had to make an effort to not come. I mean, my girlfriend’s sister was watching us fuck. Ashley must have felt similarly as I immediately felt her pussy begin to throb hard. She was coming! She usually didn’t come from penetration alone, but I guess the fact that Madison was watching us fuck (and could see everything) was enough to get her off with ease.
And that did it for me. The feeling of her pussy throbbing around my cock coaxed my third orgasm of the day right out of me. I began truly emptying my balls inside my girlfriend’s pussy while her sister watched. I curled my toes and gripped the bathmat we were laying on as Ashley’s pussy milked every last drop of cum from my balls.
As my orgasm finished, Ashley shifted herself forward so my cock slipped out of her. She wanted Madison to get a view of my cum dripping out of her cunt. And Madison sure did. My cock was lying across my stomach with a little bit of semen still dripping from the head. I reached back and spread Ashley’s asscheeks open again so Madison could clearly see her asshole. And beneath Ashley’s asshole, Madison could see Ashley’s pussy with a huge load of fresh cum slowly dripping onto my cock and balls.
Once Ashley was content, she rolled off of me and stood up. Madison just looked at her sister with a mix of shock and arousal.
“Holy fuck,” Madison said.
“I bet you didn’t expect to see that,” Ashley grinned.
“Definitely not. That was so fucking hot. Oh my God. You guys just fucked in front of me. Holy shit!”
I was still lying on the ground. “I hope neither of you expect me to be able to get a boner again anytime soon,” I said. Both of the girls laughed. “I think my balls are actually empty.”
Ashley came over and squatted next to me. She rubbed my balls, which had a little bit of the cum from her pussy on them. “Yeah, I reckon so.”
“You can’t actually tell, can you?” Madison asked.
“No, not actually,” Ashley giggled.
Ashley grabbed some tissues and cleaned both of us off before putting her clothes back on. She and I just sat on the floor until Madison finished showering. Sure enough, I did get to see Madison naked again. I got to see those gorgeous tits and her big, round ass. I could see the neat little landing strip above her pussy and the top of her lips too, but I never got a good look at her pussy or asshole. Not yet, at least.