Heath had started working at the department store only a month or two back, but he had fucked or tried to fuck every woman that worked there. Angelica fell into the latter category. He had been hitting on her nonstop, even after learning that she had a boyfriend and that she wasn’t interested. That second part was a lie. Heath was not handsome, but had his cockiness and swagger was immensely attractive to her. She noticed out of the corner of her eye that he’d be staring at her fat bum anytime she walked by, and she’d be lying if she said that she hadn’t occasionally “accidentally” dropped something in front of him and seductively bent down to retrieve it a couple of times. The second time, she was fully aware that she had worn a short shirt and lowrise jeans that day and fully aware that he had seen her ass crack peeking out as she bent. She’d also be lying if she said that she hadn’t imagined that Jason’s dick was Heath’s when she was being fucked from behind and couldn’t see her boyfriend’s face. Had she not been with Jason, she’d probably have fucked him by now. But she was, and Jason was a great boyfriend. She was 21, but had already thought that maybe he was the one. She would never cheat on him, would she?
That was the question she asked herself when she was alone with Heath in a customer’s condo on a delivery. The customer was not present, but had left his apartment unlocked so that they could walk in and deliver the packages. They had left what they brought on the floor and helped themselves to the water bottles the customer had left for whoever had had the misfortune to endure downtown traffic to make the delivery.
“You look great today,” Heath said flirtatiously.
“Ugh, don’t start,” Angelica said, trying to hide how flattered she was, “I told you I have a boyfriend.”
“You do? I forgot, I don’t see him here,” he replied with a smug look that half made her want to smack him, half made her want to drop her panties right there.
“If he worked with us, he’d have kicked your ass by now,” she laughed.
“Maybe,” he chuckled, “or maybe he’d be so intimated by how built I am that he’d cower and run away, leaving you all to me.”
Angelica burst out laughing. Heath was quite thin and Jason definitely would’ve made quick work of him in a fight. The thought was so ridiculous that she couldn’t help it, as much as she didn’t want to satisfy his ego. He took a step towards her, and her eyes met his.
“We can’t,” she said, both of them understanding that if Jason wasn’t in the picture, she’d already be face down on the bed, with her jeans and panties tossed aside on the floor and her ass up.
“We can,” he said slyly, “you just don’t want to.”
“I do,” she admitted, “I just can’t do that to Jason.” She turned to stare out the window, and Heath’s gaze immediately drifted to her juicy, fat ass and thick thighs. An idea came to her head, and she almost said it before quickly deciding otherwise. Heath noticed.
“What?” he asked, intrigued. “What were you just gonna say?”
Angelica blushed. What she had thought was so absurd that even Heath might have scoffed (after obviously obliging).
“D-does it count if you put it in my butt?”
Heath was dumbfounded. He couldn’t believe what he had just heard.
“Uh…” was all he could manage.
“Never mind, I shouldn’t have said it,” Angelica said, blushing. She was mortified. What the hell had gotten into her? She had never given up her bum, even to Jason. He had suggested it once and she shut him down. That was where she… She wanted to fuck Heath, true, but this was just insane. Wasn’t it the same, if not worse? It’d still be Heath’s dick penetrating her, even if it was her ass instead of her pussy.
“Let’s do it,” Heath said after collecting his wits. He was already rock hard, and the sight of his hardness through his pants aroused Angelica like no other. She wanted so badly for him to bend her over the table and fuck her pussy, but to alleviate her guilt and satisfy her desires, she’d let him have her butt.
“Turn around,” he commanded. She did so, and he came up behind her and put her down on her knees on the floor in front of the couch. He pushed her shoulders forward so that she was supporting her upper body on the couch with her elbows. Heath took his pants off and got on his knees, wasting no time unbuttoning Angelica’s jeans and pulling them down to reveal fullback white cotton panties. He grabbed those with both hands and pulled them down too.
Angelica was nervous. The furthest she had ever gone anally was Jason rubbing her asshole with his thumb while he fucked her doggystyle. She had enjoyed that, but taking something up there was a different story entirely. As absurd as it seemed, it took Heath palming an ass cheek and spreading it to take a good look at her brown butthole to notice that she had not even sucked his cock yet. He didn’t mean to just fuck her in the ass right away, right? She got an answer when she felt his saliva on her asshole followed by a thumb rubbing it.
“I’ve wanted your pussy for a long time,” Heath said, “but your asshole is good enough.” With that, his thumb breached her sphincter and disappeared into her rectum.
Angelica gasped and went rigid. Mouth agape, she let out a cry of ecstasy and shock. She tried to crawl forward, but her jeans and panties piled at her knees made it difficult and she was already too close to the couch to move much. Heath’s thumb only went deeper into her bum until it was entirely in.
“Where is my thumb,” he asked as he probed the walls of her poopchute.
“In my ass,” she moaned as her eyes rolled back into her head, “in my ass.”
“What’s going up there soon?” he demanded.
“Your co… your cock is going up there,” Angelica replied. She let out her loudest moan yet. With his other hand, Heath palmed her left ass cheek and spread it.
“I can’t believe your thumb is… in my ass,” Angelica said, “I’ve never had anything up there before.”
“Jason didn’t do this to you, right?” Heath inquired as he gave her left ass cheek a spank that morphed into a squeeze.
“No, he didn’t. He never had my ass.”
“Well, I’m about to.”
He removed his thumb and pulled Angelica’s hair with his other hand. He put his thumb in her mouth, and she sucked it without having to be told. When he was satisfied, he spread her fat ass cheeks apart.
Angelica gasped as Heath’s tongue made contact with her exposed starfish. He licked around, every so often probing her most sacred hole with a push. Angelica’s eyes rolled back in ecstasy. She had no idea how good it could feel to have a tongue on her asshole. She was turned on by the pleasure of the act itself, but also the taboo nature of someone’s tonguing her fartbox as she squirmed. She enjoyed herself so much that she forgot about what this was all leading up to.
Heath pulled his head back and replaced his tongue with his thumb again, rubbing her moist anus with circular motions.