Mattie was back up on her toes and groaning as the butt plug turned inside her anus. Annie continued to rotate the plug but now she had enough of a grip to pull on it. Mattie let out a soft yell as the first ball came free. Annie stared at it with big eyes as she moved it in and out slowly.
“In or out, please,” Mattie said hoarsely.
Annie got a better grip and pulled the second ball out of her friends asshole. She looked at the two balls and groaned. “Yeah, a lot longer than mine but not as heavy.”
Mattie shifted her hips from side to side. “It feels weird with it out.”
Annie giggled. “Now you can clean me up and take mine out.”
Mattie stood up straight and turned around. “I, uh,” she whispered as she slowly squatted down. Her hands went to Annie’s thighs and now it was her turn to take small steps to the side. It was obvious that Mattie knew more about what she was doing than Annie had.
Annie was whimpering and moaning as Mattie used one hand to rub the inside of one thigh as her other hand rubbed the crease between her sex and thigh. When she swapped the hands around, Annie groaned deeply. Suddenly Annie gasped loudly as one of Mattie’s hands turned so she could rub between Annie’s upper thighs. Her other hand was caressing Annie’s mound and outer lips.
As Annie slowly came up on her toes, Mattie took both her hands away from Annie’s sex. She took a deep breath and used both hands to turn Annie around. Her hand pressing on Annie’s spine caused her to lean forward against the wall. She groaned softly as she spread her feet again.
Mattie rubbed her ass and then ran fingers down the deep cleft. As the fingertips bumped over the head of the butt plug, Annie’s hips gave a jerk. “Yours is as sensitive as mine is, uh, was.”
“Take hers out,” I prompted.
Mattie looked around at me and shivered. “What kind of kinky things do you have in mind?”
“What indeed,” I replied with a wink.
“I have my ideas,” Mattie whispered as she reached for the jeweled head Annie’s butt plug.
“Me too,” Annie whispered and then gasped loudly as Mattie’s fingers touched her butt plug and gave it a twist.
Mattie made a soft whimpering sound as she rotated the head back and forth. Annie on the other hand groaned deeply and stuck her ass out more. Mattie twisted the head faster and then pulled. The butt plug popped out of Annie’s ass. Annie gave out with a sharp yell, her hips flexing back and forth sharply.
“Annie are you coming?” I asked quickly.
She shook her head and stopped her hips from moving. “Close, very close,” she whispered breathily.
“Okay, rinse the soap off and clean up the butt plugs,” I said softly.
There were some soft whimpers as they helped each other rinse the soap off. There were several soft groans and moans as they washed each other’s butt plug. Finally, Annie shut the water off.
Mattie opened the shower door. I held out my hand and she looked at it for a second before she handed me Annie’s butt plug. I handed her a towel. She quickly dried her feet and calves. She stepped out of the shower stall to continue to dry off. Annie shivered as she handed me Mattie’s butt plug and took the towel I held out to her.
*****
I was sitting in my chair when they came out of the bathroom. I held a butt plug in each hand. “Who wants to be first to try the other one’s butt plug?” I asked with a smile.
Annie groaned and Mattie shivered. “It, uh, should probably be me,” Mattie whispered. “One ball is easier than two.”
I nodded and looked at Annie. “Get the lube,” I said with a wink. She shivered and opened the top drawer of the bedside table. When she had it out, I looked at Mattie. “Up on the bed on your knees. Spread them wide and put your head on the bed.”
Mattie groaned deeply as she did as she was told. I stood up and handed Annie the metal butt plug. Annie looked at it and then looked at Mattie’s upturned ass. “I, uh, don’t know if I can do this,” she whispered.
“Put lube on it. It should be easier to put it in her than to put in your own ass,” I said softly.
She looked at the plug and then back to Mattie’s ass. She groaned as she opened the bottle of lube. She applied lube to the head of the plug, closed the bottle, and tossed it on the bed. She looked at me quickly and groaned as she moved over behind Mattie and squatted down.
With a grin, I whispered, “Give her asshole a lick or two. That will make the lube work even better.” That last part probably wasn’t true, but….
Annie’s eyes were locked onto Mattie’s asshole. It was flexing in anticipation. Annie whimpered as she thought of how Harry’s tongue felt on her asshole. With a deep groan, she leaned forward and paused with her tongue stuck out. It was an inch shy of Mattie’s asshole.
Mattie wiggled her hips nervously. A moment later, she gasped loudly as Annie’s hot tongue ran back and forth over her anus. Then the tongue was gone and the cold tip of the metal plug was pressed against her asshole. Annie held pressure on the jeweled head as she rotated the plug back and forth.
The plug went partially in and then was squeezed out. Annie kept working it and applied more pressure. Mattie let out a deep moaning sound as the plug suddenly popped into place. It was larger around than her glass one. Annie groaned as she looked at the jeweled head between Mattie’s ass cheeks.
“I, I’ve looked at the plug in my ass in a mirror,” Annie paused and whimpered. “It is so different looking at it directly.”
Mattie wiggled her hips. “The weight of this one feels different. It wobbles more.”
“Wait until you try it with high heels,” Annie whispered as she used a finger to trace the edge of the jeweled head.
“One down and one to go,” I said softly.
Annie looked at me and the glass butt plug in my hand. With a deep groan, she swatted Mattie on the ass. Mattie chuckled as she moved off the side of the bed. “Be careful with those slaps, I might decide I like spankings.”
“Spankings can be sexual or punishment,” I pointed out.
Annie giggled. “I think I’ve said something exactly like that to daddy but so far….” She paused and looked at me out of the corner of her eyes.
“On the bed,” I said with a grin.
Annie groaned as she climbed up on the bed. With her knees spread and her head on the bed, she groaned again. “Talk about showing everything,” she whispered and shivered.
“I had the same thoughts myself with you standing behind me,” Mattie put in.
Looking at Mattie, I prompted, “Lube.”
She looked at me and took the butt plug. “This should be interesting,” she whispered as she retrieved the bottle of lube. She took her time applying the lube to both balls and the shaft in between them.
Annie whimpered and wiggled her ass from side to side. The anticipation was getting to her. Suddenly she gasped and her hips jerked as Mattie’s hot tongue licked her asshole. After that, she groaned as Mattie’s tongue continued to tease her anus.
When Mattie’s tongue probed the tight opening, Annie groaned even louder and deeper. By the time Mattie moved her head back, Annie’s hips had been bobbing up and down as she fucked herself on the hot wet tongue in her asshole. The end of the glass butt plug touching her anus made her hips jerk. It seemed colder than the metal one.