“Shiiiiit,” I said as I pumped rope after rope of cum deep inside her.
“Oh my God,” she exclaimed as her orgasm continued, “I can feel your cum hitting my cervix. It feels amazing.”
Once both of our orgasms subsided, she kissed me and said, “you’re the first to ever cum inside my pussy, I hope you know how special that is.” She continued, “honestly, the feeling of being filled up was so hot… I can’t wait for you to do it again. We definitely can’t wait so long.”
“Well, whenever we can sneak off, I’m your man. I’ll cum in your pussy any day and every day,” I responded.
“Good,” she said, kissing me again, “Now let’s get down to the pond before someone gets suspicious.”
We got dressed and went down the pond to meet up with everyone else. It was a nice long day of fishing, everyone had a lot of fun. Allie, one of Erica’s husband’s assistants at work, came by and joined us. She reminded me a lot of Laura, though not quite as cute. Really nice girl though. She had a rough family life, so Erica and her husband had kind of taken her in. She stayed with them part time, depending on the time of year and her work schedule. Sometimes she’d travel with Erica’s husband during his 6 month rotation away from home, too.
After we ate dinner, Erica said, “Hey, with Allie here, someone will need to sleep on the couch on the basement.” They had a nice little living room type area in the unfinished basement with a couple couches. Since Laura and Kelsey had come down too, that didn’t leave a room for Allie.
“As long as Allie doesn’t mind a toddler and a baby as roommates, she can crash in our room with Sara. I’ll sleep down there,” I volunteered. I crashed on couches during grad school because I commuted and schedules my classes on back to back days, so I’ve never had a problem sleeping on couches.
“Thank you so much!” Allie exclaimed, giving me a hug. “I just can’t sleep on that couch for the life of me.”
Erica set me up nice with sheets and a pillow on the couch. “You really didn’t have to,” she said, “but it was really nice of you. It’s nice and quiet down here, so you should sleep well.” She left me to my devices and went back upstairs. I browsed the internet for awhile and then drifted off to sleep.
I woke up to someone climbing on top of me, covering my mouth. It was so dark, being a basement with just a single nightlight, that I really couldn’t make out who it was for a moment. As my eyes finally adjusted, I could see it was Erica, wearing only a lacy bra and a thong.
Still covering my mouth, she leaned in and whispered in my ear, “don’t say anything, just understand I need this.”
With that, she turned around and slid herself up so her pussy was over my mouth. I knew what my job was at this point. I grabbed her hips and started licking her pussy. As I did so, she leaned over and pulled down my underwear, grabbing my cock and stroking it.
“I just figured out my husband fucking Allie,” she said as she stroked my cock, “I should have seen it coming, but I just didn’t want it to be true. They’ve been fucking ever since she moved in when she was 18. I know I fucked you so its kind of hypocritical, but Allie? Seriously? Anyway, lucky you, you get to be my get-even fuck.” With that, she started sucking my cock as I continued to eat her pussy.
I started focusing on her clit, flicking it and sucking on it.
“Fuuuuuuuck, you can eat a pussy,” she growled, taking my cock out of her mouth momentarily.
It occurred to me, given the situation, she needed more than just sex right now. This needed to be lovemaking, not just fucking.
When she climbed off to switch positions, I said “lay down with me.” The couch was pretty deep, so there was plenty of room for us to lay down together. She laid down facing me, and I kissed her passionately as I pushed the left side of her hair over her ear and put my hand on her head. I kissed her neck as I reached down and caressed one of her breasts.
Then she rolled over so that she was facing away. I put my arm around her, and gently kissed the back of her neck as I grabbed one of her breasts. That caused her to grind her ass back into me, pressing my cock between her ass cheeks.
I continued to caress her breast and kiss her neck until I slowly slid my hand down to play with her clit. As soon as I did, she said in an airy voice, “please, I want you inside me.”
I lifted her leg slightly for better access, and put the head of my cock to her pussy. As I slid it inside of her, I whispered, “I love you” in her ear. I wasn’t lying, I loved her as a family member after all.
“Oh God,” she moaned. I continued to stroke her clit as I slowly pumped in and out. She reached back with her left arm and grabbed the back of my head. She turned her head and pulled me in for a passionate kiss while we spooned.
“Why are you being so good to me?” She asked.
“Because you deserve it,” I said.
She grabbed my hand that was stroking her clit and pulled it back up to her breast, holding it there. I could feel her breathing quicken so I increased my pace.
“I’m gonna to cum, cum with me,” she requested. “I want to feel it inside me.”
“If you want my cum, it’s yours,” I whispered in her ear.
“Fuck,” she said, “I’m cumming. I’m cumming.” She pulled my hand as hard against her breast as she could, and her pussy started throbbing, squeezing my cock. The feeling of her pussy milking my cock sent me over the edge as well, and I thrust as deep inside her as I could and emptied every drop of cum I had in her.
Even after our orgasms subsided, we laid there like that for awhile. I kissed her back and caressed her stomach.
“Wow,” she finally said, “I just came down for some fucking but that was nice.”
“Eh, you needed more than just sex,” I responded, “we can stay like this for awhile if you want.”
“I might take you up on that. What was that about love, by the way?” she asked.
“Well, I mean, I do love you. You’re family, even if it is by marriage, and you’ve always been great to me. Is it the same way I love Sara? No, but that didn’t matter in that moment. You needed to hear those words more than ever.”
“Well, thank you,” she said, grabbing my hand, “it was a nice touch. Oh, and by the way, I am on the pill so no worries about having a niece or nephew that’s secretly your child,” she chuckled.
“Good to know,” I said with a smile.
“So, I have to ask,” she said as she rolled off the couch to get dressed, “how is this affecting you and Sara? Don’t get me wrong, I love what we have going and all, but you are fucking around on her. I mean, I guess I should be pissed for her like I’m pissed at my husband.”
“Funny you should ask,” I said, “we have an arrangement where she’s OK with me sleeping with other women. Since her sex drive tanked when we got married, she decided it was the best solution. Now full disclosure, that was decided after the first time me and you, ya know.”
“Wow,” she said.
“She also doesn’t know about you or Laura. There have been a few other women who she DOES know about, but she said if she wants to know about everyone she’ll ask and I have to be truthful.”