Their eyes lit up when they saw me. “Hey!” They said in unison.
It was the first time I’d seen any of the other seven passengers who were on the boat with us. I was also thinking about how I could’ve avoided this situation if I just hadn’t stared at myself in the mirror a minute ago.
“It’s good to see you.” Mean daughter had an even bigger smile than back on the boat. “It’s good to finally see you.” The other daughter giggled.
I looked down and moved my hands halfway to my crotch before looking back up at them. “How’s it going?”
“Yeah, no need to cover up at this point. There never was a need to cover up. Did your girlfriends dump you for guys wearing clothes?”
“Not likely. Did your parents finally kick you out of the house?”
“No, we ditched them after eating and we’re just wandering around. We’ve been hearing rumors that you never found any clothes. Looks like that was true.”
I clenched my fists at my sides but I knew it was all over for me. “I’m still working on that.”
“You’re lucky we don’t have our phones or we’d be taking pictures.”
“That’s not creepy at all.”
“I don’t think you have room to talk the way your dick is reacting to seeing us.”
I had nothing on her at this point. My erection was roaring back. “It’s because I’m embarrassed, not that I have any interest in y’all.”
“Are you sure?” Mean daughter pulled up her bikini top to expose her breasts to me. My jaw dropped. They were on the smaller side, but they fit her frame well, and I wasn’t expecting it at all. “I feel like you have some interest in me.” She teased. I was fully hard now.
I knew I had to get out of there before someone saw us. I turned to the other daughter. “Don’t be like your sister.” I gave mean daughter a wink and started walking away.
As soon as I turned the corner, I saw Amber quickly approaching. “Hey, sorry, I just wanted to check on you is all. You weren’t gone that long or anything but I just got kind of worried is all.”
“That’s very considerate of you.” We began walking back to the tables together, and I was thankful she didn’t just witness me getting flashed by mean daughter.
“Our drinks just got here. I think I’m finally starting to relax a bit now although of course that’s easy for me to say.”
“It’s not easy for you to say when you’ve shown so much concern for me this entire time. You’ve been going to bat for me nonstop and I appreciate it so much. You couldn’t have tried any harder to prevent this from happening and since then you’ve been trying to make things as easy for me as possible. I’m honestly floored.”
“It’s the least I could do after I didn’t read the instructions. And I know you would do the same for me.”
We sat down at our table. The sun had almost completely set, but of course there were enough lights strewn about to see what you were doing and where you were going. We saw Brooke walking back from a distance empty handed.
“She didn’t buy anything?” Amber couldn’t believe it.
“I think I need a sip of this.” I tasted the cocktail.
“Greetings, here’s your wristband, here’s your wristband.” Brooke then sat down. “Oh, water! My favorite.”
“Why didn’t you get anything?!” Amber raised her voice.
Brooke put her finger in the air as she sipped her water. “Yeah, about that. They don’t take credit card.”
Brooke wasn’t finished but Amber was almost blowing up. “Charge the room!”
“Will you let me finish?” This was the maddest I’d seen them get at each other. “They don’t take credit card, so you can charge to the room, but only if you have a balance. You have to add funds to the room first, like to your wristband. We bought tickets for scuba diving and for dinner with a credit card, but the gift shop doesn’t take credit card.”
“Can you add money to the wristband with a credit card and then buy something at the gift shop?” Amber had slowed down and lowered her voice to deescalate.
“Yes, but the funds won’t show immediately. They said it can take several hours.”
“This is unbelievable.” Amber buried her hands in her face.
I took another sip. “At least my cocktail is delicious.”
“Your cock does look delicious.” Amber tried so hard not to laugh, and I think the mood lightened then.
“I wasn’t trying to set you up. But yeah, I deserved that.” I took another sip. “I want all of us to try to enjoy ourselves for the rest of the day. We’ll have some challenges ahead of us, but we’ve made it this far and we’ll figure it out.”
“Hell yeah!” Brooke put her fist in the air. “Water!” She took another swig.
“Well yeah I’m happy we made it this far but I still feel just as bad for you as before because you’re still the only one completely naked.” Amber hadn’t touched her water yet.
“Amber, I feel fucking horrible for him too and I have all day, but I’m still trying to have a good time. He doesn’t want us to be miserable with him, okay? Try to enjoy yourself.”
“Yes, please.” I nodded in agreement.
“A toast!” Brooke held up her water. “To cocktails and cocks!” Amber and I looked at each other and started cracking up. “To the swimsuit that almost made the journey here!” Amber shook her head with her hands over her face and kept laughing. “To the two bikinis that almost didn’t make the journey here!” Brooke was probably the funniest person I’d ever met; it’s just that so many of her jokes were made in the tensest situations today. But now, I was in the mood for her humor. Brooke paused, and Amber and I raised our glasses. “To the alcohol I’d be drinking if this vacation happened three months from now!” We put our glasses together and sipped from our drinks.
“What a toast.” Amber was finally settling down.
“That was legendary.” I agreed.
Finally, our food arrived. We had a wonderful meal. I didn’t refill my drink and instead got water. We considered ordering more food, but the entrees we got were huge, and we didn’t want to be too stuffed on the ride back. I think the girls were also self-conscious about eating too much food with their stomachs exposed.
“Time for volleyball?” Brooke joked.
“Oh gosh not after that. It’s too dark now anyway.” Amber stretched out her arms over her head.
“The music is still going. Want to dance?” Brooke was about to stand up.
“Oh, that sounds fun actually.” Amber looked at me. “But I won’t leave you here by yourself.”
“He’s invited.”
“Brooke.”
“What?”
“You can’t be serious.”
“Look how dark it is out there. You can barely see what people are wearing. You can’t see any color.”
“But you can still tell they’re wearing something!”
“Barely. And it’s going to keep getting darker. Whatever, we’ll just sit here.”
“You can go find someone to dance with.”
“No.”
“What else can we do while we wait to go back?”
“Order more food. Drink more water. Walk around maybe.”
“Yeah, I don’t know.”
I finished my drink and stood up. “Let’s dance.”
I heard Brooke leap to her feet, but my back was turned as I was already walking out to the open space where people were dancing.
“Yes!!! Thank you!” Brooke immediately caught up to me. “You’re seriously amazing. This is going to be so fun. Look how dark it is.”
Amber came up behind us. “Oh my gosh. Are you sure about this?”
“Did you not just see this stud pound back his drink and get up without us?” Brooke was so excited.
“Just as a warning, I was starting to get some control over my erection, but once we start dancing…”
“Oh, it’s fine!” Brooke was beaming. “What does that say about us if he doesn’t get hard dancing with us?” She looked over at Amber who was still acting a little shy.
We found some open space and just started going for it with the three of us facing each other in a triangle. It was pretty dark at this point, but we could still see as there were lights nearby. I was rock hard in an instant, and I could tell that people nearby could see that I was completely naked. But for the first time, I didn’t care.
They both knew how to move their bodies. I started getting bolder. “I would be rock hard right now even if I was wearing clothes. Y’all are great dancers.” They just smiled at looked at each other. The music was good, while the crowd had thinned out to an extent, there was still a lot of activity on the dance floor which was actually just sand.
Another song came on and people started cheering. It was more like club music than beach music now. Brooke walked up to me and put her hands on my chest. She smiled devilishly. Amber grinned as she got behind me and actually put one of her hands on my butt, the other on my back starting high and working her way down. I smiled and shook my head, speechless.
We danced like that for a while with both of them humping my front and back. My penis rubbed against the front of Brooke’s bikini bottoms and even her stomach getting strings of precum on it which she didn’t wipe off. I took her breasts in my hands through her bikini top and felt up her whole body even reaching around for her ass. I could feel Amber behind me rubbing my ass and back as she pressed her front into me. She shouted at Brooke over the music. “Am I going to get a turn there?”
“Look at you Amber wanting it so bad! I guess I can share.” They switched places and exchanged glances.
“I bet you’d rather me, huh?” I’d never seen Amber acting this way before. Was she flirting with me?
“Shhh.” I raised my index finger to my mouth and winked.
“I heard that!” Brooke was giggling behind me.
“I didn’t say anything.” I grinned.
“Look at you playing both sides. Player!” Brooke shouted.
“It’s going pretty well for me so far.” I winked again at Amber who was smiling.
“I say this ended up being a pretty good day, but maybe that’s just me.” Brooke kept talking to the both of us.
“Well, obviously same for me, but we had it easy.” Amber took a quick glance down at my crotch which I was rubbing against her body.
“It’s definitely ending on a high note.” I was all smiles now. “Now we just have to get back.” The moment I said that, Amber and I both had the same realization and stopped dancing.
“Are y’all good?” Brooke asked.
I turned around. “What time is our boat coming?” We looked out toward the water to see a boat was in fact docked. “That should be ours, right?”
“Let’s hurry.” Amber said.
We got down to the dock, and as we approached, we only saw one person in the boat. It was none other than the boy captain.
“Hi, welcome, please board now so we can depart for the Eastside condos.”
“Are we late?” Amber asked.
“No, I made good time getting here.”
“Where is everyone else?”
“Umm, my phone says no one else is making the return trip besides you three.” Just let me scan your wristbands please.
“You don’t recognize us?” Amber smirked.
“If I don’t scan them, then it’ll say the tickets were unused which we don’t want.”
“How are the other seven people getting home?”
“I’m not sure, but probably by bus as that is much cheaper. Very few people make this roundtrip because scuba diving is expense, and even most who do scuba dive on the way here take a bus on the way back to save money.”
“I’m not sure if that was an option for us.” Brooke grinned at me.
“I guess I did one thing right getting roundtrip tickets on this boat.” Amber said.
“Okay, please watch your step as you board.” The captain motioned with his hand.
“This is perfect! We’re going to make it!” Amber exclaimed.
“Somehow, someway, we did it.” Brooke nodded in agreement.
I didn’t respond as I started to pay more attention to the growing pain in my crotch area, specifically in my balls. I had never before felt so much pain in both balls at once. I kind of winced and wobbled as I walked toward the back of the boat and reclaimed my original seat.
“Are you okay?” Amber sat next to me. This time, Brooke sat across from us.
“Yeah, I’m alright.”
“Say something now before the boat leaves. Do you need to get off?” Brooke laughed at Amber’s last sentence, so I knew she understood the situation as I looked across and made eye contact with her.
“No, no, I’m just feeling some pain.”
“What kind of pain, where?
I had both hands over my balls, but my penis was still exposed.
“Look, my balls are aching. I’m sorry if that’s gross. I’m fine though, let’s just go home.”
“Are you sure that you’re okay?”
“It’s not going to get worse. I just need to settle down and the pain will stop.”
“Have you had this before? Is this just a normal guy thing?”
“Yes, balls just hurt sometimes. You don’t take medicine or do anything about it.”
“At least you can move them around freely.” Brooke got another dig in.
“Alright, we’re departing for the Eastside condos. Please stay seated for the duration of the ride.” The captain sped off into the darkness with a crew of three in tow. Amber put her hand on my leg which I noticed she never did on the first boat ride. I leaned back and put my hands in my lap, but I was still in pain. I looked across at Brooke who had her devilish grin again.
“Amber, remember when you said you’d make it up to him?”