Finally, after a few minutes, Jake sat up. “I don’t know how to thank you two for this. You have no idea how much I needed this. I’ll leave you now and . . .” A moment later, he was gone.
Jennifer eased out of bed and stepped into their bathroom, wet a washcloth, and cleaned herself off. Dan was sitting up on his side of the bed a smirk on his face when she returned.
“What?”
“For someone who was ambivalent about having sex with another man, you sure got into it,” Dan observed.
“Now you’re criticizing me?”
“No, no, of course, not. Just making an observation. I’m glad you seemed to enjoy it. You did enjoy it, didn’t you?”
Jennifer was hesitant to answer. She didn’t want to make too much of it.
“It’s okay,” Dan urged. “You can tell me.”
“Alright. Yes, I enjoyed it. In fact, I enjoyed it more than I probably should have. Jake does know how to use what he has.”
“So, you like his big cock.”
With a shrug, Jennifer said, “It was an experience. I don’t think I’d want to be married to someone like that.”
“Would you do it again?”
“You mean do tonight over?”
“I mean, fuck him again on another day?”
“I don’t know,” Jennifer responded with some annoyance. “Does it really matter?”
“I guess not.”
* * *
The activity awoke Jennifer, and almost before she could focus her eyes, Dan’s face loomed before her. He kissed her on the lips. She could now see he was dressed for work.
“Early meeting, gotta go,” he advised her. “What’s on your agenda today?”
“Think I’ll go to the office. See if I can pick up a client.”
“You might want to talk to Jake,” Dan suggested. “He might be looking to buy a condo. He sold one to move here.”
“Okay. Thanks. I will.”
After she heard her husband leave, Jennifer remained in bed for several more minutes thinking about the previous evening. As big as Jake was, it turned out he wasn’t so big that she had not been able to handle him. She had told Dan afterward that she had enjoyed it more than she should have, but she had really enjoyed it much more than that. She wrestled with her conscience because she thought she should feel guilty about that. But he had all but forced her to have sex with Jake, and she couldn’t help that Jake was good and she enjoyed it.
As they frequently did after bedtime sex, Jennifer and Dan slept naked. Getting out of bed, she went to the closet and picked out a light but opaque robe, slipped it on and tied it, then headed to the kitchen for coffee.
Once she had the coffee brewing, Jennifer was startled by the appearance of Jake. She hadn’t really forgotten that he was staying with them, but neither had it occurred to her that she would encounter him in the kitchen.
“The coffee smells good,” Jake said by way of a greeting.
“It’ll be ready in a few minutes.” She glanced down at herself and saw her nipples distinctly imprinting her robe. She considered attempting a fix but realized that he’d already seen her completely nude, and she could see he’d already noticed.
“Happy to see me?” he asked with a big grin and nodding to her breasts.
“As are you to see me,” she remarked, gesturing with her head to his pronounced bulge in his same black boxer briefs from last night.
He shrugged helplessly. “I can’t forget last night. It was magical. You were spectacular.”
Jennifer wanted to return the compliment, but she also didn’t want to encourage him. “Thanks.”
“I was really surprised by Dan’s invitation.”
The coffee finished brewing, so Jennifer poured them each a cup and set out creamer and sweeteners. As they fixed their cups, she said, “Apparently, he’s had this secret fantasy to see me with another man.”
“I’ve heard of guys who like to see their wife with another man, but I never would have pegged him as that type. I hope he didn’t force you.”
“No, he didn’t. I guess I was a little intrigued by your size.”
“It’s actually more of a curse. I’ve had women refuse me because of it.”
“Yeah, Dan mentioned a girl in college who nearly fainted.”
With a chuckle, Jake said, “And walked out. Young freshman. I wasn’t surprised. I hope it wasn’t too uncomfortable for you, although you seemed to handle it well enough.”
“No. It was no problem.”
Jake smiled. “Any chance we could go again?”
Jennifer frowned. “You would fuck your friend’s wife behind his back?”
“Uh, uh, well, uh, he did give permission,” Jake nervously said.
“That was last night with him here.”
“Uh, uh, I’m, uh, sorry. I guess I misread your, uh . . .”
“Relax. I’m just messing with you,” Jennifer said with a smirk. “But, no, I don’t want to go again, particularly without Dan here.”
“Understood.”
“So, Dan said you might be in the market for a condo?”
The sudden change of subject confused him. “Uh, yeah, probably. You want me out of here?”
“No, no.” Now, Jennifer chuckled. “I’m a real estate agent. If you’re interested in finding a condo, I can help you.”
Obviously relieved, Jake smiled, “Oh, sure. That would be great.”
“Okay. I’ll start keeping an eye out.”
* * *
When Dan arrived home from work, he advised Jennifer that Jake had called to say he had a dinner meeting and would likely be there late. Dan told him to just let himself in if they were already in bed.
Jennifer was mostly glad that she and Dan would have the evening to themselves, but a part of her would have enjoyed Jake’s company. That also guilted her into telling her husband about her encounter with Jake in the kitchen this morning.
“He told me about it and apologized,” Dan informed her. “Said he was just swept up in the moment watching you in your robe. I told him I appreciated him being honest about it.”
Jennifer was impressed. “That was good of him.”
“How did you feel about that?”
“What do you mean?”
“I mean, would you have liked to have done it with him this morning?”
“The bigger question is, how would you have reacted if I had, and you found out?”
“I wouldn’t have liked it happening without me here.”
“I told him I wouldn’t without you here.”
“Yeah, he said you said that.”
“So, if I had been here, you would have?”
Jennifer was becoming concerned about her husband’s seeming obsession with her fucking Jake. “You know, this sudden fixation you have about me and Jake is troubling.”
“It’s not a fixation,” Dan said, defensively. “I really enjoyed watching you last night, and I wouldn’t mind seeing it again.”
“Once wasn’t enough?”
“If it has to be, then it will be. I don’t want you to do anything you don’t want to do.”
“Good. I’m glad we got that settled.” But she didn’t tell him she kind of did want to do it again.
* * *
They sort of heard Jake come in at some point. It was very late, and both Jennifer and Dan went right back to sleep.
In the morning, Dan again left a little earlier than his usual time, but not as early as the day before. Jennifer heard him in the shower and getting ready, but she remained in bed until after he was gone. Groggily, she arose and went into her closet, reaching for no particular robe, donning it, and heading for the kitchen.
To her surprise, the coffee was already brewed, and Jake was pouring two cups dressed again only in gray boxer briefs. He wasn’t initially sporting an erection, but it seemed to start growing when he saw her. His eyes also became wide.
Jennifer finally thought to look down at herself to see that she was wearing a short kimono-type robe that was not completely opaque, but not entirely sheer either. Still, he could obviously determine that she was nude underneath, and that was aided by how loosely she had tied the robe. She fixed the belt.
“No need to dress on my account,” Jake quipped.
“You don’t give up, do you?”
“Do you really want me to?”
She shot him a look of absurdity. “You just can’t help yourself, can you?”
“Not around you. No.”
“You act like you’ve never been around a woman before.” She said it lightheartedly, bending down to lean on the counter. She wasn’t really annoyed with him, but somewhat enjoying the coquetry. And now she was giving him a look down her robe. But she didn’t care. He’d already seen her naked. What was it about this man?
“Not one like you.”
“Does that line really work?”
“It’s not a line.”
“And you’re not expecting me to just give in?”
“Any chance of that happening?”
Jennifer picked up her coffee cup, walked around the counter and very close to him. “Wouldn’t you just love that?” She then lightly backhanded his hard cock, returned to her bedroom, and closed the door.
He was gone by the time she showered, dressed, and returned to the kitchen.
* * *
It both frightened and excited Jennifer that she thought about her little verbal dance with Jake off and on all day. Part of the reason was because she was scoping out condos for him, but she also couldn’t shake the image of him in his underwear, not to mention that big bulge between his legs.
On her way back home, Jennifer’s travels had her passing a little Italian grocery that was known for homemade sauces, meatballs, sausage, and pasta. It was a little out of the way for her to shop at regularly, but their food was excellent, so she stopped in whenever she was nearby. However, she decided to call Dan to see if he knew if Jake would be there for dinner.
“Do you want to make him something special?” Dan asked with mirth in his voice.
“I’m near Russo’s, so I thought I’d pick up something for dinner.”
“That sounds good. I’d get it whether he’s there or not.”
“I am. It’s a question of how much to buy.”
“It won’t go to waste.”
So, she bought enough for three.
And fortunately, Jake arrived around the same time as Dan, and had brought a couple of bottles of expensive wine. Jennifer immediately opened a bottle and poured herself a glass while she started cooking. The men got beers and offered assistance, but she suggested they go outside and relax on the patio. So, they did.
Once seated, Jake said, “So, about the other night.”
“What about it?”
“Was that you or Jennifer?”
“Mostly me. Although, she obviously came around.”
“Came, she did,” he said with a smirk. “Have you two done this before?”
Dan shook his head. “It really wasn’t until I saw the two of you interact that I admitted to her that I had this secret fantasy to see her with someone else.”
With a frown, Jake asked, “But why? I mean, I’m not complaining that I was the chosen one, but why would you want to share that beautiful creature?”